Review Ny Pie - Nashville

Jamie Page

This place is unassuming, and hardly noticeable, as it sits in an inconspicuous corner of a strip shopping center at Nashville West, but don’t let that deter you. This is truly excellent NY style pizza. We were not expecting it to be nearly this good, and left rather impressed. The crust is perfect, and the toppings are fresh and full of flavor. We will be back soon.

Sierra Rakes

Absolutely delicious pizza, I thought it was a little expensive for some pizza but the portions are well worth it. I got two slices one newyork white pizza (cheese, ricotta garlic, and one garlic chicken white pizza (spinach, chicken, garlic, cheese). My partner got three slices, one grandma's (cheese basil and red sauce), one Greek (olive, tomato, spinach, garlic, feta), and one garlic chicken white pizza. Every slice was so filling and satisfying. I haven't had good pizza like this since I lived in newyork 3 years ago. Definitely coming back. The service was very friendly and we got our food within minutes of sitting down. The atmosphere was calm, yet homey.

Angelica Krischanovich

I am visiting from NYC and came in here very skeptical with my expectations high and I am eating my words and this pizza. It’s delicious. The crust tastes like my local slice. Had a cheese slice, a NY white slice, and a Hawaiian. Perfect amount of chew and crunch. All the powders you want on your slice and refreshing fountain sodas/sweet tea if that’s what you’re into. Glad to have found this place and will definitely be back.

Eliot McElveen

This was one of the top options when searching Maps for pizza. I now know why. Glad we came here because the pizza was delicious. The photos on the interior were cool too. The prices were amazing for the quality of food. Coming back, for sure!

Harvey B

Pizza by the slice! NY White and NY Greek. Two pieces for under $10. Very fast service. Awesome looking ovens. I have to admit that the White was great. I was just trying it because it was different. Glad I did. Yummy. The table condiments were good. Very nice touch to add to the flavors.

Whittney Martinez

Best pizza in Nashville. My family and I go every time we are out that way.

Anna Watson

My dad has loved this place for years and I finally gave it a try and I’m definitely hooked! I love that they serve slices and then reheat them in the ovens - they give that nice crisp to the crust and melty pull to the cheese - chefs kiss for sure. The service here is also great. Everyone working there was so kind and attentive and we unintentionally went right before they were closing. We tried several different pizzas. I really enjoyed the Buffalo chicken and we also had a sriracha chicken I believe that was so so good. We grabbed the last slice so I’m guessing it’s a popular one! Definitely would order that one again. Their inside space is a bit small but appropriate for a pizza place. We love their little outdoor patio, which is great if you have overtired whiny kids who can’t sit still. We did have a bit of a fly/bee issue outside but it’s bound to happen when you’re… outside.

Jonathon Krueck

Great pizzas. But if you order a whole one, expect a very long wait. Just get personal slices instead.

Steve Dunn

Actual NY style pizza (not just a name). I’ve been coming here since the owner (Greg) opened up. They have 2 other shops now. I’m a Pizza Snob. The dough and the sauce make the pizza not the topping. They have the best ingredients. No questions. I still have not found a better pizza in Nashville and I don’t think I will.

Elijah Stanfield

Just moved here and have been trying the highest rated pizza in the Nashville area. Randomly found this place after hitting Costco and so far its #1. The crust is perfect and sauce is fresh and tomatoey, just like you'd want from a NY style pizza. ❤️

Monica Cruz

Made a stop here driving thru Nashville and it was delicious....even to go. The food was delicious. Had a small 10 pizza and it was perfectly cooked. Greek salad was great. If you like pizza and are in the area, it's a must.

tad giddens

I moved here two years ago and I’ve been looking for good pizza this whole time. NY Pie makes great pizza ! the right way ! ! !. I feel very fortunate that I found this place.

Jonathan Moosekian

I had a slice of Grandma’s Pie and a salad and it seriously hit the spot. The guy at the register (a self proclaimed hat collector!) was super friendly and courteous. We will definitely be back!

Magefire87

My two slices tasted amazing. The staff was so cool, and they took care of me and my crew

Naturally Stellar

I grew up in Upstate NY and struggled to find food that reminds me of home, in Nashville. I'm so glad we were all starving one night and happened upon this place. The pizza is delicious and service is always excellent. We're regulars now. If you're from the north and looking for that neighborhood pizza taste, this is it. I highly recommend it.

Gunner Johnson

Had a great time here. When I walked in I was greeted and they took my order immediately. Super friendly staff and I have my slices in less than 5 mins piping hot. Food was great!

Selena

We got an XL NY meat for 25$ .. it was worth every penny.