New favorite seafood spot! steak is good too
Absolutely love this place. Nothing fancy, but the food is excellent. If you are looking for a casual restaurant that serves the freshest seafood around, then look no more.
Don't judge a book by its cover.. I drove past Rick's twice because it's in the back of a little strip mall. The exterior didn't immediately impress and the interior looks like a restaurant has been plopped right in the middle of a working fish monger. It's on the small side, so I'd recommend making a reservation (because it's always busy).
There is a wide selection of seafood, which is always fresh. The bread and flavored olive oil dip you get while deciding on the night's meal is addictive, so pace yourself.
Food has always been tasty and satisfying. The only negative I've experienced so far is their roasted potatoes, which I expected to be crispy, but were on the soft/soggy side. Other than that, I have thoroughly enjoyed my meals at Rick's.
Be prepared to add this restaurant to your favorites list.
Absolutely deliciously fresh seafood. I would say the best around. Great selection of seafood to purchase and they also have a sit down area where you can eat in. I've lived around here for 10 years didn't know they were here. Such a great gem and locally owned. Had the zuppa de pesce, the lobster brisk and fish and chips for the little guy and it was simply delicious! The staff was also friendly and welcoming.
My wife is hooked on this place. For good reason. I've never seen a fish market so clean. And the fish so fresh. Definitely top notch fish! Only the best of the best.
Well above the grades from the markets i am use to from the city.
This place is fantastic! Food was great! Calamari appetizer was beyond phenomenal! The shrimp scampi and salmon entrees were both delicious and the service was exceptional! Such amazing people there! Super friendly and courteous!!! The owner is a fantastic young lady who goes above and beyond for her customers. We will definitely be back! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!!!
Super fresh food and very nice and knowledgeable staff!
Great seafood, very fresh ,great service highly recommend. Great place to get lunch to go cooked shrimp and cocktail sauce best lunch ever.
Michael and Nadia Whiting
+5
Oh my god! The oysters were amazing!!!! This is my new favorite seafood store!! Thank you, Diane for having such a great store and quality products.
This place is my preferable site. Of all restaurants I know I prefere it most. I never miss an opportunity to go to visit this restaurant. when I want to go to a good supper, this place comes straight to my head. outstanding and food and a large list of dishes.well mannered team, and pleasant spirit
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Mahopac
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes