The best Dinner in Ithaca | Sluurpy updated in June

"Honestly one of the best wonton soups i have ever had. It was extremely flavorful and honestly set the mood for the rest of the meal. Honestly will..."

Jess Hollenbeck

Drew Haaland

Jennifer Veit

June Luu

The Dock

Loumies

Non-smoking restaurants

Maxie's Supper Club And Oyster Bar

87/100 (2750 ratings)

Accepts American Express

Free off-street parking

"For appetizers we had fried green tomatoes with a remoulade and the steamed clams. The fried green tomatoes were incredible, crispy and a touch spicy..."

Nikoli's Kitchen

"Babyyyy, I would give 7 stars if I could! I absolutely lovedddd my blackened catfish sandwich, the cornbread, the very friendly and helpful service,..."

L Smith

"Charming, cozy and classy. Excellent service and delicious food. Even after a bit of an ordering snafu (slight difference of interpretation as to..."

Coleman Swartz

"Great service! Delicious food. Cold beer and wine. Really nice atmosphere. We had a fantastic evening! Jambalaya was amazing! Fish and ships are the..."

Janine Ziermann-Canabarro

"The live oyster was fresh but a little bit pricey…the crabcakes and others are in medium quality to..."

Le Phuong Tran

"Great food, nice atmosphere and friendly staff. Excellent homemade cornbread. If you like oysters they were preparing them the entire time we were..."

Dane Summerville

"One of the best restaurants in Ithaca. Maxie’s truly brings an authentic and delicious southern seafood experience to Upstate NY. The quality of..."

Ben Wells

"Very crowded during the Ithaca College family weekend. Reservations recommended. Great food, and wait staff were very attentive despite the rush. ..."

Skip Zimmerman

"Loved the oysters on half shell. The Finger Lake Old Fashion was perfect. Smooth bourbon with excellent bitters and flavors. The Po'boy..."

charles lawhun

"We stopped by after visiting the Ithaca falls and we loved it! The seafood platter was so..."

Nina Brajdic

Bones Bbq

Collegetown Bagels

Free off-street parking

Accepts American Express

Seating

Wheelchair Accessible

"Bagels were really great. Very fresh and very filling in both the breakfast sandwich and the lox. I don't think I would get the matcha again; should..."

Courtney Rasura

"I had a sandwich on a za’atar bagel and it was great, very fresh and tasty. Their white pumpkin mocha was great too, the portion is awesome for the..."

Roma G

"My favorite coffee shop in Ithaca, but their WiFi has been iffy for months (November 2023 now). I sure hope they will try to fix it so I can..."

Sandra Lynn

"Bagels great, other things pretty..."

YC S

"Staff so friendly and helpful. Food is delicious. No skimping on cream cheese. Love this..."

Jay Davis

"Had the Six Mile Creek and a Catwoman and they were both..."

Josh Dobbin

"For what it is CTB is good. I do get somewhat frustrated when I ask for actual shots to be pulled for an iced latte and tip a lot as I know I’m..."

Mallory O'Donnell

"Excellent food and service! Prices fair but worthwhile. They had a help wanted sign that pointed out they pay a living wage. A business that is..."

Kevin M. Drury

"When we visit family in Ithaca every year we come here 3-4 times. Huge selection. Very consistent food. The coffee is enjoyable. Pastries are very..."

Alexander Ledbetter

"Nice selection of great things to eat. I got a pretty basic turkey sandwich which was very filling and delicious for lunch. Prices are very..."

Mike Ray

"Good vegetarian & vegan options. Not too pricey. Always tastes good. 4 stars because sometimes they forget to add the honey asked for into my coffee..."

BP

"This is my go-to when I'm feeling lazy or under the weather. I would call it a step up from McDonald's or Dunkin...but you pay for it. The prices are..."

Demi Perry

"Great food and a HUGE variety! If you can't find something you like here, you are very picky! Some of the best bagels I've had north of NYC. Tasty..."

Craig Scott

"Knowledgeable and helpful staff. Food options for everyone. Wheelchair..."

Annamae Scheuerman

"I am contemplating on rating them between 3 and 4. I would rate their smoothies 5 anyday. They make amazing berry smoothie and also a espresso+banana..."

Siddhartha Shandilya

"The breakfast bagels are the best. Highly recommend the California Sunrise, love the blend of guacamole, red onion, egg, and your choice of cheese...."

Beth Hulbert

Los Hermanos Mexican Restaurant

Wheelchair Accessible

"Stopped in for an early dinner, and the service was awesome and friendly. The chimichanga was loaded and lasted for two whole meals. The Carne asada..."

Beth

"This is literally the weirdest 5 stars I’ve ever given a restaurant…. So me and my husband went here a couple days ago. The place was packed but..."

Alysa Marquez

"Wow! We were recommended to this place by a family member and we were not disappointed!! Nachos were amazing and the kids loved the chips and salsa..."

J. H.

"Best service in the County. Food is always top notch. Been working my way thru the menu for the last 5 years and not found a meal yet that wasn’t..."

Terry Geer Sr

"A great little mexican restaurant in downtown Ithaca. It is only 4 or 5 minutes away from 127, parking in front or back. Very large menu and pleasant..."

Jeffrey Farell

"Amazing food, fabulous portions. Great for take out. Staff is nice and there is more than enough food. Pictures is the especial dinner and tostados..."

marti schmehl

"Definitely better than ANY Mexican restaurant in Alma and Mount Pleasant. Salsa was great, food could’ve been better.. But the service was AMAZING!..."

Rebecca Ann

"Fantastic food, friendly staff. I got there and is was super busy. They were still smiling and friendly. The food is outstanding, you could tell it..."

rod m

"I hate going out to eat it's usually to expensive had a mushroom Swiss burger here best thing I've tasted in a long time it's worth a shot in a damn..."

Kyle Meoham

"Staff is always friendly and attentive, food is delicious and served quickly. Love dining..."

Sue Corrigan

"This is our favorite Mexican restaurant to eat at once a week even though my wife is Hispanic. Restaurant has done fantastic since their opening and..."

Paul Phenix

"Great food! Everything I’ve had has been..."

Carl

"Everything thing was delicious- food & drinks. Staff was friendly & explained things. It was cheaper than another place we go for the same things. ..."

Regina Andersen

"Everything was amazingly flavorful. Some other restaurants take shortcuts and use salt to add flavor, but Los Hermanos uses well-balanced spices. The..."

M Malone

"Loved the food, salsa was the bomb… only thing I would change is the chips… they were cold and..."

lillie bfryesr@yahoo.com

"I recently visited Los Hermanos Mexican Restaurant and I have to say, I was blown away by the Burrito Pancho! If you're looking for an authentic..."

Chris Stephens

"Food was great, service was wonderful! Will be back..."

Logan Shackelford

"Good food, fast friendly people. Good..."

Donell Giffei

"Food is great, service is fast and friendly. It is however very small and..."

Sarah Fisher

Zocalo Mexican Bar & Grill

Wheelchair Accessible

Serves Alcohol

Wine and Beer

Parking Available

Free off-street parking

Full Bar

Accepts Credit Cards

Non-smoking restaurants

"The fajitas were phenomenal - maybe the best I’ve ever had. The atmosphere was also beautiful and lovely. My expectations were low because of the..."

Abbey Kampel

"This restaurant is my favorite place to eat with my family. Literally you feel like you are the part of the family there. Best place to get drinks..."

Meldina Muminovic

"This restaurant is in a mall but once you get in its like any other restaurant. They have authentic Mexican food. The portions are huge and everytime..."

Michael Kelly

"Pictured is shrimp tacos, seafood chimichanga, & 2 passion fruit margaritas at least that's what I'm going to call them, forgot the actual name 😁...."

Bob Rehner-Brown

"A great place for a casual meal. Food was delicious and very reasonably priced. Staff was friendly and attentive without being intrusive. We..."

Will Waite

"Always good food. Great, family-friendly space-- music is loud enough to drown out kids but not so loud you can't talk to others. Servers always..."

Duane Couture

"We're the kind of people who like to try everything a city has to offer and make recommendations to our friends and family for when they visit from..."

Ryan Owens

"The food is AMAZING! Not a single bit was left over!! In addition to our great waiter, Rafael, checking in on us and providing great service, three..."

Julita Smith

"Excellent, authentic Mexican food. Nice atmosphere. Wonderful waitress, very friendly and attentive. Food was exceptional, I had the vegan spinach..."

Lynn M

"Best in the Ithaca area!! Pollo Yucatan was authentic and superb. The flan is rich creamy and made on premises. Mani served us and was very kind..."

John Finn

"The food here is always incredible and very generously portioned, and the service is prompt and friendly. An excellent spot for a date night or a..."

Danielle

"Good food. Nice big bar. Great cocktails! Located in the..."

C Fish

"Awesome 👍 everything was great. Had a taco salad with chicken and shrimp ceviche . A frozen margarita. Friend had a platter. And a Craft beer Good..."

susan bard

"Great restaurant, great food, great atmosphere, great service. Best Mexican restaurant in Ithaca and the price was very fair. Would recommend to..."

Jared Glosser

"The wife and I went out for a kid free date night and had an extremely large mango margherita for two! It was a great accomplishment taking sips..."

Eric Banta

"Honestly, after moving to Ithaca from a big city, I was disappointed in all the food. This place redeemed Ithaca! For $20 you can have all the food..."

Fredrick Johnson

"I'm impressed with the service. Clean & well kept. The waitress was very attentive to our needs, checking us often. I couldn't ask for a better..."

NNatz Natz

The Bistro At La Tourelle

Wheelchair Accessible

"Excellent atmosphere with exposed wood beams and a fireplace in the green room. The service itself was good but it took a very long time to get the..."

Gary Brazel

"this is seriously the best penne alla vodka i’ve ever had at a restaurant! my advice: pay the fee for adding chicken on top; it’s so worth it...."

Rachel Adam (Rae)

"The place is so cozy and amazing to find in Ithaca! It's like an old house converted to a restaurant. I am a picky eater and I scrutinize everything..."

Rawan Aljallal

"This is our second time having breakfast here but the first time we stayed at the inn and ate in our room. The sausage was excellent. and the Liege..."

Joseph McLain

"Absolutely fantastic service at the Bistro! Our waitress was attentive, kind, and gave us great recommendations. Breakfast was a delicious classic..."

Cassie Rommel

"I recently was on a bus trip and we stopped for lunch. As a group we had placed our food orders ahead of time. A few days before the trip I had to..."

Sheila Wilett

"This was our last dinner on our honeymoon and I'm so glad it was open in the evening for our last night at La Tourelle. My wife had the Roasted..."

Grant Patton

"Went for a wine pairing dinner. The wine pairings were ok, but the food at the bistro rescued the night. The octopus, the lamb, the crab cakes, the..."

Heath Robinson

"Very cozy and old timey! Great little secluded spot with amazing service. If you're visiting Ithaca and want to experience a little peace and quiet..."

M J

"Food was excellent. 2 short ribs and Tarragon chicken, all came out really well. Deserts were also very high quality. Place was dead on a Saturday..."

calum Gillies

"Vegan & gluten free option !! Everything was delicious and so fresh. Nicole our server was so sweet and great. Highly..."

Danielle Pelaez

"My family has gone here on a regular basis for over 2 years. While it's not overly fancy, we have always been met with pleasant staff, great service..."

P

"My husband and I ate multiple meals here. Breakfast and dinner as well as takeout dessert; the dishes listed below do not include all that we ate. ..."

Diane Isenberg

"We came here for breakfast, and we're completely satisfied by the experience. We arrived fairly early (reservations at 7:30am), and had the whole..."

Jeney Wierman

"Went here on Ithaca Colleges graduation day with a party of 10. We arrived 20 minutes early for our 7:30pm reservation and were able to be seated..."

Stephen Kelsey

"We had a big party on a Sunday morning with no reservation. It was clear the place was busy, so some service was not great, but the food was very..."

Dorothy Franzo

"Great food but the restaurant needs a little sprucing up. I loved eating..."

Bill Cave

"Loved it. I wish I could drink mate every single day. We got the mango and the lemon-lime iced mates and both were amazing. Super flavorful and very..."

Dani Marie

"Loved the atmosphere of the place. It's a very well designed Interior. The Latte that I got(fresh green hot) was..."

Brody

"Got 3 delicious sandwiches. Not a whole lot of variety but I liked the "make your own" option. More choices that way. Bread was fantastic, ..."

Karen Pastore

"I'm shocked at the reviews of this place. Did people go to the same place as I did? Creepy? Cultish? Rude? What?! This felt like a cute, quaint,..."

Mohit Gore

"I do love this place! Even better to know they are the only place opened 24/5 which is awesome because sometimes you go down from the Pikes Peak and..."

Nicolas Ruiz Pedroza

"Charming place and such a fitting atmosphere for Manitou Springs. Very nice staff and quick service. Delicious teas and smoothies. Did not have any..."

Ivona Ault

"Unique small restaurant, house made bread, and everything from scratch, you will love the sound of the lake while having the best sandwiches in..."

Irvin Sanchez

"My wife and I were passing through Manitou springs on our honeymoon and couldn’t help but stop in the building looked so cozy. The mango mate..."

Nolan Baker

"This is my favorite place. The mate teas are delicious. I always get the peach one. The new lemon lime one is also good. They used to have raspberry..."

Rose Dawson

"This place is suuuper awesome, I make special trips a lot just to come here. Atmosphere is very unique and cool, looks like an indoor rainforest..."

Daniel

Ithaca Bakery

86/100 (3782 ratings)

Accepts American Express

Parking Available

Street Parking

Accepts Discover

Free off-street parking

Wheelchair Accessible

"We swung by before a busy day for a coffee and breakfast and were pleasantly surprised by the quality and speed from the staff! They have a huge menu..."

Drew Hoover

"The food never disappoints! A lot of choices and everything is delicious. Great local beer and cider selection too. A must visit when in..."

Eugene C

"How can anyone not love this bakery? It is so unique because it's not only a bakery and cafe, but they serve alcohol too (they even do happy hour..."

Melissa S.

"Great bakery! Love the bagels! The Ira sandwich is really good too. Quality lox and cream cheese. Lots of seating and helpful staff. The coffee was..."

Matt Daniel

"First time visiting. Took my parents and daughter here and blown away with the options this place have with sandwiches, pastries, coffee drinks and..."

Mieko A Ozeki

"Amazing place! Great menu options, great coffee, good drinks. Nice selection of food for being a bakery. I highly highly recommend a stop here if..."

Jordan Pero

"Good breakfast bagel, good cubano, good coffee. I'll come back next time my travels take me..."

Laika Sawyer (KillerofPCs)

"Have been here both times I've visited Ithaca and have really enjoyed it. The lunch/sandwich menu is gigantic and has something for everyone. I like..."

Thomas Harner

"Went here for killing some time for a pitstop brunch with my friend. Been here for a year in Ithaca but this was my first time going to Ithaca Bakery..."

Anne Dewanto

"Everything is good. Very fresh! Great Turkey sandwich! Great bread! My Daughter is a student at Cornell. Every time I come and visit her I insist..."

Teri L

Ned's Pizza Ny

86/100 (1650 ratings)

"We've ordered pizza regularly from Ned's for the past two years, and usually we've been pretty satisfied. The pizza is high quality and stays well in..."

John O'Reilly

"So, I had an event that I was getting food for it last minute and let me just say that, from a business standpoint, the service I received was second..."

Hadassah Jahani

"I order from here occasionally for pizza night. The sheet pizzas have always been good. This time I used their delivery service through chownow which..."

Shelby Shultz

"We were in the area and looking for a quick NY style pizza and I’m pleased to say this hit the spot. We ordered an 18inch margherita and meat..."

Eric

"Ned's is my favorite pizza in Ithaca! We usually order take out, and everything is always nice and hot. The crust is great and the wings were also..."

Austin Hovland

"The guys are hospitable, very hardworking, and all-around excellent in what they do. Needless to say, the pizza here rocks and they make a delicious..."

John Vongas

"So right off the bat this pizza passed the flop test. Crust is A+. Perfect amount of toppings. Some of the best pizza in Ithaca. Wings are cooked to..."

Derek Brown

"One of the best pizza places in the Ithaca area! First time getting a sheet pizza here and it was delicious. I'm glad they're open..."

Angelique Marie

"Pizza was very good. Did an online order and was told I would get a follow up email. 45 minutes later no email. Called the restaurant and was told..."

William Packer

"I eat here on a regular basis. The employees are always so nice. And the food is always amazing. Great place to grab a..."

Malinda Bickham

"Friendly handsome staff! Wonderful delicious food! They even made a brand new pizza just for me to have a slice because they didn't have the eggplant..."

Kelly Griffin Sherwood

"Service is always fast! Great pizza and always have many choices for slices at lunch..."

Kelsey Murdock

"The pizza is delicious and they sell by the slice. They're quick and efficient, which is a huge plus during lunch time. The prices are also cheap -..."

Richard Matheny

Gola Osteria

86/100 (1737 ratings)

Tonnarelli Carbonara or Cacio E Pepe

Octopus

Pappardelle with Porcini Trifolati Butter and Parmigiano

Lasagne

Biscotti Platter

Carbonara

Triple Layer Bar and Biscotti

Arancini

Arancini Siciliani Risotto Fritters Stuffed with Sausage Sunday Sauce and Ricotta

Wheelchair Accessible

Accepts Visa

Dinner

Fine Dining

"We had a lovely dinner last Wednesday to celebrate our engagement. Caitlyn was our server and she provided excellent service! The portions were..."

B

"I’ll say this…the food is very good. Being that I share my life with a person raised by Italian immigrants, I feel he knows good authentic..."

Courtney Tom

"A friend brought me here for my birthday. In response to many complaints here I would like to offer: High prices imply exclusivity. That is part of..."

Joyce Stillman-myers

"Such an interesting location. I would never have expected to find a gourmet restaurant back there. We had a mixed experience with the food. Our..."

stan stewart

"Generous portions of fantastic food served by attentive and experienced staff. Great spot for an elevated date, or just to spoil yourself. I..."

Michael Ullberg

"This was EASILY one of the top meals we've ever had! The swordfish was delicate and fell apart in a cacophony of flavor! The Veal Saltimboca wrapped..."

Cody Snyder

"Decent food, polite service, excellent ambience. I can't say the food is amazingly creative, bit the quality was always solid. A bit pricey for what..."

Michelle M. Park

"Gola Osteria catered our wedding and it was the GREATEST experience my guests and I have ever had! It started with planning and menu selection; Gola..."

Luis DeJesus

"This was good rich and heavy Italian fare in a very traditional setting. The portion sizes were quite large and filling. For..."

Sharadh Bhaskharan

"The food here is rich, delicious and totally worth the calories! ;-). Anything they make with a sauce or ragu is fantastic! They also make..."

Adam Brumberg

"Fantastic menu and service. Do not be discouraged by the location. Real Italian food! Absolutely..."

Al .Martino

"While a little pricey, this small Italian restaurant tucked away in this apartment building features great ambiance, food, and service. Especially..."

W W

"Todd is the best server in the world - I greatly appreciate his kindness, knowledge, overall demeanor, and willingness to correct my failure to ask..."

Ashley Lombardo

Corelife Eatery

Accepts American Express

Seating

Wheelchair Accessible

"An amazing place for lunch! Great service and attention to detail! Allergy friendly! I have a peanut allergy and they were extra careful with the..."

Kelly DeLisle

"Great healthy, farm fresh foods. All juices are delicious too. Would not be upset if they added a dessert option..."

Nick Tubbs

"Though a bit on the pricier side, CoreLife has a great range of salad, soup, noodle and rice/quinoa bowls with fresh, healthy ingredients and some..."

John Chapman

"This place is simply amazing. They put an extreme focus on serving fresh, high quality ingredients. The green and grain bowls are so tasty and also..."

Thomas J. Armitage

"I had broth bowl. The vegetables were fresh and good, the chicken tasted amazing but the chicken broth need more flavour. I recommend..."

Emilie Dauzon

"Went with a friend and ordered a main plate (pad Thai bowl) and a soup with a drink (each of us got a similar combination!) and they're on the more..."

Sambhavi Vempati

"I had lunch at CoreLife Eatery...again. I’ve normally gotten the salad bowls when I’ve gone, but the other options look amazing as well. But..."

Sunshine Chris

"First time here and I loved it! Got the shiitake and tofu soup with rice noodles. Their juices and tea infusions are great,..."

Yuji Y

"Being the new eatery on the block they had a uphill battle and easily won that, with there fresh food, amazing staff and delicious in house made..."

Don Manuel Presents

"Very healthy options at reasonable prices. I found the hand-drier in the men's room a bit strange: It was over the sink, and it blew anything..."

DrMatthew Evans

Angelhearts Diner

Ithaca Beer Co.

86/100 (14731 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

Serves Alcohol

Parking Available

Free off-street parking

"Great stop. Spacious on the inside, picturesque on the outside with big patios and Adirondack chairs in the grass. The fries flight is a mountain of..."

Christopher Fiscus

"I love this place, and I always take guests here, especially the beer lovers! I don't drink beer, but I LOVE their fresh root beer on tap. Sometimes,..."

Melissa S.

"What a perfect place! Brought our travel baseball team and their families here after a game for some food and drinks. The staff was accommodating,..."

Ron K.

"One of the original craft breweries. Great taps and brews on hand. Food is available, including veg options as well. Pours are 8 oz or 16oz, with..."

Mike S

"Nice place with lots of space, friendly staff, a large variety of beer, prompt service, and good food. We had the white pizza which was very good and..."

Jala Kidd

"Not a beer person so everything tastes bitter to me. However, I enjoyed the scenery and services. Pizza 🍕 was good. But the appetizers were not..."

Sophie Xie

"Service was great and the outdoor area has some nice field and forest views and is a nice place to spend some time. We had the bacon nibs which were..."

Scott Crowder

"We first discovered their root beer in Watkins Glenn. We noticed they were fairly close, so why not? It was worth the trip. The beer is very..."

Tim Yox

"Always nice to enjoy a beverage where it's made and this place doesn't disappoint. The food is great,..."

Paul Combs

"This came up rather early on a list of things to check out in Ithaca and I have to say - solid recommendation! The outdoor area is absolutely..."

Manan Doshi

"Must visit when you are visiting Ithaca/Cornell/Finger Lake region. Great place to end the day or have a nice relaxed afternoon. Beside the beer and..."

Santosh Shetty

"Quality place! Had the burger and it was top notch. So good. I loved the homemade fries. Beer garden outside was full so we couldn’t sit out there..."

Holly Wilson

"I'm from Texas ! & let me tell you , when it comes to food & beer we are very very demanding & then some. This place was above average in the beer &..."

Karlos A

"What an amazing experience! This is truly one of a kind. Beautiful outdoor beer garden . There is so much room. It is so spacious. The setting is so..."

Marina Kim

"Loved the beer. Flower power is good and understandably their flag ship beer. Found the brewery was really interesting and the tour was fun. Maybe..."

David Chiang

"We hired the outdoor tent area for an event and Jackie and her team were amazing! It was the perfect setting for an afternoon of beers and food and..."

Hazel Nasta

Old Mexico

85/100 (1537 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

Lunch

Dinner

Mid-range

"We stopped by for dinner while visiting Ithaca. The ambience has an authentic Mexican vibe. Portion size is good and they serve complimentary nacho..."

Varsha Dhavale

"This Mexican restaurant is really nice, and the staff is friendly. Our server provided good service, and the food arrived quickly and tasted..."

Bhushan Sonaje

"We are traveling to Itacha and we're so impressed with this restaurant. The place is beautiful, the cocktails are great, the service was super..."

Inbal Tenzin

"Good Mexican food in a lovely atmosphere. Our waitress was so attentive. We went back the next evening for taco Tuesday, the tacos were pretty bad I..."

Gibs

"The food is amazing, the waiter and waitress we dealt with are very nice and professional Diego and Sindy did a great job and made us feel very..."

Meldina Muminovic

"The maitre D had all the patience in the world. She never wavered when dealing with perhaps one of the most rudest customers who was ordering out..."

Ktol 11

"We hoped for a mexican restaurant and we got it! The kids meals are ... $2 more than usual and the adult meals are $2 less than usual. The..."

Bradly Larson

"The food was good. Had a good number of options in the menu. The vibe was really nice. The staffs were super friendly. The food I offered was good..."

Manoj Sapkota

"Delicious Mexican spot. I had the Diablo Steak Burrito. It was huge and was filled with delicious carne asada steak strips. They also serve you with..."

Jennifer Scarlet

"Amazing value! I ordered sizzling steak and chicken. For $16. Dollars I got 2 plates of food. And took home 2 take home boxes of food for 1..."

Camping Companions

"Stepped in to order takeout and everything was delicious. Steak street tacos were great, and it was so nice to get four!! The corn tortillas were..."

Jessica Ferrer

"I recently had the pleasure of dining at Old Mexico, and I must say, it was a truly delightful experience that transported my taste buds straight to..."

Mehul Desai

"Great food and great service. Our waitress was super friendly and kind. Would definitely..."

Dane Summerville

"Found parking easy. Went inside and was greeted by host. My friend hadn't shown up yet so I waited in the entrance where there were some seats. ..."

Socorro Varela

"The pinacolada with rum was great . I also the the rice drink Horchata. In dinner We had veggy fajita, dinner combo and the appetizer Quesadilla(..."

Paul

"Food was good and the quantity is actually quite big. Service is very..."

Jonathan Kauch

Italian Carry Out

85/100 (1115 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"I used to work for Ico for a brief period while in college. Working with everyone was like an extension of my family back home. They were genuine..."

Barbara Ann Hauss

"Great large spaghetti with a meat ball. Absolutely more than enough for Anne and I to handle (esp. when you add the bread that came with it), and the..."

Chris Woodard

"Thanks for all you did at Uncle Jake's memorial today!!! Yummy..."

Rosie Perry

"Worked with ICO a few times in the past few weeks to get a party catered and to order food for a business lunch. In both cases they went over and..."

Susan Evans

"Best homemade sauce ever!!!! I love their chicken parm dinner. I highly recommend..."

Sue Watkins

"Best food in Ithaca! Best pizza, salads, subs. Oh! and the blue..."

Kristopher Terry

"Best pizza in..."

Jesse Wiiki

"The King of South Hill Pizza! Had it tonight --..."

Zoltan Gergely

"Simply put - everything is great! My favorite meal in town is the Flying Squirrel sub. First - all subs are made with Ithaca bakery bread and..."

Benjamin

"A little bit of a wait. Full 30 minutes or so. But I got free slice of pizza as they were closing and only 2 left to choose from. Ordered chicken..."

Jon Pendleton

"If I could give this business and family 10 stars I would. Their chicken wing pizza is out of this world! Their salads are fresh and they use..."

Nathanael Katsiane

"Best pizza in the region by far! They’re also the go to option for wings, bomb hot subs, crazy chicken parms, and killer salads. If you’ve never..."

Tyler Nevill

"Review: Italian Carry Out, Ithaca NY First things first; I ordered my standard “review” pizza, a pizza with extra cheese, and the pizza showed..."

Michael Angley

"Best pizza and wings in the Ithaca area!! Great customer service..."

Jeremiah Clark

"Double dough, pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, probably the BEST pizza we have ever had from Italian Carry Out. Full of toppings, cooked just the way we..."

Deidre Deeley

"Loved the lasagna and the pizza was good too. The pizza portion, 2 slices and a drink for $5, was huge. The Greek salad with feta and olives was..."

Kim G

"Best pizza and wings in the Ithaca area by far. Never..."

Garrett Storm

"Used to be able to dine in..now only take out..food great..as..."

Bob Mcavoy

"Gotta eat a great chicken Parm sub at least once a..."

Herb Whittaker

"I asked for a pizza recommendation, and two folks sent me here. Glad I listened. The pie was very good and the price was..."

Timothy Celenza

"Beyond fantastic! Food was delicious, very large portions, staff was friendly and prompt! Meatballs the size of my fist! Will definitely be back and..."

Beth O'Connor

"Is there a sixth star? The "squirrel" pizza with their homemade blue cheese dressing has become my favorite pizza around. Great food and..."

Scott Schmutzler

"Coming to ICO for 30 years when I visit Ithica. Same great food as..."

Dana Parker

"The staff here are some of the most genuinely warm people, making their service next level and “at home”. Quality of product is outstanding,..."

Family Account

Mitsuba

Wheelchair Accessible

"Just got back from dinner there. Everything was done just right and presently beautifully. We ordered the Rock Shrimp, Crispy Calamari, and the Sushi..."

Tammy Watkins Andrews

"Great hibachi show! Food is very good and the salad bar is a wonderful touch. It's our 3-year old's favorite restaurant... And thanks to the..."

Jennifer Fee

"Amazing.. just..."

Sheena L. Monroe

"So I went there before I looked at the review of this place. When I see people say it's expensive or has bad hygiene, I think the opposite. Because..."

Timithy Lui

"Very nice and friendly staff. Wonderful food. Ordered something by mistake and they were very easy going and accommodated my last minute order. Such..."

Milo

"Best restaurant around! I can't say enough for the staff and owners. Top notch! Food is incredible!! I have been going here for years. Now I continue..."

Matt Marsh

"loved the food there! very authentic, yum and at a good price. the service was good, not overly..."

M

"Their serving is big and I really liked their salt and pepper squid when I ate there so I decided to order for delivery. I ordered the salt and..."

Angel

"Definitely one of the best spots for Chinese cuisine in Ithaca. They have two menu options, both Chinese and Japanese. Always make sure to suggest..."

Ajay Pillai

"Excellent prices on Sashimi and Sushi. The Tempura appetizers were really good. No alchohol served but the tea was good. Service prompt and..."

charles lawhun

"Literally my favorite place to eat. They have the most delicious food especially sushi. The owner is an amazing, staffs are always super nice,..."

Meldina Muminovic

"Very good Chinese food. Highly..."

Thuy La

"Delicious food, great service, and sweet..."

Qi Zhang

"Basically a Chinese restaurant disguised as a Japanese one! Make sure to ask for the Chinese menu with pics (which also has cheaper prices than the..."

Massimo Zeppetelli

"It was insanely busy. Service was decent. We went for a girls night, so we didnt mind waiting cause we were laughing and enjoying our time. However,..."

Kristine

Domino's Pizza

"This five star rating is from the turn around this store has done in the past year! Very responsive, and attend to concerns fairly. The staff has..."

Destiny Durgan

"We order from this Domino’s several times a week, and the food is consistently great, and the delivery is super fast every time, no matter what..."

Sarah PB

"Had to share my experience since I was wary about ordering after seeing some of the recent 1 star reviews. I had no issues ordering online for..."

Celine Gellineau

"Overall good experience. We had two carry outs in two days. First day the person who made our pizza gave a good amount of cheese but the second day a..."

Raihan Khan

"Their workers were amazing and the service was beyond phenomenal! However the domino's app to order on..."

verble shevalier

"Great Food Like the point system Best Driver Adam Thanks Bud Delivery price is a set back but Pizza is on..."

QuickDecision

"Jamillya is very good at her job she goes over and beyond to help a customer out. She has amazing customer service and great work..."

Melissa Scott

"Great service and delicious food, wonderful employees and delivery..."

Resi Lient

"we asked for plates and cups and they gave us some and the food was hella..."

Bewly isepic

"OMG!!! I haven't been to Dominos pizza in forever but I didn't feel like cooking so I want to grab one. I would like to add that the customer service..."

SingTrece “SingTrece”

"I always love getting pizza from here. The pasta is delicious too. There's many deals daily which helps you save up to $20. The workers are friendly..."

caitlin spry

Little Thai House

Lev Kitchen

Wheelchair Accessible

Wine and Beer

Non-smoking restaurants

Mercato Bar & Kitchen

Accepts American Express

Accepts Discover

Seating

Table Service

Wheelchair Accessible

Dinner

Fine Dining

"Oh my goodness, we were seriously thrilled to stumble upon this place! We came for the wine/convenient location and ended up falling in love with the..."

Shelby Wilson

"What a pleasant surprise. My boyfriend and I were driving through Ithaca on our way to the finger lakes and needed a spot for dinner. He texted an..."

Kate J

"My girlfriend and I decided to take a romantic getaway on the finger lakes and our drive had us passing through Ithaca, so we decided to stop for..."

Steve S.

"Definitely an above average restaurant for the area. The service at Mercato was the standout and I appreciated the varied drinks menu. The food..."

Jeremy Yowell

"If I could give 8 stars out of 5 I would. I'm taken away how great the food is from such a small kitchen. I really wished I lived closer to enjoy..."

Elliott Tso

"Very quaint and inviting. The atmosphere in this restaurant is very relaxed and offers dinning as well as a great bar. Our waiter was excellent. He..."

joe h

"This place is just perfection. We sat at the bar at around 5:40. The restaurant opens at 5:30 and all the table were already full but the time we got..."

Honor Marie

"We love this place we love to watch the kitchen work and the bartenders they all were very smooth and quick. Food was good and service was good we..."

Karin Marsh

"This place is a great little Italian spot with steak and homemade pasta. Go for the entre but skip the desert. Drinks a re pretty good as..."

Roman Rabinovich

"Mercato is clearly popular and with good reason -- wonderful food and drink. We started with two very well made cocktails, Cidecar (twist on..."

Douglas Weiskopf

Rashida Sawyer Bakery

Wheelchair Accessible

Dibellas Subs

Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich on the New Rye Bread Roll

Chicken Bacon Ranch Salad

Wheelchair Accessible

"Great food! First time I’ve been back here in a little while and the quality is still as good as before! Friendly staff, and the owner walks around..."

William Landon

"Just ate here for the first time and we will definitely be back! Staff and owner were friendly, food was good and made..."

