New York Pizzeria

New York Pizzeria, Jacksonville 2040 Wilmington Hwy - Jacksonville

Pizza

74/100
Give a rating

What's your favorite New York Pizzeria's dish?

Ratings and reviews

74
/100
Based on 988 ratings and reviews
Updated

Ratings of New York Pizzeria

TA

Trip
Last update on 31/12/2023
4,0
6 Reviews
Google
Google
Last update on 24/12/2023
4,1
362 Reviews

MW

Menu with price
Last update on 14/05/2020
4,6
486 Reviews

MP

Menupix
Last update on 06/09/2020
2,5
4 Reviews

R

Restaurantji
Last update on 06/09/2020
3,4
70 Reviews

Available menus

Reviews

5
Brandy Schmidt
+5
Another wonderful meal for my family. The food is always great! The garlic knots and wings were out of this world. Pizza was a hit as always! See you soon!
5
Brianna Vollemans
+5
Have ordered pick up plenty of times and never had any complaints. My husband and I decided to dine in this evening with our kiddo and no complaints there as well! We absolutely love the diner atmosphere. Everything was clean and everyone was friendly!!! Pizza was phenomenal. I’m from Bridgeport CT so it was a quick trip to New York City and the pizza here definitely matches!! Felt like a dork asking where to put our trays since we haven’t dined in and the gentlemen said he didn’t mind grabbing them. Super calm and friendly atmosphere. Loved it!!!!!
4
Keith Bloom
+4
Me and the wife were in town and this was closest to us at the time. We ended up getting a large pepperoni and mushroom pizza, an order of mild buffalo wings, and an order of garlic knots. I'm no pizza connoisseur, but I'd say the pie was average. It has plenty of cheese, the right amount of toppings and not too much sauce. The crust however was lacking and just didn't wow me. The buffalo wings were fantastic, but were held back by bottled ranch (you just gotta have the real thing!!). The garlic knots were amazing. These things are not for the healthy conscious. The "knots" are basically small dinner rolls cooked in a ton of butter and garlic. They were cooked perfectly and were quite tasty! The prices were fair and we left full, without any complaint, aside for the bottled ranch. Check em out!
5
Gab
+5
This pizzeria reminds me of the ones in NYC, it has that vibe in the restaurant. The pizza here is just like it, the slices are large, cheap and always fresh and delicious. Just like the pizza I remember eating, growing up in NY. I do recommend eating here.
5
Whitney loggans
+5
I love this place. The food is AMAZING, The staff are so kind, great family atmosphere and even better food
5
Ken May
+5
Slices so big they are practically a meal. Really good pizza!
4
Jeff Buchanan
+4
My family and I ordered two individual slices (pepperoni and cheese), garlic knots, and a specialty pizza. The pizza was very tasty. Food was ready in a timely manner and the eating area was clean with plenty of condiments. Their ranch was rather exceptional as well. Management staff was engaged, however the one less star was due to the bathroom facilities for both male and female to be less than favorable. They seemed rather busy with orders as well. All things considered I will definitely go back there for the pizza and the real "New York" experience you get from the employees.
5
Sergeant Major
+5
I ordered a traditional calzone. It was amazing - no photos because it looked so good I had to eat it right away. Service was great, positive atmosphere all around the place. Biggest thing that has me rating this place with 5 stars was the number of happy customers. I now have a favorite pizza place in Jacksonville.
5
cornsnaketamer
+5
Food was very good... Had it cooked for us quickly... Great experience...
5
Gena Hagan
+5
Came to the pizzeria for the first time. We had great food and good service. The white pizza was fantastic. Crust was the best I have had since coming to Jacksonville.

Description

Timetable

Monday:
10:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Tuesday:
10:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Wednesday:
10:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Thursday:
10:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Friday:
10:00 AM - 09:30 PM
Saturday:
10:00 AM - 09:30 PM
Sunday:
Closed

Read the reviews on

TA

Trip
Google
Google

MW

Menu with price

MP

Menupix

R

Restaurantji

Info

Compare the best restaurants near New York Pizzeria

bianca Sluurpy rate Google rate Facebook rate
TA

New York Pizzeria

75 4.1 4
Pizza Hut 70 3.4 4 2
T C's Bar B Que 82 4.1
Krispy Kreme 81 4.3 4.1 4
Taco Gringo 71 4.2 3.5
Tienda La Juanita Taqueria 89 4.4 4.5
Chick-fil-A 70
Burger King 70 3.4 3 1

Our aggregate rating, “Sluurpometro”, is 74 based on 988 parameters and reviews

If you need to contact by phone, call the number +1 910-938-2201

MAKE A QUESTION

SUBMIT
1