Paulie Anthony Puopolo
+5
If you want authentic Italian, fantastic drinks and to just feel at home then this is the place you want to be! From start to finish the food was amazing! If I can recommend what to start with it's the Silano. The Freshest off Italian meats, cheeses and the eggplant was to die for. As a meal I got the very flavorful lamb skewers and a side of homemade fusilli that I highly recommend upgrading to! To finish the night I strongly suggest getting their version of limoncello called the orangecello as it is delicious! Big congrats to Chef Gino and manager Raff on such great success thus far!
Amazing meal and drinks. I watched 4 different kinds of martinis be made; all perfect, my espresso martini was the best I’ve had! Our delicious meal was topped with complimentary homemade limoncello. Needless to say we were very satisfied with the service, food, and beverages. This is a yes all around. Enjoy!
My husband and I first discovered this restaurant this fall because of Yelp reviews when we were looking for some place different to try. We’ve since been three times, once with friends, and it’s been amazing each time. The atmosphere, the service, the food—it’s all top notch. Elisa has been our server each time and she’s always great. We highly recommend Casa Mia and look forward to our next visit!
Felicia De Cicco Puopolo
+5
Thank you for a great dinner with my forever friends!! Great service, amazing food and the bread pudding was to die for!! �
One of the best dinning experiences in a long time. Start to finish!
Don't wait! Make a reservation today or just stop in, Alberto will find room for you.
Best Italian restaurant hands down!! Used to go all the time but I moved. Hopefully I will stop in soon. Delicious food and great staff!! I always feel like family here!
Absolutely the best spot on the north shore for authentic Italian .. The atmosphere is fantastic, food is delicious, drinks are on point, and in the most picturesque town around on top of it all.. what is there not to love?! Props Raffaele and Gino .. :-)
Had a special birthday celebration here last night ! I have to say, the service was excellent, the atmosphere here is perfect, The food was simply amazing ! Our new special place ! The energy here was inviting making us feel comfortable from the moment we walked through the �. So glad we went, I’m looking forward to our next special occasion so we can go back. Thank you Casa Mia for making his birthday special.
Such a great experience! Fantastic food-- I may have licked my plate clean. Awesome service, they were so nice! And helped us choose a beautiful wine letting us taste it first. Also loved the atmosphere. Will definitely go back again!
Our new favorite local Italian restaurant! Amazing food and very personable service in a relaxed, casual atmosphere.
Had a delicious dinner with my host sons family from Germany last night....two of us had lobster ravioli which was absolutely delicious- someone had the Bolognese and loved it! I'm not sure what the other two had but they were no problems only rave reviews. The spumoni it was delicious- they did run out of milk for the cappuccino or cream if that's what goes in it. Our appetizers were Delish -bruschetta and caprese. Our waitress was so very attentive. We were amazed at her politeness and promptness considering she was nine months pregnant. God bless her and her baby and may she have a healthy and easy delivery.
Joanne Flaherty Norcross
+5
Had an excellent meal!! Food is so fresh and well made. Staff is friendly and helpful. We definitely recommend and will be back!
I love this small family local gem! The food, the service the family....always make you feel at home! I have never been disappointed for walking in their door....It's like going home!!!
Excellent food, service, martini's and the homemade spumoni was the perfect ending to a perfect meal!!!!
Exceptional dining experience. Staff were friendly, attentive and efficient.The Carbonara and pistachio crusted salmon with homemade fussili were amazing! Not in Marblehead very often but well worth the drive.
Authentic Italian food, feel, and hosting. I have been there almost every week since May! I was even there 10 hours after we got back from Italy! It's that good.
First time visitor, will absolutely come back. All three items we ordered were excellent.
We ordered the Octopus Carpaccio, the Alla Mariana and the Porkchop Ripiena.
All were great. The Ripiena especially so! A group walked in just as my order was brought to me - one of them wondered about it, and ordered the same.
My partner did not like the canoli that much. I hoped for a better beer selection (not much of a wine person, though the glass she had she enjoyed).
Very welcoming place. Will be back - and bringing friends along!
The service is excellent and the food in incredible. Always a different specials available. I recommend the stuffed porkchop it's my favorite.
Haven't been to Casa Mia in a long time and glad to be back! Service was great from the minute we walked in the door - thank you Audrey for your great sense of humor and wonderful service along with the rest of the staff! Food was good too! See you soon!
My husband and I had a wonderful dinner at Casa Mia. We were so delighted with the quaint atmosphere, the warm welcoming staff, and the delicious food. Everything was just perfect, and loved the pumpkin ravioli special! The pasta is homemade and truly delicious, and you must try the famous spumoni for dessert! The restaurant was spotless, and they placed tall clear barriers between tables-what a fantastic idea and made us feel very safe! We will definitely be back.
Authentic Italian cuisine. Portions are a good size, the flavors burst in your mouth. The octopus was amazing, just like the calamari, the burrata and everything else we had. I highly recommend this restaurant. Parking may be a bit difficult but it's worth going.
We ordered Casa Mia to celebrate our anniversary during the quarantine. It arrived still warm and was wonderful. The original drop off was missing our cannoli order. About an hour later they delivered extra cannolis, an additional dish and a bottle of wine. Thank you so much for making our anniversary special even if we were not able to come to the restaurant in person!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes