Good food, good people, a family atmosphere. I highly recommend this place
The best Deep Dish Pizza that you will ever eat, and the Italian Cheesy Bread sticks are Cheesy Goodness. The customer service is always "Service with a smile."
Spending the weekend in Montague and this is the first time ordering from here. It’s hard to find a pizza place that has a taco pizza and a decent one. It was delicious and the Philly and beef dip subs were good as well.
This was our first time here and it was October 22nd. It was decorated yet had a very relaxed atmosphere. The food was delicious and unlike most Pizza places the pizza was not greasy. It was also freshly made. I would definitely recommend. We got 2 Pizzas, a cheese and a pepperoni.
Felt like a went back in time. Definitely an old school pizza place. Meat lovers deep dish was amazing. Also got a pepperoni and a cheese pizza for the kids that were top notch. Wish we had a place like this in Alabama.
Classic as heck. Embrace it and ease your taste buds. This place is gr8. Mom and pop through and through. I had their cheese pizza. A true mark of quality, something simple. Bravo.
Family location that has been here for years.
Someplace that recognizes good pizza takes time to cook!
This evening I ordered a "Chicago deep dish" the gentleman on the other line had to ask the other employee what it was? Which tells me 1)he is a new employee or 2) hadn't been there long for someone to have ordered a deep dish. We ordered a deep dish with sausage, onion and green pepper. I only gave this a 4 star review because the pie was still exceptional! However, had I rated it by a traditional deep dish pie? I'd have rated it a 2, and souly on the flavor. We were given WAY too much cheese. Little to no sauce. We wanted a pie full of sauce, a good amount of cheese and to taste the topping. Again, WAY TOO much cheese. I havent eaten at Papa's and many years. Not a disappointment but please! Make sure employees know what a traditional deep dish expectations should be♡ We will order again regardless
Wanted a great hole in the wall experience, definitely got it, service was great, nice kozzy atmosphere, pizza was good, filling, went deeeep lol you'll enjoy :_)
Excellent food and service since I was a child, I'm 60 now and going back still both dine in and take out , have to try the papa wapa, yum!!
Pizza and Italian bread tasted great. People working were friendly and helpful.
They have an air hockey table for the kids, or adults, to play while you wait.
If you like really great tasting pizza, Italian bread, sandwiches, etc., this is a great place. Ambiance is simple and the same as it has been for years. They seem to do a very good take out biz too. No alcholic beverages served, however I survived just fine!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Montague
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes