Some of the best food my boyfriend and I have ever had. The ribs are phenomenal. Bob and Maryann are wonderful people. Always a great time, but beware you only have to eat here one time and your addicted! Also the byob is a plus! So delicious, highly recommended!
Had a strip steak that was to die for last night. Perfect prime meat, seasoned and charcoal grilled to perfection. It was served with the best broccoli and hash brown potatoes I have ever had. A friend and I were the only guests and we had a lovely time. (My friend had crab cakes which she raved about!) I highly recommend this restaurant. We were too full for desert -- but I hear the strawberry short cake is the best anywhere.
Had our first meal here tonight and will definitely drive back 2 hours for another. The pot roast and bolognese was out of this world. Next time we will definitely order the ribs and rack of lamb. (Must order them when making reservations) see you soon Bob!
What a cozy, little place! Wonderful atmosphere surrounded by delicious home made food. A limited menu, with a few selections that must be pre-ordered. Recommended, the Pot Roast, delicious, tender and flavorful. The rack of Baby Lamp Chops, cooked to perfection. Salmon served with ginger soy sauce and Crab Cakes ala Joe were very tasty. Simple desserts are offered as well. Chocolate cake, New York style Cheesecake and Strawberry Shortcake. All made fresh. Bob, your host, is very friendly. It's like eating at a family members house. In closing, make a reservation well in advance, as the Iron Skillet is only open on weekend nights. Btw, the I.S. is a BYOB kind of place. Enjoy a very unique evening! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I liked it. it was an interesting experience. I felt like I was eating in somebody else's dining Room. Conversation definitely flowed looking at all the interesting Knick knacks that line the Room. Curated over many years. Absolutely a definitely must do me. Definitely recommend call ahead.
Amazing restaurant, everything we had was fantastic. Everyhing is cooked to order in a small kitchen so don't eat here if you're in a rush. It is definitely worth the wait! Reservations a must.
My husband and I just had dinner there .. This was amazing cooking ..I had the pot roast. Delicious.my husband had the ribs. He absolutely love them. Deserts we had all 3.. Just saying .. Amazing hospitly..
Excellent food. It was like eating gourmet food inside an antique shop. Keep the byob policy. I love bringing the local wine
The best home cooking on Long Island. Small menu and everything is cooked to perfection.
Great place!! Mom and pop cook up a home cooked meal that was absolutely delicious. I will be back.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Mattituck
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes