Great food and service. I recommend the reb wine beef braised short ribs. It was so good. Also tried the carbonara and the pasta was perfect and fresh. A little heavy on the bacon but was still great. Calamari was also very good with a light panko breading. Would recommend and will be back.
J
Justine Filapek
Google
a year ago
5.0
Small, rustic location. Very comfortable atmosphere. Casual. Service was excellent and the food delicious. I ordered the Carne pizza. So good. I would have liked it cooked a bit longer to brown the cheese, but that's just a personal preference. I did brown it when reheating the leftovers and it actually brought out the flavor of the caramelized onion more. Don't get me wrong, it was still VERY tasty cooked per their recipe. Others in the group ordered the fettuccine, rib eye, risotto, and one ordered 2 appetizers for her dinner. All agreed the food was excellent.
The only problem you'll run into is parking. It is most challenging as there are no parking lots anywhere so it is all street parking. In a busy area. Free, but you COULD be walking a block, or more, If it's a busy night on North Avenue.
Worth it.
B
Bradford b
Google
a month ago
5.0
Very enjoyable meal. Excellent service. 5 stars. We will be back. Chicken Parmesan. Spaghetti Bolognese. Seafood specials. And dessert! Excellent.
P
Piper Obrien
Google
a year ago
5.0
Great place to go for New Year's Eve! Food excellent. Service great. Atmosphere relaxing. Will be back soon!
H
Heather Rathjen
Google
2 weeks ago
5.0
I have come a few times. Always have had good service and great food. My most recent visit we did the cooking class. Which was a blast! Highly recommend if you can get a group!
Parking can be a little obnoxious but usually a side street will have space!
W
WI GIRL
Google
2 weeks ago
5.0
As always, delicious food, great staff and lovely atmosphere.
M
Mr. B
Google
2 months ago
5.0
Catered our wedding and the food was delicious! Many friends and family came up complimenting the food! The appetizers were perfect; was great having server's walking around with them. The best was the beef short ribs; just melted when you ate it! Everything again was delicious! Chef Michael Feker made us feel like family! He goes above and beyond what's expected making everything feel perfect! My new wife and I will being making IL MITO Trattoria a usual night out for dinner! 100% recommend the catering service you won't be disappointed!
B
Bob Coletti
Google
2 months ago
5.0
One of our favorite Italian restaurants. Il Mito is a Milwaukee Metro gem. The food is always and consistently delicious and the prices are reasonable. The wait staff is friendly, knowledgeable and efficient. This is an easy 'go to' whenever we don't want to cook or want to go out with family and friends.
J
JH JH
Google
3 months ago
5.0
Even though we were unable to go out, my husband and I enjoyed a fabulous dinner at home. The food was fantastic. The calamari was fresh. Just like being at the restaurant. Nice job! Totally exceeded our expectations. Love this restaurant and chef.
J
Jacob Miller
Google
4 months ago
4.0
Food was pretty good, had the risotto, pomodoro, and carne pizza. Ambiance was nice sitting outside although there were a ton of gnats. Our server didn’t get to us right away, but she was great once she got to us.
R
Rachel G
Google
5 months ago
5.0
Hands down the most incredible gem of a restaurant in Milwaukee! Outstanding flavors, menu selections, staff, and atmosphere. My absolute favorite restaurant ever! Every menu item is insanely delicious!
N
Naomi Strusz
Google
6 months ago
5.0
Fettuccini Chicken Carbonara was very good as was the spaghetti Bolognese. Waitress was very kind and patient. Atmosphere was relaxed and fit for a nice date.
L
Lou S
Google
6 months ago
5.0
Excellent food, great gluten-free options (including bread before meal-NEVER have had that offered before!!!), great service! Very much enjoyed our evening there.
K
Kevin Golliher
Google
7 months ago
4.0
This is my favorite Italian restaurant in the Milwaukee area. The food is outstanding. We ordered Bruschetta. I don't like tomatoes but I loved this dish. For dinner I had Scallopini with Spinach and Angel Hair pasta. It was cooked to perfection, the spinach was probably the best I ever had.
The service was very good, but a little over the top. The server was great, but the hostess came over constantly to the point of being annoying.
The atmosphere is nice, nothing too special other than the party / cooking class room, which is great. There was something that sounded like a cell phone ringing numerous times by the desk was loud and bothersome.
I will definitely go here again. And again.
M
Mike Varga
Google
7 months ago
4.0
Nice Italian restaurant in downtown Tosa.
We were able to grab a reservation to ensure we had our table on time and were seated right away.
The staff was fast and efficient and took great care of us.
I got the lasagna which was very very cheese forward. Unfortunately I did not care for this. I like lasagna where the meat flavor is more prominent and the cheese is baked.
My wife got the short ribs with mashed potatoes which were better in my opinion.
I’d definitely come back to try something else though.
T
Tarek ElGammal
Google
11 months ago
5.0
I liked everything they served that day. Appetizer, drinks, and main dish (duck meat with berry sauce is out of this world).
Thanks for the good time and delish food
R
Rob
Google
2 years ago
5.0
Hands down the absolute best Italian food in the area. Yes, I am Italian and it's better than my Nona's. I cannot recommend this place enough. The food, the drinks, the staff, the atmosphere and unmatched.
