Pizza was very good and decent size for the price. We had a Stella and it was very good. Lots of greens on top! The booths are very tight for groups larger than four so plan accordingly. Lots of street parking available.
Really enjoyed eating at Newcastle Pizzeria. The pizza was unique, delicious, and looked great. The service was awesome and the atmosphere was cozy and friendly. Can't wait to go back
If you're up for a wonderful surprise go to Newcastle Pizzeria, a hidden gem in Newcastle! The tastes, textures and smells are superb because of the fire roasted oven they use! And everything is made from scratch in their kitchen! Also a plus is you don't feel horrible afterwards like with other pizza!
The team at Newcastle Pizza make a great pie, their wings rock and the ambience is laid back. Love em.
The best pizza!!! Very cozy atmosphere! Good attentive servers. I highly recommend you go!
Excellent pizza and beverage choices, friendly staff, and quick service, would give 10 stars if I could
Food was excellent, though a bit slow, and they forgot to bring our friends pizza out, but it was kept quite warm and they enjoyed it. Great staff, but weren't actually serving outside due to staffing issues, but we sat outside anyways. No to go utensils, so luckily pizza is finger food. Meatballs weren't, but my fingers worked on them to pop into my mouth just fine. My buddy went back to his house to get a portable propane heater, as it was quite cold outside, which made it more comfortable.
Great food we great beer great staff very friendly the Sonoma 2.0 and the sweet chili wings with the Newcastle salad it was amazing I love the atmosphere and the people are so happy
The folks at Newcastle Pizzeria helped us out with a very special family event. They went above and beyond to a accommodate my family (a very large party) for a special get together. They were ready when we got there (they opened early for us ) and the salad, pizza and drinks were all amazing! We’ve been eating there for years and again we were reminded why. Give this great Newcastle pizza restaurant a try. I promise you will not regret it. Thank you all! We will be back!
First time to visit and will definitely be back. The “cheeze” bread for starters followed by the Stella 2.0 pizza was absolutely amazing!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Newcastle
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes