Dewey's Pizza

I am a picky eater when it comes to pizza, so when my girlfriend and I tried Dewey's Pizza, I was a little hesitant. However, along with the excellent service we had and the quality of the pizzas, I can say that this is one of my new favorite pizza restaurants. I forgot our waitresses name, but that wasn't a problem because there were two others who attended to us as well. I was completely shocked! My girlfriend had the Southwest BBQ Chicken pizza with the Peppercorn Ranch salad while I had the Bronx Bomber pizza. They were so delicious that we had to take leftovers home with us, which tasted just as good. If you are ever bored and want to try a pizza restaurant with great quality, I highly recommend Dewey's Pizza in O'Fallon, IL. There is a large window in which you can see the cooks make pizzas from scratch which is also quite entertaining!

The pizza is really good but the service can be hit or miss. I will say that the service was outstanding this time around and the waitress was very attentive and filled our drinks many times. I have gone other times where they seemed to not care about checking up on you, but maybe those days are behind them. The wait times have always been reasonable on busy nights.

We are in town and were struggling to find a place for dinner that didn't have an hour plus wait. We called Dewey's and they put a table together for us before we arrived. Their customer service was top notch. Very friendly, helpful, and fast. Their pizza was amazing with a nice crust that was flavorful and was a perfect density. Not too thin or too thick. The sauce had a lot of flavor and just the right amount of sweetness. The toppings were well paired and very high quality. Don't expect the small unappealing pepperoni you get from a chain pizza place, expect more of an artisan style pepperoni that compliments the overall pizza. Overall highly recommend.

Dewey's is always AMAZING! Pictured here on the left is the Yukon Cornelius (doesn't appear to be on the menu anymore) and the Socrates Revenge is on the right. The YC was interesting! I think the potatoes needed to be cooked a little longer, or maybe sliced thinner, but I hadn't had potatoes on my pizza until trying this one. I appreciate and love that Dewey's experiments with different ingredients. The Socrates Revenge is my go-to: minced garlic, spinach, black and green olives, onion, and tomato, with mozz, fontina, and feta. Magnifique. And really, you can't go wrong with a classic cheese here either. Dewey's does it best!

I enjoyed a glass of Troublemaker red blend while I waited on my carry out. (I walked over from a nearby hotel.) The staff is friendly and the restaurant is very clean. We got a couple of 11” pizzas and a peppercorn ranch salad. Ingredients seemed fresh in the salad and on top of the vegetable pizza. They have a selection of craft beers as well.

Excellent wait staff! All wait staff helped/assisted/served all tables. The waitress who took our order was helpful, pleasant and made great suggestions. The house salad and pizza were delicious! There are no issues whatsoever with alterations to anything! I wanted the house salad with gorgonzola vs goat cheese and we wanted a half cheese half mushroom and banana pepper pizza and the half pizza options were even offered at half the price! The crust was delicious and the sauce was flavorful. Grated cheese and red pepper flake shakers were on the table for our use. So many pizza and salad (house and full size) options are available.