Lived here for years. First time ordering a full Stromboli (no peppers, add bacon)
HIGHLY Recommend!! It’s big and full of meat, it’s great. New favorite item on their menu.
DO NOT FORGET TO GET EXTRA RANCH!
Photo doesn’t give it the proper justice
We drive about a 20 minute drive to get the pizza here. This really is one of the best pizza places in town.
A local business loved by her community. They've cranked out pizza pie after pie for the needs of the community for YEARS! If you are in the area visiting, get some takeout, you'll love it.
Staff is always polite and any request I have they honor. We buy pizza and wings all the time but the ravioli and chicken spiedies are amazing.
For the little town of Newark Valley, this place is good. They have a charming, homey atmosphere with good service and a friendly waitstaff. The prices are fair, and most the food is very good. The spaghetti and meatballs is always a solid choice. I loved their sauce. If you stop in be sure to get something they make from scratch. If you are in the area and hungry it is worth a visit.
We got a sheet pizza here for 13.99, was the best tasting pizza I've had in a while. Sauce and cheese remind me of Anielios in Corning. We were more than happy and what a value, great customer service. Price was a sale, I hope this helps price may be different on certain days of week. I'd still pay full price to get the sale it's that good!
Great atmosphere and service!! You get more than you can eat and it's old school Italian!! Absolutely delicious!! We are up from Florida and my In-Laws took us there, if we lived in the area, this restaurant would have my business week!! So, if you live in or around the area, stop in and give them a try!!
Never been. Taking son to mx track down road figured we could try it. One of the best steak subs I ever had. If we come down here again (2 hours from home) will definitely go again!
Surprising restaurant find in Newark Valley, NY. We've drive by Fortunato many times, and finally decided to stop in. The outside looks decent much like many small town Italian restaurants we've encountered. Walking in the door we found a nice dining area and a separate take out area. The menu was surprising as it offered more than your basic little Italian restaurant.
Since it was dinner time, I ordered one of the specials which was spaghetti with sausage and peppers while my wife ordered stuff shells. Both meals were great. The service was excellent and the prices are very good.
Overall I would recommend this place and will try it again.
Chicken in our salads was bone dry.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Newark Valley
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes