Super good pizza!
First time having it tonight & wasn't disappointed. We were took off guard by the "abnormal crunch" the crust had - Personal preference is a more doughy crust - but hey that doesn't mean it's a bad thing!
Got to chat breifly with the owner (I assume) and he's pretty rad. Check this place out and see for yourself!
Beautiful crust, delicious sauce and cheese. They have been around for ever and they are the only place (expanded to multiple locations now) that puts cheese on top after the pie comes out of the oven. Unique in the land of cookie cutter pizza.
I love this pizza. It's unique, and nothing like the local shops. The crust is crispy and thinnish, but almost like Sicilian. Make sure your first time is in the shop. It doesn't travel well.
I love the food they are nice employees. and the is better house pizza and pizza Hut and couple more places. I glad they're are there good good place and severe good food . Clean table . 😃😍😍😍 this is my first time have a good pizza in Lancaster .thank you everyone I appreciate all the hard make a decision pizza . God bless you and your family
I'm so grateful DiCarlo's opened! Lancaster needed a great pizza shop like this. The location is perfect & the service is excellent-- very friendly and welcoming. If I could give it 5 more stars, I would.
It's the best pizza. Get it with the cold cheese, the original way. This pizza is phenomenal. The staff is great too, but nothing compares to the pizza. Best in Lancaster.
If I could give more then five stars , I would. I ate here a couple of days ago and it was just completely delicious. The people here are kind and I would totally recommend this place to any pizza lovers!.
Carol Ann Higgins Cajigas (Carol Ann)
+5
Heading there today! Just found this online. As an avid DiCarlo's Pizza fan from Wheeling, WV, I am eager to try the Lancaster version. I'm so excited!!!! My mouth is already watering. More later to let you know how this compares to the original.
The pizza is excellent, not greasy like some pizza shops. I work close by so I call ahead for take out and I never had to wait more than a few minutes for it to be ready, friendly service!
Sophornara “Sope” Prak
+5
Great Pizza!! A must try with the unmelted provolone cheese!!!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Lancaster
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes