Visiting Key West & craving something familiar , Papa John's was close by, so that got our vote.. we found an extremely friendly staff, impressed at how clean the store was, met an awesome little dog & most importantly, we had one of the best pizzas we've had in a long long time.. don't get me wrong, lots of great restaurants and little desserts places all over Key West, however it was nice to go somewhere predictable & have a reasonably priced meal.
Hadn’t been back here in over 3 years from a bad experience but today it was redeemed Juaquin was very helpful and made delicious pizza. We will be back
I’m the morning manager at Papa John’s. A lot of these reviews are funny to me. Especially since you guys complain about delivery service or service in general. You people are not the only one ordering. There is all of marathon as well. In the mornings we only have one driver and one inside person. At night we barely have two drivers and one inside person. So please be aware of this Before you start writing bad reviews. We are extremely short staffed just like everybody else’s. And if you can’t understand that take your entitlement elsewhere 💯
Haven't had this in 3 years but I can say it's still good pizza. Bought a medium size cheese pizza with no toppings for my sun, pizza was delicious but a little bit pricey $12.00. The store was super busy and packed with cars waiting outside along with delivery drivers, we had to wait around 15 min for pickup carryout. The guy at the front register gave us plates and napkins. The garlic sauce was a great treat and I love how the box has a special place to keep it for not rolling over the pizza.
All the customers seemed to enjoy the pizza and phone was buzzing all the time when we waited .
I was on my way to key west and was craving some papa johns so I put in a pickup order at this location to eat at our hotel. After the order was ready for pickup, I got a call from the location that my order was ready to pick up which was awesome. The pizza was hot and tasted great. They also gave me Parmesan and the dipping sauce was good. I used a coupon so my pizza was only $5. I highly recommend this location, while there are other negative reviews, I am not sure why (posted is a picture of the pizza). If you like the pizza here be sure to like my comment.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Marathon
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes