This restaurant is amazing! The staff is so friendly, the food is out of this world. My favorite waitress is Patti ��
I have been enjoying Pitch’s and the family’s other locations for MANY years — 30 or more. I have never had poor food or service. Have taken many friends and family members there, and also several of my Broadway play group outings. Never disappointed.
Roe W.
Pitch's is an old-school supper club serving classic Italian dishes plus a nice assortment of meat and seafood options. There's also a full service bar, which makes great dirty martinis. The atmosphere is casual with a rather vintage decor, keeping the focus on the food.
We ordered the Fried Calamari and Mozarella Marinara for starters. The Calamari was nicely breaded and crispy, and the mozarella pieces were large, lightly breaded, soft, and gooey. For dinner, we ordered the
Deep Fried Shrimp, which was a little rubbery, and the Pork Chops Calabrese, which was very tender and flavorful. The side salad was made of a mixture of greens, the coleslaw was nice and crunchy but was lacking in tang, and the hashbrowns were good but very crunchy.
Our waitress was friendly and enjoyed joking around with us, but she was a little slow and seemed distracted. Still, our food came out hot and overall timely.
In an age where new restaurants come and go, this old school gem stands as a testament to the enduring charm of impeccable service and time-honored culinary craftsmanship. If you appreciate a dining experience that harkens back to a golden era, this establishment is a must-visit.
Even though it's in a neighborhood location this is a fantastic hidden gem. Old school atmosphere with amazing food. The cocktails are very reasonably priced too! You absolutely will love this place.
We have become regulars here & love it - the food, drinks, & wonderful people!
Old/Old School Charm: I've been past this place many times and always wondered what exactly it was, as it looks like a dive bar in the front, but then has a huge seating area out back. Stopped in to check it out and teleported back into the past. The staff was friendly, and were surrounded by friendly regulars at the bar. We will probably stop back to try to food at some point. I can't determine if it is an "old school" style establishment or just "old." A little outside repair/refurbishment.
Hadn't been to the restaurant in years. It's almost the same! Excellent service, food and atmosphere. Planning on going back soon.
Pitch's Lounge & Restaurant is one of those old school Italian neighborhood joints that has been around forever. They serve good stiff drinks and they have great ribs and pasta. It has not changed much over the years. When you step inside it is like going back in time but that is part of the appeal. The servers have all worked there for a long time and they are super friendly. They also have a private parking lot with a handicapped accessible entrance in the rear of the building. Definitely worth a visit.
Excellent menu! Good is always good. Thursday free brunch 1 - 3 pm. (Requires bar purchase). Great selection of happy hour drinks. Great atmosphere and friendly servers. Known for their BBQ Ribs - which are delicious! Craft cocktail and beer selection. Doesn't matter if they'er busy, food and drinks arrived without a long wait! Spacious dining room for table service. Can't praise their customer experience enough! YOU WILL HAVE A GREAT TIME DURING LUNCH AND DINNER!
My personal favorite ribs in town. I also love the hash browns, salads, and appetizers. Peter Sciortino's bread is provided on your table before your starters arrive. The ambiance is comforting, with Sinatra playing in the background. Kind of like an old-school supper club. Jimmy is an excellent host. There is free parking in back.
MicheleFelice Bohlmann
+5
Pitch's Restaurant reminds me of a supper club. Great Brandy Old Fashions, BBQ ribs and the hash browns are to die for! I was even presented with a surprise cake because my daughter mentioned it was my birthday. A class act.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Milwaukee
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes