Gary's Pizza

Pizza was ok with flavor nothing to outstanding their wings were very delicious, good sized and very flavorful definitely you get the most bang for your buck with Gary's if you are hungry or looking to feed a group of friends. It's been a year and I thought I'd update things a little, your pizza has greatly improved flavor was outstanding and portions are still phenomenal definitely try their house pizza, looks like I'll be eating pizza for the next few days 🤣 keep up the good work and I'd definitely recommend Gary's over Pagliai's Pizza at this point and time.

This is our go-to weekly pizza place. A lot of the guys here know me on a first name basis, which is really fun. However, the quality of their food is what really matters. For the money, I've not found pizza in Mankato that I enjoy more than Gary's. The crust is really fresh, and if you're there at the right time, you can seek them bringing just-made dough in to kitchen. There can sometimes be a bit longer of a wait than they tell you, but staffing issues are everywhere these days. I've only been coming to Gary's for about a year and a half, but there's nowhere else I really want to go for hot, fresh pizza.

Ordered 3 pizzas, a loaf of garlic bread and 2 pounds of buffalo wings for our party group and the entire table resoundingly loved it!! Several comments about the quality of the garlic bread. Some preferred the thin crust to the traditional, but thought both were excellent. The BBQ chicken pizza was my favorite with just the right amount of BBQ sauce and plenty of chicken. The bacon cheeseburger pizza had a really fresh flavor going on, probably due to the nice amount of freshly diced tomatoes on it, YUM! The wings were traditional buffalo sauce, and there was no shortage of sauce!! The bone-in variety were really flavorful and not some weird alien size of wing or leg like some places, just normal bone-in wings like pre-covid before the wing shortage. We ordered carry-out style and the guy working the counter was really friendly and fun and not a mindless zombie running a cash register. How refreshing!! The order was ready on time and piping hot. We will definitely be ordering Gary's pizza again! Especially on Sunday when the competition (I'm looking at you Pagliai's) is closed!!! How can you be a "great" pizza place if you are closed on the most important pizza day of the week!!?? No worries... Gary's is open 7 days a week!!

What can I say about a horrible experience. In town for the weekend and decided to order locally - BIG mistake! Ordered a large Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza - pizza was cold and hard, like it had been sitting around before delivery. Ordered shrimp alfredo pasta - jar sauce from a store was better than what we received. Cheese bread was literally bread sprayed with something with cheese on top - cold, hard, and gross. Finally, the cherry dessert pizza. This was cherry pie filling on cardboard. No taste, no flavor, nothing. I don't know how many times I've tried calling to speak to someone and even left my name and number - NO ONE will return a call. Not worth the money! (Only reason for the 1 star is because that's the minimum in order to post - no blanks.)