Very friendly and homey feel. Met with the owner about a wedding cake and he was helpful and not pushy like some places.
Update 6/10/17
We had our wedding and the cake was amazing. My wife said she could not have asked for anything better. It was beautiful and delicious. Tom the owner is very pleasant and professional. We are so happy we chose the Pie Shop for our wedding!
Choosing to work with Ye Olde Pie Shoppe was an easy choice! Tom was very accommodating and made sure to go over all the details. Their cakes are all baked from scratch. We did a cake tasting and ended up going with a 3-tier strawberry shortcake with European buttercream. It not only tasted amazing but looked stunning as well! I highly recommend going with Ye Olde Pie Shoppe!
We used Ye Olde Pie Shoppe for our wedding cake nearly a year ago. Tom was pleasant and easy to work with. We opted for a white cake with fresh strawberry filling and european buttercream; it was delicious. The cake was absolutely gorgeous and exactly what I wanted. Highly recommend using Ye Olde Pie Shoppe for any special occasion cake and more.
Eileen did a great job making my Nightmare before Christmas themed groom's cake for my wedding. Not only did the cake come out looking great, but it also tasted great as well. She was also very responsive to my questions during the cake design process. Everyone at my wedding loved the look of the cake and took a lot of photos of it. It really made the wedding reception all the more better and made for a great wedding memory.
The tasting at Ye Olde Pie Shoppe was my absolute favorite part of the wedding planning. I went with my mom and dad, and right away Eileen treated us like gold. She explained everything to us in detail, and then she brought up out the cake and icings. It was so difficult to choose, because everything was delicious. The cake was so delectable and the icings had so many flavors for all different taste palettes. We decided to go with vanilla cake with strawberry mousse with fresh strawberries, and traditional buttercream icing. It was absolutely delicious. We decided to go with a flower waterfall down the front to match our color scheme with different patterns for each tier. We brought our own cake topper, and she made it work for us. I can't wait to go back there for all of our special occasions! This is the best place for a cake in Monmouth county!!
We worked with Ye old Pie Shoppe for our wedding this past September. Tom was a pleasure to work with. I can't say I have ever been to a wedding where I was still talking about the cake two months later! Literally 50 people have gone out of their way to tell us it was the best wedding cake they have ever have. We asked Tom to serve cakes from the back so we could offer a variety and all three (Double Choc, Strawberry shortcake and carrot) flavors were a hit.
Highly recomend
Great experience working with them to design our wedding cake! Cake was beautiful and delicious. Tasting was a really fun activity to do with my husband in the midst of all the craziness of planning.
The bakery was fast and efficient. The cake I ordered was a chocolate cake. It was very nicely decorated and tasted delicious. I liked the fact that they carried candles and some extra things to make the whole ordeal easier.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Little Silver
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes