One of my favorites in NewYork. I make a point of going there every time I visit! Great food!!!! A little better than mama used to make!
We went for the Valentines Day Price Fixe menu and everything was amazingly tasty, cooked perfectly and portioned generously. Nice Greek wine selection as well. The seating is tight so I recommend sitting in the back by the bar if you'd like more room. Only complaint was that we were the first couple there for the 9:00pm seating and the place was empty but they sat us at the worst seat, right in front of the door! Luckily the manger moved us to a much better location but bad move by the hostess.
Pylos was the perfect choice for a large gathering of friends and family! The service was outstanding, shared appetizers wowed everyone, lamb shank won the night, and the desserts left us deeply satisfied. All the reviews I read were right - the best Greek food in Manhattan!
Incredible food. 10/10 would recommend. Ordered several entrees and appetizers and everything was amazing. I would recommend the salmon.
One of my favorite restaurants in NYC and for me certainly the best Greek food in NYC. I’ve been going for more than a decade and it’s still delivers consistently great quality. It is a relaxed and more causal atmosphere with amazingly authentic and sublimely executed dishes. The octopus, lamb chop, the trio of dips, the whole fish, hummus, the halloumi cheese, and the baked pasta are highlights for me. The octopus especially is cooked to perfection. The wine list has a good selection of Greek wines. The service is very personable and attentive.
Delicious authentic Greek food. Loud guests at the restaurant though. Service was great and attentive.
The octopus appetizer came with generous portions and it was easily one of the best executed grilled octopus I've ever had. The grilled whole fish was phenomenal - you could taste the freshness and the love and care that the chef had poured into this humble yet delicious dish. We also got the moussaka, which was hearty and satisfying. Our waitress was knowledgeable, attentive, and sweet. Will definitely come back!
Just as great as always.. authentic food and wines.. not over priced just fresh..
One of my favorite Greek restaurants. The food is simply outstanding. I recommend sharing a bunch of appetizers and skipping the entrées.
Our favorite Greek place in Manhattan. Great at the restaurant or delivery. Artichoke moussaka was 🤤 and can’t beat the lemon potatoes
I've been wanting to visit Pylos for 4 years and I finally got the opportunity last week. We got in at 10 pm on Friday and they still took us in. The food came out super fast, and the servers were very nice. The proteins were excellently cooked. My favorite was the grilled octopus.
If you found my review helpful give it a thumbs up👍 to help others.
Very good food, amazing service.
Lamb chops, lamb shank were great.
Appetizers were also pretty good.
Place is not huge and fills up quick.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in New York City
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes