Food was great! Definitely some great pies. It was our first time there so we got a medium pep pizza and a kids meatball, mushrooms, onions! It was DELICIOUS and flavorful! Only gripe is my husband doesn’t eat pork so having an Italian beef option would have been awesome! Nonetheless it was still amazing! It’s a little small inside but it’s quaint! Service is a little slower and the lady we had that day could have been nicer but maybe it was just busy and she was overwhelmed! Anyways we will definitely be going back as it’s now our new fav pizza spot in Omaha! We will also be trying the pastas and apps next time!
We had an awful experience with the Staff, but Deb the owner called and addressed it promptly, so I will give 4 stars for the food and the owner reaching out.
Food was amazing as always. We will be back and hope to be able to give 5 ☆ next time.
Thanks again Deb!
Love their pizzas and soups. The staff at this place is always very friendly and courteous. I would recommend them for any occasion. 5 stars all the way.
I was waiting for my order for pick-up, the lady incharge of the restaurant, told me it was going to be a little bit longer for my order. So I went outside to smoke s few minutes later the lady brought my order out to me and informed me it was free. She said I had waited a long time for my order(I didn't mind at all).
The food was delicious and I was surprised she didn't charge me. I have always loved Sgt. Peffer's food and atmosphere. And now I LOVE THEM EVEN MORE!
We went into this with relatively low expectations, however we'd seen pictures of the food on Yelp and it looked good, so we wanted to try it.
We ordered the cheesy bread, mozzarella sticks, and for our entrees, my husband ordered the Yellow Submarine and I ordered the baked Tortellini with Alfredo sauce... And booooy, let me tell you. Our food was amazing.
The only complaint we had was that we had to ask for our mozzarella sticks to be reheated because they were served to us still cold... However, I think this was just a fluke and not a regular circumstance. They were apologetic and immediately fixed the issue. Once they were thoroughly heated, they tasted incredible.
We enjoy little mom and pop, hole-in-the-wall type restaurants with delicious food, and if you do too, you need to try this place.
Very unassuming exterior but wow! Last night I had my first experience at Sgt Peffers and it did not disappoint!
We order the New Yorker (minus the anchovies because l'm a chicken) and it was everything! The toppings were so delicious and the cheese was perfection. Not to mention the amazing crust...Most definitely homemade!
(Unfortunately, I did not get a photo because we were all so hungry!)
If you haven't put this pizza spot on your list yet, add it!
If you're visiting Omaha, and you're hungry for pizza that tastes homemade, I would highly recommend!
Top notch pizza, yes you will pay more than some others in town BUT it's well worth it so don't get caught up in the $5 pizza trap 😉 if you catch my drift their pasta is very delicious too!!
This place has been a part of my life for a long time...
That Beefy Mushroom soup on Tuesdays with the slice of 5 cheese is the best
The pizza is great but DO NOT ORDER FROM DOOR DASH. If your pizza is destroyed by the delivery driver, Peffers WILL NOT replace the damaged pizza. You'll have to get a weak excuse for a refund from Door Dash directly, we only got $10 back and had to put our pizza back together like a greasy puzzle.
It's been decades since I last ate here, so I took the family out and had a nice evening. The wait to place our order was maybe 15 minutes, which felt long, but food came out relatively quickly. Pizza was good, manicotti was good, and the cheesy loaves was great too. Kids loved it, so we'll definitely be back.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Omaha
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes