Claire-Elizabeth Diamond
+5
Worth the hype. Food was subtle perfection and service was warm and friendly. We sat outside as a group of 4 and it was one of my favourite dinners in NYC. Lasagna, sourdough pasta and the potatoes were show stoppers. Recommend going as a group so you can order a lot and share family style. Will definitely be back.
We lined up at open and were able to get seats at the bar after a less than 2 hour wait (we were given an accurate estimate). The host did a great job facilitating this and made the night very seamless.
The food and drink lived up to the hype. My prosciutto washed cocktail was a very refreshing entry into the evening. The chrysanthemum salad was one of the best salads I’ve had in NYC. My pork steak with beans and dandelion greens is probably a top 10 pork dish in NYC. The meat was cooked perfectly and the overall dish worked really well. The tiramisu was also amazing. A great way to end the meal.
Highly recommend for all looking for innovative Italian food in a great atmosphere.
This place was so so so good. I don’t understand the negative reviews. I’ve had a LOT of Italian food in New York and this is up there with the best. Highly deserving of their star!
Garlic flatbread - perfectly flaky and warm.
Chrysanthemum salad - more of a cheese salad with greens but I’m not complaining. Loved their take on a Caesar.
Lasagna for two - star of the show. I will crave this in my dreams!
It was very hard to get a reservation here. When they open up reservations at exactly 9am they always ran out right away. We were finally able to land one and we were very excited to try this spot out. Sad to say, i think there’s better food places that’s easier to get to. The food wasn’t bad. It was well balance. I would recommend the chrysanthemum salad and the lasagna. The lasagna was very well balanced and fits my flavor profile. The prices were alright it’s not too bad considering NYC. I feel a little indifferent about the service just because i was observing and there was no consistency with the servers. One person was giving exceptional service (ex. Asking if they have any allergies, are they celebrating anything etc) and some were just there to get orders. I would go again to try out the different pasta but other than that it wasn’t as enjoyable as i expected it to be.
Don Angie's totally lives up to the hype! I had been waiting to try the lasagna, and it was definitely fantastic. Crispy on the edges, hearty from the sauce and cheese, and overall so satisfying! We had the chrysanthemum salad and sweet potatoes as well and both were also delicious. The tiramisu was unique and excellent as well!
Don Angie's is a memorable meal! The interiors are clean and cozy and the service is personable, friendly, and attentive too.
Would highly recommend! Don't wait - try getting a reservation now!
Amazing experience!!! This place is awesome! All the staff was attentive and friendly.
We traveled from Arizona on vacation and tried to get a reservation before we left, but no luck. We decided to try to walk up before they opened and we were able to get a reservation.
The food was FANTASTIC! We ordered too much for just the two of us but had to try it all. Would highly recommend Don Angie!!!
Came to Don Angie with my wife on the last night of our honeymoon. The food and service were absolutely amazing. The attention to details their whole staff provides made this a great experience. We will definitely be back as we are constantly day dreaming about that lasagna. Thank you to Don Angie for such a memorable night
Super hard to get a reservation, every time we tried they were gone in minutes. Luckily, we snagged a Sunday reso at 5pm. The food was great, especially the lasagna for two, which we split between three people. The space is well designed and feels like your neighborhood Italian restaurant, with a bit more hipster/cool vibe. Although it felt like the dishes came out slowly, the servers were friendly and very helpful. This place is worth the hype.
The black cocoa tiramisu is absolutely DIVINE!! They could honestly set up another restaurant just for the tiramisu. It had so much layers and texture, from a moist chocolate cake base to a crunchy caramel filling with cream on top. Lasagna was delicious, and the focaccia that came with it was top notch. Worth the hype!
If I could give this restaurant more than a 5-star rating, I absolutely would. The food, atmosphere and service were all beyond fantastic. Totally next level. I wasn’t able to snag a reservation, but my mom and I sat at the bar and had such an amazing experience. Our bartender and server, Daniel, was a superstar. He made our visit to Don Angie even more special and memorable. For food, we started with the Chrysanthemum Salad (best salad I’ve ever eaten), then got the Japanese Sweet Potatoes (words cannot describe how amazing these are) and the Lasagna for Two (beyond superb!!). And for dessert, we had the tiramisu and it is definitely the best I’ve had in the US - hands down. If you’re thinking about coming to this restaurant, don’t just think about it, do it! You will not be sorry. I will without a doubt be back.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in New York City
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes