Mighty Cessna
This was my first purchase from Sweet By Holly and it was a fantastic experience. I ordered a gluten-free cake and 6 cupcakes. The order process was quick and the local manager(Elise) called me to confirm my order. The delivery process was great and they were able to deliver the cake and cupcakes when I needed them. These were the best gluten-free cake and cupcakes that we have ever had! My wife has been gluten-free for 15+ years and she has tried many different gluten-free options over the years. We both were incredibly impressed!
C Trimmings
Sweet By Holly is amazing! I ordered a red velvet graduation cake and matching mini cupcakes (not pictured) in Plain Jane. Can we say MOIST and delicious, because that's what everything was! Everyone loved the red velvet cake and raved about the homemade icing.
Kayla Ross
The strawberry and DULCE DE LECHE cupcakes deserve a review of their own , absolutely amazing. The prices were a little more than I anticipated but that’s the price of going into an actual bakery so I understand. The staff could have been a little more welcoming, the say me walking in but continued to have a conversation so I wanted a while before someone else helped me. But over all the cupcakes were very good!! My fiancé who isn’t much for sweets also had a few of them which I wasn’t expecting so they must have been pretty good 😊
Cristina Batista
Sweet by Holly has some of the best cupcakes I have ever had. The cupcakes are dense, moist and super tasty! There are plenty of options to choose from and there are even gluten free cupcakes, too. We order from Sweet by Holly at work each time someone has a birthday and they are definitely a crowd favorite. My personal favorite is the cookies and cream cupcake.
The icing on top is how friendly and helpful the staff is.
Tip: go on Monday for $1 mini cupcakes!
Amanda Rivera
Best cupcakes around! Love the variety of flavors and their deals. $1 Mini Mondays are great and you can't beat the price for delicious cupcakes. The staff is always really friendly and willing to help.
Elizabeth McEwan
Love Sweet by Holly! I got my friends shower cake, my own shower cake, and wedding cake from here. Their cakes are so delicious and there are so many flavor options. They also make everything beautiful and I was so pleased with all my speciality cakes I have ordered from them. I’ve also had people tell me their cake is the best they’ve ever had at the events I had their cakes at! My shower and wedding cake were also ordered during COVID and they were so flexible and accommodating regarding our tasting and pick up/delivery times of the cake and their staff is always very nice.
Amy
We have ordered many beautiful cakes…wedding, groom’s, birthday and yummy cupcakes from SweetbyHolly since 2017. I highly recommend this bakery!! Recently there was a hiccup with one cake, but kindly the management and staff went above and beyond to make it right! I am very gracious that they cared so much…. Thank you SweetbyHolly for being so Sweet!! XOXO
Troy Broas
If you love cupcakes, then give Sweet By Holly a try. I personally recommend the "High Hat". This is a chocolate cupcake, with a large dollop of butter cream on top, that is then dipped in chocolate. You can't go wrong with that! I also love the "White Cap" and the "Mississippi Mud Slide". Sweet offers two sizes of cup cakes, the traditional standard sized cupcakes (they actually seem larger than regular cupcakes to me), and mini cupcakes in case you just have craving for a little something sweet. I haven't tried it yet, but Sweet also offers a variety of frozen yogurts. Next time you are in the town center and want something sweet, give this place a try.
Lexie Diaz
So incredibly disappointed by this location....
Update: 4/12/21
I was contacted by their regional manager and he made everything right and then some! He went above and beyond to make sure that I was satisfied: he had the cake completely remade and done by their head decorator, he offered me a full refund and had the cake delivered to my house. His actions completely changed my experience for the better and my mom and I couldn't be happier with our cake! I've attached the new image of the cake and pictures of the sweet card and cupcakes they included with delivery.
Marc Lippa
It's always a treat whenever I go to Jacksonville to visit my favorite Drs. & nurses at The Mayo Clinic.
However, the best treat is to stop at St Johns Town Center & buy the best of the best cupcakes at Sweets by Holly.
BTW If ever in Jacksonville visit this amazingly large outdoor mall.
Another review another time for St John's.
Bonnie Fenwick
We were planning a baby shower with a surf theme and they nailed it beautifully! The cake was absolutely delicious! We also had various cupcakes made too!
D S
Mini cupcakes!! These babies are adorable and the perfect size for two people to taste! The dulce de leche cupcake and coffee bean were so moist! It was our favorite! We loved them all.
Diane Scheirman
I love cupcakes. Tried this place two months ago and loved it. I ordered like 8 mini cupcakes 🤣🤦♀️. Finally got back there tonight. Went in for 4 mini cupcakes. The young sales clerk said “if you buy 6 minis, I’ll throw in a dozen mini Halloween cupcakes.” Uh yes, yes I’ll do that.
ChelseaAndAnthony Pearson
Amazing! I love this place amazing fresh baked cupcakes daily . They also have a pretty good vegan cupcake section ! Try them out ! There open til 10 pm and closed Thanksgiving Thursday
Samantha Logan
Our wedding cake was perfect! From the planning to the delivery the staff did an amazing job. Thank you for making our day special!
Amanda Packard
We recently used them for our wedding cake and it was super easy and reasonably priced-
They delivered the cake over to St Augustine without a hitch. I called a few weeks before to pay the balance, never followed up and they had the cake set up & looking great by the time the event started.
Cakes of course taste amazing (if you've ever had a cupcake from them that is what they taste like) & the tasting process was super easy. You just go taste their mini cupcakes & there are so many flavors - your wedding cake definitely won't be boring.
It also was absolutely beautiful and exactly how I wanted!
Sarah Smith
Sweet by Holly definitely has the best cupcakes in town! My wife and I met them at a bridal expo and fell in love with their cupcakes. They are beyond addicting. We ended up ordering 20 dozen varying flavors of their mini cupcakes for our wedding and all of our guests loved them. 10/10 would eat there again.
Karli Jenkins
Delicious and Awesome Customer Service!! Something about the atmosphere was just off. I love the mini cupcakes because you can try all the different flavors.
Christa Zielinski
Several different flavors, daily, of gluten free cupcakes! My biggest problem was which flavor to choose😊 Thank you for caring enough to make several flavors. It was fantastic 🍰
Karen Krull
This is my favorite yogurt place and love the cupcakes even more. Can’t decide which is my favorite flavor because they are all so yummy! I can bribe the kids to do most chores or sit still through a haircut when they know they are coming to Sweet by Holly. 💕🍧
Kelsey Crabtree Nevin
I ordered a very dramatic Dinosaur Cake for my 7 yr old’s Birthday. I was looking for something fiery specific. Sweets By Holly blew it out of the water!! This cake was beautiful and so delicious! Everyone kept commenting about how amazing this cake looked. Thank you so much. We will definitely be back for all our party needs.
Angel Lundy
It might have been because they were sitting out for a while in the case, maybe not, but the cupcake quality was not what I was expecting for a competitor of cupcake wars. It was dense, a little dry, and eggy tasting. The frosting was fantastic, no doubt, and the flavors that the cupcakes are named after seem to be pretty accurste. The atmosphere was nice as well. I just would caution you to not set the bar too high for the cake itself. Nice place overall though. Will probably go again.
Karen Ziegler
Not impressed and the prices were ridiculous. Cupcakes were dry it didn't seem like anything was fresh and the store had a wet mop smell which made eating there funky so we took our treats out to the car and ate instead.
Grace Watson
I got my wedding cake from them and they had unbelievable customer service. I hands down recommend this place. Everyone should have customer service like Sweets!!!
Verdantlee Holly Hipskind
Incredible job on custom-order cupcakes for our Wedding! Theme was executed beyond our expectation, order delivered on time, customer service staff was amazing throughout, and most importantly: the cupcakes were Delicious! Guests raved & we were bowled over by how well it turned out.
Kailah R Miller
You guys made a cake for my daughters 1st birthday party and it was amazing! Her first birthday was so important to me and the cake It's exactly like the picture I gave and more! And it tasted amazing I will forever recommend you guys for not only cakes but your cupcakes are amazing!! You will also forever have my business Thankyou ��
Kaneesha Ishman
We really enjoyed our visit and the staff was wonderful. Michelle was one of the wonderful staff members who helped us!!!!!!!!!
Shawn Carter
The place was awesome great selection of music cupcakes were great i ate the Boston cream omg!!!!! I will definitely go back ����� �
Jeanne Estelle Batten
Everyone loved my smores cake! You guys do such a great job. Glad it was easy to pick up a vegan option as well. The cakes look great but more importantly taste amazing. Thank you!
Ashley May Griffin
Our 5-tier wedding cake came out delicious and looking BEAUTIFUL. It was a huge hit, as it had a "geo" made from rock candy. Probably one of the best wedding cakes I've ever eaten and can't wait to eat the top tier in a year �
Toni Shuster
Best Cupcakes we love $1.00 Mondays every flavor is yummy worth every calorie
Alee Cat
A friend gave me an assortment of cupcakes for my birthday from here, and they were great! My favorites were the pumpkin spice, and cookies & creme. Yummy!
Darby Craig Mueller
Too much icing not enough cake and then a filling too not my cup of tea
Courtney Laufenberg
Wonderful staff, amazing cup cakes , frozen yogurt � and beautiful cakes � Also, you can’t beat mini mania Monday!
Gina Sondgeroth Dacosta
Always Amazing! Never a disappointment! Always worth the time to stop by!
Jen Meury Whittemore
They made my wedding cake and grooms cake for my wedding yesterday. The cakes tasted amazing and were absolutely perfect.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes