Simply Bagels

Name: Simply Bagels
Address: 1299 McCarter Hwy, Newark, 07104-3757, US
Telephone: +1 973-482-8000
Rating: 3.6

1299 McCarter Hwy, 07104-3757 - Newark

Recommended by Sluurpy: 2021

🏆 #268 of 319 restaurants in Newark

Updated on 31 May 2026

Known for: bakeries

★★★★★ ★★★★★

3.6/5

381 recommendations

Sluurpy Quality Index

PROPRIETARY

Popularity

100/100

Quality

55/100

Data Completeness

56/100

3.6/5

Sluurpometro: 73/100

Sluurpy Score

381 total reviews

TA Trip

3.0/5

4 reviews

G Google

4.2/5

317 reviews

MP Menupix

3.5/5

2 reviews

R Restaurantji

3.8/5

58 reviews

Rating distribution

5★

4★

3★

2★

1★

👍 Recommended by 2 people

Including

Contact Information

📞 Phone: +1 973-482-8000

📍 Address: 1299 McCarter Hwy, Newark

🍽️ Menu - Menu

📷 Photos (9)

+1
more photos

Google Reviews

4.2/5

★★★★★

317 Google reviews

Michael Hoffman

2 months ago

★★★★★ 5/5

Very very good. One of the best bacon egg and cheese bagels I have had in recent memory. Very low key local spot. Nothing fancy but great food. Check it out

Google

Beck

8 months ago

★★★★★ 5/5

Lox and cream cheese bagel. Phenomenal! Everything from the service, to smells, to presentation, to taste. Such a great food experience. I love that you are super close to my hotel and I can walk here. Can't wait to try your sausage veggie dish with rice!

Google

adelin figueroa

10 months ago

★★★★★ 5/5

Ugh this place is sooo delicious! Baked goods are fresh there daily including this croissant used in this sandwich [bacon eggs and cheese on a croissant]. Prices are great but they close at 3pm! Be sure to get there before then!

Google

J

a month ago

★★★★★ 5/5

Nice, classic deli experience, order from them whenever I dont feel like cooking breakfast. Good flavor on potatoes, quick with the sandwiches. If you want a good pit stop on the road or you're close enough to order on grubhub, get some simply bagels!

Google

Edgar Morales

2 months ago

★★★★★ 5/5

Always Good Food by a Friendly Staff.

Google

Josh

3 months ago

★★★★☆ 4/5

Pretty good! Bagels could be chewier, but the staff is nice, the place is clean, and the prices are fair. Cute decor as well.

Google

Justin Adams

9 months ago

★★★★★ 5/5

Glad I found this place for breakfast. Great food...great service. Wished it was open in Sunday...

Google

Roschel Davis

3 years ago

★★★☆☆ 3/5

Was referred to the location, had a poppy seed toasted bagel with walnut cream cheese and butter. very good and home fries, good as well. Not conveniently located on McCarther.

Google

Explore more in Newark

By specialty

Bakeries in Newark

Recommended pages

Help improve this page:

← Back to all restaurants in Newark