Don’t be fooled by the outside like we’ve been for years. Don’t be fooled by the inside either as it’ll take you back a few decades 😊 we thoroughly enjoyed the food and wine. The lasagna and the spaghetti and meat sauce were delicious. The Key Lime Pie was very good 9 out 10 according to wifey.
We’ll definitely be back to try the pizza….oh don’t forget to ask for the dinner rolls, they were amazing.
Probably the best food we had on our trip to marathon. If you want something normal besides tiki bar fried food and sticky tables and the smell of fish this is the place to come to!! The menu is very nice with many choices and we opted for the Italian dishes! The mozzarella sticks were handmade and sauce was delicious. The French onion soup was perfect, fresh bread, lasagna was amazing and enough to feed two. There was 6 of us and everyone loved their meal and the service was fantastic!! Loved the family, warm dining decor! Great place!! Will be back next year!!!
As my week long vacation is coming to an end, we stopped at this restaurant, which is just down the road from where we are staying. I can honestly say, after every single place I have tried so far, this restaurant is my favorite!!! My boyfriend got the filet, and he said it was cooked perfect, but a little dry. Our friend got a shrimp salad and said it was amazing. Our other friend got a burger and said it was great. I got the blackened chicken with a salad, & side of spaghetti, and added a side of spinach, all of it was spectacular. I can’t think of anything that could make my meal better. The portions were big, and prices were very reasonable. Also, the bread that was served before your meal is wonderful and fresh too. Waitress and other staff was super friendly!! I can’t wait to come back! :)
![5]( "Recensione")
I have been coming here for about 18 years. The current owner is newer. But I am so excited they continued tradition.
We started with salads. The Blue cheese and Ranch are made at restaurant. Both are excellent. They are both my favorites. I think others are homemade as well. My picture was half eaten because it is that good.
We both ordered the Lorenzo. I did the Dolphin and my wife upgraded to the Snapper. The Dolphin was great. But it is worth the $6 dollar upgrade. Seriously not a knock on the Dolphin, it is just the Snapper is perfect for this dish. Yes the price is higher than it used to be. BUT.. Unlike most places that are charging for half a yellow tail filet. It looked like 2 full filets. The picture does not give the the quantity justice. It was so good. This place is is one of the best places in the Marathon area. You must try this place it will become a yearly tradition for you as well.
There is a post about early arrival menu that is not a thing. See my photo.
This place is the highlight of our yearly trip. We make this stop a priority.
Service was great. Food was pretty good, but not great. However, we did come in at 8 and they close at 9, so the baked potato was old and not really edible. What we did love was the line in de coconut drink! 🥥 🍈
I haven’t had fried calamari and linguine with thick clam sauce in ages. The size of the serving was large enough for me to have a lunch next of leftovers. Hmmmm. The service was attentive and not overbearing. I was happy to leave a generous tip. They treat you warmly.
Slightly hidden from the main traffic, but well known by locals. This place has great cook your catch options and is an affordable white table cloth dining option. So far this place has the most options for cook your catch that I've seen, hands down.
Its a bit dark inside, which is a shame because the views of the golf course are nice and it's surrounded by beautiful homes.
A wonderful find in Key Colony beach ! The restaurant is enclosed and has AC with a stunning view of the key colony inn golf course so you get the best of both worlds. As a local this is one of our favorite spots for its versatility and great food/ drinks specials. You can come in for an Amazing and cost effective lunch, hang out at happy hour where drinks and food are $5 or come in for a nice dinner/ to celebrate any special occasion. The staff is always friendly and accommodating. The food is phenomenal, always taste great and the portions are huge. I highly recommend making this a stop on your trip, you won’t regret it !
Bring your catch of the day and they will prepare your dinner for you! As a Mid-western gal this was an amazing experience! If you get to the Florida Keys, Marathan Key, this is a must go resturant after your fishing trip! They also had live music in the bar on Friday night! Definitely would go back again!!
This is a regular stop for us when we are in the keys! A fine dining atmosphere with excellent food that is not too pricy. We were disappointed to hear that they stopped offering the early bird specials, but they still have my wife's favorite: chicken almondine on the menu. I tried the chicken marsala which was delicious! We will definitely be coming back. Thank you Key Colony Inn for another great experience!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Key Colony Beach
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes