Sweet Pete's
511 Greene St - Key West
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
#238 of 340 restaurants in Key West
Updated on
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
69/100
Data Completeness
61/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
🚚
Delivery
🥡
Takeout
♿
Wheelchair accessible
📊 Popular Times
Not busy
Moderate
Very busy
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
2,275
Google reviews
The original pie is smooth light and delicious. You can watch them make it.
Google
Best Key Lime Pie around. Not to tart, not to sweet. REAL key limes are used. Owners are friendly. Must stop and enjoy. Btw, I personally made sure it was true key limes being used since I'm skeptical.
Google
EXCELLENT… What can I say? They make a great piece of key lime pie… Great flavor and value. I tried others and they didn’t compare!
Google
This was my favourite place in Key west and the pie is still the best key lime pie I have ever had. However my most recent visit noted some concerning trends. First the piece of pie was much smaller, the price was much higher, which ok maybe with inflation. But $6.00 for a sliver of pie and then the nerve to charge me $1.00 for a plastic fork is over the top and left a very bad taste in my mouth. Come on if you are going to charge a dollar for a folk make it wood, or bamboo or environmentally friendly. Not a plastic fork.
Read more
Google
The best key lime pie in the keys. Tried the chocolate one tried the frozen one tried the deep fried one and this one is the best
Google
This is a must if you are in Key West. We purchased a whole pie since there were 7 of us. The manager provided us with plates and utensils so we could eat it right there. I seen him smile as he noticed the delighted expressions on our faces with each bite we took. My taste has not been right since I was struck with covid in 2019 but to my surprise I was able to enjoy it.
Read more
Google
I am not a fan of Key Lime Pie (I know, shameful as a Florida native), but everyone i was with that had a slice said it was fabulous. And the people in the shop are incredibly friendly. A definite must do when in the Keys.
Google
Must stop for key lime on a stick dipped in chocolate.
The chocolate is of high quality. Every pie is made and baked in house.
Definitely worth stopping by.
Google
What a charming bakery! The key lime pie was fantastic! Friendly owner and great atmosphere! A must visit :)
Google
The actually key lime pie is delicious! Other versions of cheesecake & pie/cake desserts are phenomenal as well. Little pricey but it is geared towards tourists with trinkets and such so understandable. Nice people working inside too! Will always go back for a sweet treat or something cold to eat whilst walking around downtown!
Read more
Google
Explore more in Key West
By specialty
Recommended pages
Help improve this page: