Gotham Bagels
112 E Mifflin St, 53703-2825 - Madison
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2021
#286 of 703 restaurants in Madison
Updated on
American
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
57/100
Data Completeness
56/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
Contact Information
📞
Phone:
+1 608-284-7145
🌐 Website:
http://www.gothambagels.com/index.html
📍
Address:
112 E Mifflin St, Madison
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
736
Google reviews
I’ve never seen such a wide range of bagel sandwich options. I ordered the Brighton Beach, and it was absolutely marvelous! I mean, those layers are just beautiful.
Google
GOTHAM BAGELS #1
Flat out, this is the best place to buy a bagel in South Central Wisconsin...maybe the best in the state! Better yet, it's not just the bagel that's fantastic, the bagel sandwiches, chips, soup, etc, are ALL great!
The people that own and work at Gotham are amazing, too. Overall, incredible value! If you're looking for the best of the best, place an order with Gotham. You'll be happy you did.
Read more
Google
Note to owner of Gotham Bagels. The pandemic is over and you can end the theatre. I love the bagels and at one time the C0vid protocols were needed. But what you are doing is a farce. You’ve got your doors blocked off and force online orders only with window pickup with long wait times. You and your employees work unmasked, ignoring social distances. Yet you continue to make it inconvenient for your loyal customers by not taking walk up orders. Most are complaining and put up with this nonsense because they need their bagel fix. However, I believe that customers vote with their wallets. You can be sure that I’ll never come back.
Read more
Google
LOVE Gotham Bagels! Currently dining inside is not available, but you can order online for window pickup. Loads of awesome bagels and bagel sandwich options. I highly recommend the OMFG one, there's a bit of spice, but it has fried chicken, bacon, overeasy fried egg, cheese, and a pepper aioli. I really like mine on the everything bagel.
Read more
Google
By far the BEST bagels in Madison. Highly, highly recommend their Piled High Pastrami bagel sandwich. It's life changing.
Google
I'm not sure what to write I cant rate the food because I never got any. They randomly have a internet only day because they are busy "boo hoo" then it looks like they will serve me anyway and then say it's cash only. What backwards business thies days only takes cash that's when I cut my losses and just walked away. I hear they have good food oh well not worth the hassle.
Read more
Google
I’ve hear good things about this place, but was very disappointed in it. We waited almost 45 minutes for a sandwich and a bagel. And there were multiple hairs in the sandwich. Not pleased with this at all.
Google
Old fashioned bagle house nearby madison capitol.
If you want to enjoy the diversity of cream cheese, this place would fit to you.
Also very friendly staffs make guest smile.
Google
Explore more in Madison
By cuisine
By specialty
Recommended pages
Help improve this page: