Old Barn Out Back

Have not been impressed with this place for many years. Come back occasionally hoping for the best, but have yet to be 100% pleased. Overpriced buffet for the amount of items on the buffet. Sides on buffet typically look like they've been sitting way too long. Came in with a decent size party tonight, and no one was pleased. Those that got the buffet were finished eating well before the menu orders were brought to the table. From order to meal delivery was over an hour. The appetizers arrived 2 minutes before the meals. The dinners were disappointing. I personally had grilled chicken with broccoli and baked potato. While a decent size, the chicken was warm the broccoli was cold and the potato was cool and hard. Drink refills were few and infrequent. Staff was more interested in socializing than working. Honestly not worth the time to come here. There are other restaurants in this price point that are far superior. I was hoping that the updates that Old Barn has undergone over the past few years would have improved it, but unfortunately it just doesn't hit the mark.

Thank you to Rachel and all the servers and cooks for making our daughter's wedding a beautiful event. We highly recommend you to all for your outstanding service and food. It was totally a stress free night. Even when we were early arriving after pictures you was able to have the food ready within minutes and it was delicious. And your prices were amazing for the quality of the food!! what a beautiful venue. Thank you again.

Nice atmosphere and the staff was friendly enough. My wife and I got the buffet. Food was rather bland and the selection wasn't huge for the price. The buffet was well attended however and was kept very clean. Unfortunately I think our waitress was busy as it was a certain long wait for drink refills. Would be willing to go back if we're in town but not to make a special trip.

The bathrooms were the cleanest and smelled really nice. The tables were clean and the waitress was really nice. She actually had helped us fund out how much their cups were and we bought some. Our steaks were cooked perfectly, and our side dishes were really nice! The only complaint was the Mac N Cheese. It tasted really bland and plain. It honestly tasted like it had no cheese on it. I couldn't eat it and when I tried to feed it to my son. He hated it as well. He actually spit onto the table.

Wow! Cute little place we decided to stop at on our way to Columbus and we are so happy we did. Best fried chicken I have ever had! Brandy our server was incredibly nice and very attentive. Beautiful atmosphere and very spacious! We will definitely stop through again the next time we find ourselves in Lima!

Went for the prime rib buffet. Prime rib was ok, but it was sliced very thin and put in warmer trays which continued to cook the meat further. May be worth getting a carving station to cut as needed if its going to be sliced so thin. Fried chicken was great. Items were a bit limited for the price, but overall it was fine. Attentive and friendly staff.