Island Cream Co in Lahaina, Maui is an absolute gem! From the moment I stepped in, I was greeted with warm hospitality and a vibrant island atmosphere. The ice cream selection is beyond delightful, offering an array of unique and mouthwatering flavors that perfectly capture the essence of Maui. The quality and freshness of their ingredients are evident in every scoop, making it a delightful treat for the taste buds. The friendly staff added to the overall positive experience, and I can’t wait to return for more tropical delights. Highly recommended for anyone visiting Maui!
Best ice cream I've had. It's not gelato or ice cream but their own recipe called island cream. Flavors are all made fresh in store I heard and from real ingredients. Great range of flavors from the must have comfort food flavors to the asian fusion ice cream flavors. Oh! They also have shaved ice which hits the spot.
Absolutely scrumptious! Wish we'd known about this place earlier in our trip or we would have come multiple times. Generous portions, tons of flavors, decently priced, would highly recommend it. They provide the shave ice and you choose your own flavors from their flavor bar which is fun. The ice cream is also excellent, I got a mini scoop of passionfruit cheesecake at the bottom of my shave ice and that was amazing. Definitely try this spot
The best ice cream in Maui. Well it's technically not ice cream... ITS HYBRID GELATO! Great shaved ice too. There was also an interesting bird...
So many unique flavors. As advertised, a mix between gelato and ice cream. The shaved ice station has every flavor imaginable. The pineapple cream is far better than the Dole whip.
The cutest ice cream and shaved ice shop. Would definitely recommend! They had a HUGE variety of impressive flavors of ice cream and shaved ice! Our group really enjoyed the cinnamon waffle cone as well!
Very friendly staff. Mika was more than happy to answer all of our questions and even put the babies sorbet in the freezer until we were ready to leave. We can try as many samples as we wanted. The coconut taro ice cream was just sweet enough that it hit the spot. The choco macadamia nut was also good and the cookies and cream had big chunks of cookies
Probably the best cream we’ve had. We came back everyday of the vacation after we found it. It is crave-ably tasty, doesn’t leave you feeling heavy or gross afterwards, and has a wonderful selection of flavors. I kept getting lillikoi cheesecake though! Please open these on the mainland!
If this isn’t the best ice cream on the planet. My goodness. It was so delicious!! There were so many options. The kids loved it. The manager was so sweet and kind. She showed my children how to make waffle cones. She really showed hospitality!! We were impressed. They have an awesome 6 mini scoop bowl. Still not enough lol. We went back multiple times to enjoy our favorites and try new ones. Phenomenal!!
Check my profile for more Maui reviews!!
This was amazing ice cream. I got the Chantilly and I can’t remember the other scoop, but hands down some of the best ice cream I’ve had. So hard to choose a flavor but we had great service and they offered as many samples as we wanted.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Lahaina
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes