Varied selection of whole and single slice pies. Variety is seasonal. Some savory pies, frozen take, and bake selections are available. Order in advance for holidays! Buttermilk chess pie was great. Also tried a slice of quiche, and it was very good. The apple crumble pie with caramel topping is a family favorite for holidays. Small seating area inside. It is located in a fun area of OKC to walk around and visit.
I am a pie connoisseur, and I live in Georgia, which is known for their pecan pies. I have to say this pecan pie is in my top three, and I have had pecan pies all over the south. Definitely try this pie. If you come on the weekdays there isn't much of a wait, on Saturday you will have to wait in line. Also, heat the pie slice for 15 seconds and it will be perfect.
Update: I returned for some more pie. This time I was able to try the bird dog and the peanut butter.
They are stingy with the punch card for slices. In the past two weeks I have purchased a ton of whole pies and a bunch of slices. They only gave me 6 stamps, when I have purchased way more slices than that.
I also bought the turkey pot pie, but haven't baked it yet.
My favorites in ranking order:
#1 Pecan, #2 Banana, #3 tie between the Coconut & Bird Dog, #4 Peanut Butter but only if mixed with the banana pie, #5 French Silk
Have been here several times for single slices of pie, but was recently given a chicken pot pie and a drunken turtle pie as a gift from a friend. The pot pie was exceptional! I could eat it every day. Seriously. The drunken turtle was good, but really missing salt, so I fixed that by sprinkling some flaked salt I had on hand. Very good otherwise. I highly recommend trying out Pie Junkie!
Literally the best pie. My favorite is the peanut butter (warning: it's ALOT of peanut butter, I like getting some vanilla ice cream to cut it.) and my boyfriend's favorite is the drunken turtle. Went 3 times and haven't been disappointed in a single flavor yet.
The pie was good, but I had higher expectations from a bakery that’s exclusively bakes pie. The crest was fantastic, but the filling itself wasn’t nothing to brag about (coconut cream and french silk). The mini chocolate chips on French silk was a bit off as well… ladies up front taking the order were extremely nice and helpful.
Great place to satisfy your Pie craving. Good selection. Limited seating.
Dahlia Pierce-Mitchell
+5
Simply delicious!
I had The quiche pie with the most fluffy eggs ever tipped with cheese that was slightly crispy on top, the crust was wonderfully flaky yet moist.
My son had the S'mores pie and my daughter had
The Apple Pie they were quiet the whole time while eating with their eyes closed.
Lol
We loved every minute!
Pros: prompt service, top notch desserts and good coffee. We really liked it! They also have savory items. Recommend!
Cons: No seating inside. Only one small 2 chair table outside. Would be nice to enjoy the dessert on premise as a nice end of the evening or rest while exploring midtown
I come in a few times a year to get slices of pie and bring them to family out of state. My husband always gets me a slice of pie from here for my birthday, too. The sweet pies are 5/5 but I’m taking off a star due to a recent experience.
I bought a take and bake chicken pot pie, and it was pretty disappointing. Pretty sure the chicken was canned and the veggies were frozen. Gravy was meh. The crust was the best part, but being pie pros that was no surprise. For a pie with such low-quality ingredients, it’s kind of absurd to charge $30. I also learned that whole pies don’t count towards the rewards stamp card. Overall, I definitely don’t recommend the savory pies.
I've never considered myself a pie person - unless it's banana cream - so I was not expecting to fall in love with 3 different flavors! They had so many options and each one was unique and tasted so so great. Next time I'm visiting OKC I'll definitely be back
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Oklahoma City
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes