Best pot pie I've ever eaten. I've had both the beef and the chicken and both were great. Lots of flavor, plenty of vegetables, and the crust is perfect. Girlfriend had the pan roasted chicken and said it was really good also. Nice atmosphere, and the staff is friendly, helpful and on top of their tables. Pot Pie could become habit forming.
Never had a bad meal here. Space is small so you need reservations for sure, but the staff will take great care of you. We always get the mussels (with extra bread to take advantage of the great tasting broth) and then enjoy sharing an entree like the scallops or chicken pot pie so we have room for dessert. Dim lighting, exposed brick walls, menu written on chalkboard on the wall, fantastic bar - great date night place.
The crust on this pot pie was literally so flaky and delicious. As a baker myself I am truly curious how they were able to get their crust to be so amazing. I got the beef and mushroom and my friend got the chicken and vegetable. Both were very good. They also have lots of other things on their menu including fish and steak. It’s a small intimate space so I’d recommend making a reservation especially on the weekend.
The atmosphere was quaint and the staff was very polite. The food did seem a little under seasoned, but was cooked very well. I had the trout and it just didn't have a lot of flavor. The carrot puree it was accompanied by was phenomenal though. The other people in my party ordered the pot pie and added a lot of salt and pepper to their dishes to bring out the flavor. I would give them another chance though.
My wife and I had the opportunity to eat here on our Dec trip to KC. We like to explore different places to eat that are off the beaten path. We had a wonderful dinner at Pot Pie. The servings were large and fresh. Service was great. We thought the prices were reasonable. In addition, the atmosphere and decor was comfortable and inviting. We would definitely visit there again.
Small restaurant, big crowd, very cozy. The server was so nice with a big smile. We got a small table and she saw us with quite some stuff and switched us to a bigger one.
Food was awesome! Everything was tasty. We had three courses and expected a big bill but it wasn't the case at all. Highly recommended!
A small getaway in Westport KC. Had the Steamed Mussels for an appetizer (5) Chicken & Veggie Pot Pie (5). Flavors pop right at you with the lightest flaky pie crust, which is a good thing because it will definitely fill your tummy. My table also had the Pan Roasted Chicken on a bed of Green Beans & Mash Potatoes (5). The chicken had a blast of crispy skin flavor that will keep you coming back for more. And if you can find space after all that, try the Bread Pudding (4) with a cup of their coffee (5). Awesome dinner guys keep up the good work, and we will see you in the near future!
Probably the best service I’ve had in years. The server took care of the entire restaurant and did it extremely well!
The menu is limited but very good. Our group had several different items and all were amazing.
Their drinks are also fantastic…I recommend the Hey Rey.
Just wished we lived closer as this would be one of our regulars!
We've been going to Potpie for YEARS. Since I was a kid, it's always been one of my dad's favorite restaurants here in KC and we have had a lot of wonderful events there. It's a small restaurant but it is so cozy and the owner is the best. This is definitely one of my comfort places and I will always have good memories of it!
The Rustic interior will fool you, the food is first class. I have eaten scallops from Vancouver to Halifax, Seattle to Bangor Maine and these are hands down the best I have ever had. The bread pudding is also excellent. If I could give more stars I would.
Potpie is an excellent little restaurant with amazing food and perfect cocktails. It is small inside which really adds to the charm of the place. This was my first time eating here and is easily my top 3 favorite restaurants in the kc area. If you like comfort food paired with a cocktail then make a reservation and go, you won’t regret it!
Really enjoyed the atmosphere of this restaurant. Extremley cosy. When the restaurant fills up it has a great tavern feel to it. It can get a little cold when the door opens but not really a major issue. The food was great and really enjoyed the butcher board and I think that was the largest pot pie i have ever seen. I really like their motto that this is not fast food but good food.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Kansas City
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes