Always a great time! The nicest bartenders on the island! Their kitchen staff, not so friendly, BUT, if I were working hot summer nights next to a hot pizza oven I wouldn't be friendly either! 😃 The subs are fantastic! The wings on the grill are amongst the best I've ever had! The restrooms... awful and almost as hot as the kitchen. BUT, all the public restrooms on the island are gross. By far, the place to be when visiting KI! Good times and great memories every year for the past 20+ years! Wish The Caddy Shack could trade locations with The Casino 😉
We have been coming to Kelleys Island for years but this is a fairly new place for us to visit. Bartender and staff was great. They actually talked us into coming back to try their "amazing" wings and they were simply amazing. Pizza was fantastic as well. Great staff, great prices, amazing food!
The Caddy Shack is a stop for me on every island visit. Great food and even better service! I highly suggest the pizza, sandwiches and Brett's wings are the best I've ever had.
love the staff at Caddy, and the Italian sub is the best,nobody should leave the island without the Caddy Shack experience
The food and staff are great! The entertainment is an added bonus. Love this place! It simply rocks!
This place just plain out ROCKS!! Up every week on my boat. Great place, great food, and some of the friendliest bar tenders!!! Word up smiles....
We experienced our first visit to Kelley's Island today and we had our lunch at The Caddy Shack. Their pizzas and sammiches are Amazing! Fresh, quality ingredients; great food at a great price. The staff was excellent as well, very friendly and seemed to be enjoying their jobs. We rarely have that at our local places, so that alone added something to the day. I hope we can make it back again. Thank you!
Favorite place on the island. Great pizza, bloody Mary's, wings, and subs.
Nomad Soul loves the Caddyshack! We had such a blast playing last Saturday July 8th! thanks to all the staff who took such great care of us,everyone who hung out all night to dance,whoot and holler♫ and to all our friends who came over to the Island with us to party! We can't wait to come back!!! Thanks you guys!
Great wings
Amazing Pizza
Awesome owners and atmosphere the beer selection is very cool
We had a great time out on the patio...Italian sub and pineapple cider.... yummy!
The food is always fresh and tasty! Love that turkey, bacon provolone sandwich!
Fun atmosphere and awesome owners! Keep on rockin'!!!!!!!!!!
The beer was cold and the bartender was very nice!!
This place is great! Best wings on the island.
Yummy yummy yum yum I love the pizza here you have to get some if you're hungry bring the whole family over here and get a pizza
The ABSOLUTE best wings EVER! Never had wings like this, and WOW, they were delicious! You definitely can't go wrong with the pizza as well. Great sauce, and the cheese is phenomenal! Keep up the great work Brett and staff! Awesome selection of beer too!
Fantastic pizza, great beer selection! Outdoor seating and live music!
The people here are GREAT👍...you feel right at home...and the Italian sub? Absolutely the best☝😋
Awesome place with Great Pizza and Subs along with a draft list that is out of this world! 47 Taps! They do the absolute best Grilled Wings but only on certain days!
Amazing wings and cheap beer in the off season
Great pizza and very good music!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes