I have to say first that my kids and wife love and have an addiction to this place! They will want to go any day any time even right before it closes and beg the people to stay open for them! The employees have great customer service, patient and kind. In nice days it is full of people but always with a good vibe! Their Frozen Custard is super delicious with even a non milk option for me! The toppings are what I think make it awesome! Either way a by and check this joint out its worth it!
Today my friend and I walked in our first time, we were met with an extremely friendly, enthusiastic lady named Dorthey, Latonya who took great care in explaining the self serve style frozen yogurt, pictured above is the strawberry and cappuccino flavors. The dispensersers were very clean and easy to use, Tip the middle lever gives you a mixed combo of the 2 flavors
I was there on a cool autumn day in early October around 5pm. I was the only customer and was told by the sole employee that I was to serve myself at the 4 to 6 dispensing machines in the store. I proceeded to get a study paper bowl and selected some flavor's. The product is very similar in many ways to soft-serve ice cream. They had claims of low/no sugar and fat on some of the frozen yogurt.. but the taste was great. Chocolate, Strawberry Short cake, coconut were some I tried.
Cones would be nice in warmer weather. I think they stock them in summer.
Price was higher than I expected.. $9.96 for a substantial small tub of the goods.
I recommend this place for ice cream and yogurt lovers. You can the decide which is better.
On 1/11/2022 I wanted some yogurt and was told from a friend of mines to try out My OH My on water street! I went on down there and was greeted with this energetic and positive attitude, explained all of the flavors with samples for me to choose from !!!! And I must say I fell in love with the original tart (my favorite) if we have more people that had the great customer service as Latonya did I wouldn’t mind going to some of the other places I use to go to!!! Great place and awesome employee!!!!!
My daughter loves the juicy pearls this place is a wonderland for frozen yogurt. The price is decent they have a very nice area. Very quiet. We love visiting at night when it's not busy and not sunny. If we lived nearby we'll probably be here every other night. The yogurt selection and toppings are awesome. We'll definitely keep coming back.
On Jan 20th, i went to my yo my by myself for frozen custard. ever since i was a kid all i ever ate in desert wise was frozen custard! with my mental health being had frozen custard is the only thing that makes me happy at the moment and when i walked in to my yo my, i felt safe and secured ! especially Latonya, she was very understanding and welcoming and had great customer service! i found my frozen custard home .
Lots of options for toppings, but sometimes the actual selection of froyo flavors can be pretty slim - last time I went, half of the dispensers were turned off. Prices are predictably high, but not terrible.
Good experience for not having frozen yogurt for 5 years
Nice location just south of downtown. Great flavor selections and numerous toppings to choose from. My son and I had a great time.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Milwaukee
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes