Mari H-E
One of my favorite ice cream places in the cities! It’s a good one for vegan ice cream - there are an assortment of vegan flavors that are just as good as the dairy ice cream. Pumphouse also uses local and sustainable ingredients and everything is reasonably priced.
Angela Sadat
Love this place! The flavors are so creative and well made. We love the option to do a fight, so you can try several flavors (it's tough to decide which ones, as so many are amazing). The apple crisp flavor we got a few weeks ago was one of my very favorites; it was perfectly constructed!! Our pup loves the pup cup, as well😁
Prim Ilagan
Pump house creamy is so much fun. You can find a line waiting outside in the summer. The selection is unique and all very good. They have these ice cream flights with 5 small scoops of your choice. My favorite this rotation was the Burnt Butterscotch- this deliciousness reminds me of the sugar coating of crème brûlée. It might not be for everyone but it’s definitely a must try. I think there’s a flavor for everyone here.
There are a couple of benches to sit outside otherwise the tables at the restaurant is free game after they close.
Maryam Kameli
Absolutely amazing ice cream boasting distinctive flavors! The strawberry lemon, and banana were a delight. Anticipating the sour cherry will be another fantastic choice! Eagerly waiting to sample it! The woman behind the counter was super friendly and helpful! The ambiance of the shop truly complimented the unique gustatory experience!
Tammy Demko
This shop never fails me! The ingredients are top quality and local. I have dairy sensitivities and my stomach has never hurt from eating there. Anyone who says anything negative about this creamery probably has dulled tastebuds and a grumpy attitude ;-)
Christina McCleary
Three words. Ice cream flights. They’ve solved the problem of wanting lots of different flavors. 5 flavors for $6 is a great deal. There wasn’t a flavor I didn’t like, and I really enjoyed the sorbet. Plus the staff was friendly. A few seats indoors and benches outside. Perfect treat for a summer night!
Andrea Bartosh
Nice selection of ice cream in a cute community setting. They do split single scoops, which is a huge plus! Tried the strawberry and a raspberry mix. Both were fresh and delicious!
Tim Lang
What can I say? This place has the best tasting and the most creative flavors I’ve ever seen. Very tight space inside the store with little room to maneuver if there are more than four people. With a list of current flavors on the wall, it makes ordering quick and easy. You can sample flavors, order cones or bowls with multiple flavors, as well as buy pints of any flavor they have available. Some of the flavors are seasonal and may not be seen for months at a time but there are always other options. A little pricey but well worth it! There is usually a line any time I’ve been there but everyone seems to be helped quickly. There is a small amount of seating outside that’s shared with other restaurants and animals are welcome. Friendly atmosphere inside and out. Try the mango and Carolina reaper or the speckled milk chocolate and you won’t be disappointed!!
Ryan C. Van Wyk
What a lovely ice cream shop. The owner, Barb, was behind the counter the Saturday evening we stopped in. Great selection of flavors, including some solid vegan flavors. The cinnamon and mint chocolate chip were both delicious. The ice cream was rich and flavorful, without being overly sweet/sugary. Really reasonable prices and everything is locally sourced. Looking forward to visiting again!
Evgeny Bashirov
Love this place! Their ice cream is incredibly delicate and smooth. I also love the portions and pricing, they don’t make me ill with a “super duper scoop fudge Brownie Carmel swirl with Jimmie’s infused with candy cane crunch”— they have solid, subtle, focused flavors that overall have a good balance of mix-in and cream. Always a treat to come here and try their special seasonals.
Ann Marie Zimmermann
By far the best ice cream I have ever had. Cute shop, great customer service too. Love the farm to ice cream and how she uses local berries and local shops baked goods in her ice cream. We are so lucky to have this in our neighborhood!
Lori Carlson
Thank you for having such great non-dairy choices and changing them up from time to time! The coconut palm sugar flavor is heavenly. I just had the fresh strawberry, and it was so good I forgot I was eating non-dairy.
John Kozlik
Annnnnnnnnnnnnnnd yum! This place is really delicious. I tried a few flavors but decided on the buttermilk lemonbar... which is weird because I'm a chocolate guy. But, it was so good!
Michelle Howd
I love this place, such interesting flavors. They try to have a selection of dairy free and sorbets as well as amazingly decadent ice cream. I had to try the Pear & Blue Cheese with Fig swirl. Yep.... Blue Cheese in ice cream.
Verdict : I liked it, both sweet and savory. The pear and blue cheese pair perfectly. I've made a divine chicken salad with this combo and Greek yogurt.
The fig swirl was not overdone, it added just the right amount of sweetness and texture to balance the salty strength of the bigger chunks of blue cheese.
Though it was enjoyable, it will not unseat my favorite Grapefruit Sorbet.
Jennifer Garrison
I was so excited and had been looking forward to visiting here, the flavors we're fun and exciting and that I appreciated. Sadly the ice cream was grainy. I went with my husband and 3 kids and we each a different flavor and all had a very grainy texture...so maybe it's something in their base :(
I was hoping for a smooth creamery texture with the texture if the adds (i.e. the lemon bars) but it had that texture of ice cream that was frozen, then melted then refrozen...oh well :(
Michelle Kurowski
OMG! The best I've cream I have ever had! And to add to it a very cute place with friendly service! 5 starts just aren't enough!!
Raven A Moe
There ice cream is amazing but when there done giving you your ice cream they don't care anymore I would recommend going to get the ice cream but I wouldn't stay plus they never answer there work phone cause they're on there own cell phones the whole time
Deborah Kadlec
Terrific. Homemade ice cream and homemade waffle cones. Great ice cream!
Alisa Tollin
Delicious ice cream. Wish we had found out about this place sooner!
Linda Quimby Batterson
"Out-of-this-world" ice cream! Now my number one favorite! <3
Kay Bee
Never disappoints! Homemade cones - the best w/ incredible ice cream!! Great date place - go to the card/gift shop across the street. You are assured to laugh the WHOLE time!!
T.j. Prall
I recently moved here a few months back and friends that I've made have taken me to their favorite places! I was craving Fall flavors and my friend took me to Pumphouse today. We stumbled upon on several flavors of Fall including Pumpkin and Apple pie! My day was made and I'm being my family the next time they are in town! I love supporting local businesses esp run by 'family'!
Jenny Bridges
Ice cream as wonderful as the staff! 5 starts!! love the fresh banana!
Kathryn White
The mango rhubarb sorbet was EXCELLENT.
Would have taken some home but live in Rochester.
John Zanini
Sea Salt Caramel is my old standby, but like to venture out from time to time. The Door Country Cherry is amazing this year. What makes this place even better is the staff. They are awesome!
And of course, my dog thinks his specialty ice cream is the best.....
Gina Palandri
Barb--- that Vanila Bean with Choc Flakes had such a great Vanila Blast--- loved it. One of the best I have tasted!!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes