Croton Reservoir Tavern

Croton Reservoir Tavern, New York City 108 W 40th St - New York City

Now open
American
• Bar
• Pub
• Grill
• Sit down

71/100
Give a rating

What's your favorite Croton Reservoir Tavern's dish?

Ratings and reviews

71
/100
Based on 2193 ratings and reviews
Updated

The menu of Croton Reservoir Tavern suggested by Sluurpy users

Ratings of Croton Reservoir Tavern

TA

Trip
Last update on 27/03/2023
4,0
207 Reviews
Opentable
Opentable
Last update on 05/12/2023
4,0
933 Reviews
Google
Google
Last update on 02/01/2024
4,2
631 Reviews
Foursquare
Foursquare
Last update on 05/12/2023
2,5
227 Reviews
Facebook
Facebook
Last update on 05/12/2023
3,0
135 Reviews

Menu Croton Reservoir Tavern

    • Brownie Sundae
    • Berry Tart
    • Caramel Apple Pie
    • New York Cheesecake
    • Plate of House Made Cookies
  • Cognac / Brandy​
    • Apricot Brandy
    • Delacour Napoleon Brandy
    • Courvoisier Vs
    • Courvoisier VSOP
    • Courvosier XO
  • Port / Sherry/ Dessert Wine​
    • Cockburn – Lbv Anno 2006
    • Cockburn Tawny 10Yr Old
    • Calvados- Daron 5Yr Fine
    • Dry Sac
    • Dubonnet Rouge
  • . . .
  • Browse the menu

Available menus

Reviews

5
Bill Dittrich
+5
Looks like a typical cross town bar but has a great atmosphere and exceptionally well prepared food. Not a big menu but the selections provide for a nice lunch or an excellent dinner. Somebody in the kitchen is chef trained, a surprise in what you might think is just a small bar. Huge liquor selection and knowledgeable bartender.
5
Maria Munoz
+5
My daughter and I were having a pre birthday dinner. The place is lovely. We particularly recommend the Brussels sprouts!!! Delicious.
5
Diana Salmazo
+5
The food is delicious so are the drinks. The waitress was super nice to make sure the soup was vegan. We will be back for sure.
5
R A
+5
Early dinner after an enjoyable matinee. Never been to Croton but a place we wanted to try! Host/waiter greeted us upon entering and seated us quickly. Great service and even more wonderful food!! We will be back when we’re in the ‘hood!!! They also have a nice, long bar with plenty of seats. TVs everywhere. Plus, a downstairs bar (it was closed) but I’m pretty sure they use for private gatherings.
4
Joe M
+4
We came in a Saturday around 7 and the restaurant was just about empty, which made me nervous. However, we were seated at the bar and was met by the nicest bar tender. He provided exceptional service and I wish I could remember his name. The cocktails were good and the food was very good. Next time we are in nyc we will make a point to visit again.
4
Kassim Chaudry
+4
Spirited atmosphere and an energetic vibe. Food was nice with fresh vibrant vegetables. Bartenders were polite, attentive and responsive.
4
Katie S
+4
I've been here a couple of times, and it's hit or miss food wise. Service is usually good, but they are out of things a lot. For example, I went tonight and tried to order the steak sandwich. They were out of steak, crab cakes, pasta primavera and Cobb salads and the menu isn't that big so I ended up with a chicken sandwich that was dry and flavorless. Nice atmosphere, well made drinks but food is just okay.
4
Executive Thrillseeker
+4
Nice place in the craziness of Bryant park! Service here was good. Beer line can use some checking as we had a couple flat lagers in our group...but all in all good place to visit if you’re in the area
5
Joe Lee
+5
Awesome restaurant. Great service, amazing food and the prices are great compared to other upper scale restaurants.
4
Robin
+4
I really enjoyed having lunch here. The burger was excellent it came with a very small salad but the quality of the meat was good and the flavor was very good! I also enjoyed the service and the ambience for just a casual lunch. The nice thing is they don’t push you out to get the next group in there very respectful and courteous to the customers. Overall a really good vibe and a good lunch location I saw some really yummy looking food being served and the bartender is very pleasant as well!!

Timetable

Now Open
Monday:
11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Tuesday:
11:30 AM - 12:00 AM
Wednesday:
11:30 AM - 12:00 AM
Thursday:
11:30 AM - 12:00 AM
Friday:
11:30 AM - 12:00 AM
Saturday:
11:30 AM - 12:00 AM
Sunday:
11:30 AM - 09:00 PM

Book a table with

Opentable
Opentable

Read the reviews on

TA

Trip
Google
Google
Foursquare
Foursquare
Facebook
Facebook

Info

Compare the best restaurants near Croton Reservoir Tavern

bianca Sluurpy rate Google rate Facebook rate
TA

Croton Reservoir Tavern

71 4.2 3 4
Original Location, 74th St, NYC 95 4.7 4.9 4.5
Piccola Cucina Osteria 84 4.6 4.5
Club A Steakhouse 85 4.8 4 4.5
Piccola Cucina 94 4.6 4.9 4.5
Loi Estiatorio 89 4.7 5 4.5
Boucherie Union Square 83 4.6 4.9 5
Pisillo Italian Panini 84 4.7 4 4.5

QR Code Menu

QR Code

Our aggregate rating, “Sluurpometro”, is 71 based on 2193 parameters and reviews

If you need to contact by phone, call the number +1 212-997-6835

MAKE A QUESTION

SUBMIT
1