Best Restaurants in Kelleys Island

⭐ Top

★ 98 /100

View →

Taste By The Lake

Fast Food

💬 105 reviews

📍 15 Division St

⭐ Top

★ 93 /100

View →

The Village Pump

American Bar Pub

💬 1470 reviews

📍 103 W. Lakeshore Dr.

⭐ Top

★ 91 /100

View →

Island House

American International

💬 416 reviews

📍 131 Division Street

📋 Menu ⭐ Top

★ 90 /100

View →

Caddy Shack

American Bar Pizza

💬 473 reviews

📍 115 Division St.

📋 Menu

★ 87 /100

View →

Dockers Waterfront Restaurant & Bar

American Bar Seafood

💬 463 reviews

📍 114 W Lakeshore Dr

★ 85 /100

View →

Ki Cantina

Mexican Brew Pub Pub

💬 234 reviews

📍 418 Woodford rd

★ 85 /100

View →

Peepers

American Barbecue Pub

💬 175 reviews

📍 109 West Lakeshore Drive

★ 84 /100

View →

Captains Corner

American Bar Mediterranean

💬 525 reviews

📍 101 W Lakeshore Dr

★ 83 /100

View →

Rock, Baker, Sippers Island Bakery & Coffee Shop

Cafe

💬 22 reviews

📍 Caddy Shack Square Downtown

★ 81 /100

View →

Kelley's Island Wine Company

American Wine Bar Pizza

💬 611 reviews

📍 418 Woodford Road

📋 Menu

★ 80 /100

View →

The Casino

American Bar

💬 762 reviews

📍 104 Division St

★ 75 /100

View →

Kelleys Island Brewery

American Bar

💬 326 reviews

📍 504 West Lakeshore Dr.

★ 70 /100

View →

West Bay Inn

American Bar Pub

💬 880 reviews

📍 1230 W Lakeshore Dr

🍴

★ 70 /100

View →

Dipper Dan's Ice Cream

📍 115 Division St