Compadres Mexican Restaurant

Mixed feelings with this restaurant. As we park our car, we noticed that it’s packed and we thought “this is a good sign!” It was packed for outdoor eating but the restaurant is very big inside and it was there that it wasn’t as busy. We were seated in a very cold area, we could have asked to be seated elsewhere we just didn’t bother. Our server was very nice and he did check on our table several times. Food wise, here’s my grades starting with the free chips and salsa. The chips were good, the salsa had good taste but just so watery. We did order a queso fundido with chorizo, it was also runny and we didn’t receive any side plates for the queso so we actually made a mess on the table trying to dip our chips. Our main dishes were tasty, but not the greatest. They were edible and that’s a good thing, but there was something missing. The Carne Asada meat seemed low quality, it was too chewy and thin, very rubbery. The Enchiladas with Mole were okay, but an hour after eating and I feel very yucky, too heavy. I had hoped for a better quality because of the reviews I read prior to actually going.

Finally a decent Mexican restaurant in WI, we are from TX and have tried few Mexican places around the Madison area that have failed miserably. After a lot of uncertainty and hesitance we decided to check out this place, however to our surprise the food was pretty decent. We loved the spicy salsa, the queso was a hard pass, however all the entrees were delicious. They do have a lot of options for vegetarians. The price was reasonable especially considering how expensive it is eat out around Madison. We will sure come back.

I’ve been here several times always enjoy the experience. But tonight it was truly a disappointment it was truly a terrible experience. The sides were cut in half and put into one plate even though I was charged for both. Kids meals were ludicrous and literal 1/4 from was was previously served (and sufficient for only a toddler). The guy who was our waiter obviously didn’t want me there or my kids. Asked for a Shirley temple, received iced-tea, then I asked for a sprite and grenadine- was charged for both as it was not worth the argument. Seriously not coming back.

The food and service was great. The chips and salsa were fresh and the Agua de Horchata tasted fresh and homemade. I will definitely be back with my family, everyone was very attentive and the food was very delicious. The only odd thing is there is a shower in the men’s restroom, definitely a first time I’ve seen that in a public restaurant. I would still recommend you check them out.

Great place for lunch. Complimentary fresh chips and salsa. Chips weren't salted. I liked it. I'm huge favourite of Mexican rice and beans. They did not disappoint me in that. I had tilapia from Mexican traditional. Combined taste of the dish was delicious. It wasn't spicy for me so I got the "Spicy spicy", that made the dish perfect for me. Veggie burrito, chicken burrito and veggie fajitas other liked them all. After a long time I had fried ice cream. It tasted good with friend tortilla, whipped cream and chocolate syrup. But the fried ice cream had more oil absorbed into the batter. Overall we all liked it and I will return to this restaurant to try more traditional Mexican food.