Farinacci Pizza

I was That guy - I came in at closing time and asked for a large. The folks were friendly, engaging, and best of all the pizza was awesome! Came back the next day for the even larger size - well before closing. I highly recommend this place, they make it all from scratch and you can tell. 5 stars plus!

I hate to give my all time pizza place a three Star. And say it's no longer my favorite. I am not sure what is going on but the pizza was absolutely not the same this evening. I have a gluten intolerance. So when I decide to pop a gluten aid and cheat on my lifestt...its for a treat ...it's always with Farinaccis because they are the best and worth it. However, the pizza is just not the same. The dough and crust was not how it normally is . Almost like cheap dough. Thinner ...mushy.. The sauce was watery. And even the salad wasn't the same. Definitely will not choose the next time I want pizza!

You've Heard about it, it is worthy of the hype. Period. I can deal with the limited hours and basically pickup only. But only taking check or Cash is obnoxious in 2022. It's not Old fashioned it's an impediment to profits.. get a merchant account at Costco and raise the price 3% and watch the business increase. But I got into the weeds. Go get what might be the best Pizza 🍕 in northeast Ohio.

Love Ferinaccis, best pizza hands down! I hadn't been to ferinaccis in Macedonia in a long time because I moved about 20mins away but I was craving some good pizza so I decided to make the drive. I forgot they only accept cash and I ended up being 3 dollars short for my order. The workers were so amazing they told me they would just take the 3 dollars out of their tip jar to pay the remaining amount while I was trying to scrape up some change. Of course I felt bad because that also meant I couldn't t tip them but their faces never changed when they seen me trying to find change to cover the order knowing that I didn't have money to tip them. Seriously such amazing, kind people they deserve my money over any other pizza place because people just don't do kind things like that anymore and their pizza is the top pick for me so I'll make the drive from now on.

Pro tip: CASH ONLY I just moved to the area and I am always looking for a good pizza joint. This place hits the spot. Decor hasn't changed since the 70s but I love that about this place. The menu is on the wall and the tables are clean. We ordered a large three topping pizza, mushroom, green pepper and onion. Very good loaded with toppings. I really like the crust, it's different. I'm sorry, I can't describe it. I'll go back and try it again! The salad is shredded iceberg lettuce with white cheese. Unless you're calling something basic, skip this part. The waitress was fantastic. Very lovely lady. I owe her a better tip (I'll be back, as promised) as we had no idea this was cash only. No signs no notices anywhere. Luckily my friend had a twenty and I had a few singles to help with her tip. Will order again. I'll eat in again.

Traditional Taste and service is the norm at this Family Owned "Pizza Joint". I've enjoyed this Pizza and Salads since the early 1970's, not much has changed here over all these years. Other than the founders retirement and one expansion it's stayed true to itself. Value friendly no frills Great tasting Pizzas, available in 3 sizes, including a family size sheet. The hand pinched sausage is a favorite of mine. While living out of state for over 20 years, I craved the flavor this pizza offered. Whenever I returned to the area this was always my first stop. I'd like to thank the staff for their dedication and friendly ways. Give them a chance to prove why the regulars return time and again.

100% nostalgia visit from 20+ years ago when I lived in Ohio and would walk here with my family for Friday night pizza. Farinacci's did not disappoint. They have maintained the same menu, recipes and atmosphere from over 30 years ago and hope they do for another 30. Worth a trip, even if its just once a year when you return for Thanksgiving.