Alicia Tappan

"Outstanding. This place puts subway to shame..."

Les Felton

"Excellent salads and subs. Fresh ingredients and the Staff are wonderful. Best place to eat in..."

Deb Sanford

"Love their smoke house brisket sub. Delicious sub's for a good price, and friendly..."

Rod Ike

"Their subs are the best. I'd go there again anytime :..."

Maazouz Fatima

"Very delicious subs!!! Very clean and friendly. Steak and..."

Misty Farrand

"Good place to eat be cool if they would put one in big flats..."

Robert Buchanan

"Customer Service is top notch! I have not had one bad sandwich..."

Chris VanDruff

"Wonderful food and service! I ordered ahead, intending to take it on the road. I realized my phone was in desperate need of a charge and they pointed..."

Kristan Crowell

"Ordered online, they were packed and it was delayed by a bit. The dude with longer hair came out with apology for the wait and couldn’t have been..."

Alex H

"I really enjoyed the atmosphere. The food is..."

Kent Chilson

"My family loves this place. We order weekly. Great food, great service. Bonus points: I was in a rush to get my sandwich. They really helped me get..."

Sheila Bidar

"We’ve ordered here several times and it’s always delicious! They have the best hot subs, the Philly cheesesteak is amazing! Bread is always fresh..."

Crystal Reeves

"Tast like Jersey Mike's subs but the bread you can actually chew. 10 out of 10. Love..."

Lady Winter

"Clean store, kind staff! This was my first time here. I ordered corned beef x2, Genoa salami, pepper jack cheese, parmasean, black olives. Their..."

K M

"Always delicious sandwiches. The bread is amazing. Not the cheapest option, but you get what you pay for. My favorite is the cheese steak. Lots of..."

Tina Wood

"had the chicken Caesar salad and it was fabulous! The lettuce was very fresh and the chicken was cooked perfectly; it was cooked but not overcooked..."

Susan Cavataio

"Best place for a cheesesteak in Ithaca! The bread and the long hots make for a reasonable facsimile of the real..."

Hugh Anderson

"DiBella's catering always does a great job for our GM meetings. Subs/salads are always fresh, condiments and utensils are exactly what we need...."

Robin Carlisle-Peck

"This is my favorite sub shop in town! The staff are wonderful. The food is beyond amazing - fresh and exceeds expectations. Online ordering is a..."

Lori Dorn

"I decided order ahead so when I got done with shopping it would be ready. I got there 5 minutes after it should have been ready but it wasn't. The..."

caitlin spry

"First time going and I was impressed ❤️ Because I didn't know what to order I asked the staff and I ordered a chicken Philly sub and some..."

SingTrece “SingTrece”

"Friendly staff and fast service. If you get a meatball sub you might want to ask for a little extra..."

Marcus Schwartz

Sunset Grill

85/100 (1417 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"This was an amazing place! The view alone was worth coming here. We all ordered different burgers and they were all devoured. Tater tots as an option..."

RaeSharon Alonzo

"I would definitely give this place another try as they seem very well-meaning, and it wasn’t terrible by any means. The view is wonderful from on..."

Tina Dietz

"The view was impeccable, I could see the whole town and the lake below! The service is only down 1 star due to there only being like 2 overwhelmed..."

Emerson Del

"Great breakfast with our dog on a partly rainy Tuesday. Their covered deck had a nice view of the lake as well. Server was accommodating and..."

Nell C

"We were in the area for a trip and googled a brunch spot. The food looked good on the site and we decided to stop here. This place didn’t..."

Jamyra Roberts

"Google listing offered a patio with a view of Cayuga Lake. True enough, but we did not partake as our server warned of the presence of bees. Our..."

Joseph Wagner

"Went up to Ithaca with family for the weekend and opted to dine local instead of going to another chain restaurant. This is a really cute spot..."

Melissa Bolanos

"Out of towners looking for a place to eat. Picked this place for the view of Cayuga Lake. Place sure did not disappoint!! It was beautiful and comfy...."

MJ Fan

"My favorite diner in town. Friendly staff who will get to know you and your order when you come in a few times. Great views of the lake. It's not a..."

Courtney Roby

"Service was awesome (Ashley is great), the outside patio is nice, food was good, portions are generous, and prices are decent. Came in for..."

Rawad Elias

"A favorite, especially for the bacon. Perfect! The hazelnut coffee is a star. Overall, great for the price. Sunset grill isn’t high end, just a..."

Reset

There are 203 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Dinner in Ithaca

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Karim Yaport

Rach H

Aakash Kapoor

Soy B. (SoyB)

Laura Domic

Dan Sweetland

C A

Yuriy T

Jason Galak

Catio (DogDoge)

Giveita Shank

Tyler

Catherine Colley

Caleb Vogt

J G

Shalaila

Stin

Kate Maher

Hsin Yi Wei

Irene JUNG

Ornwara Tritrakarn

mitch davis

FINGERLAKES TASTING & TAP ROOM ADVENTURES

AWillems

Giveita Shank

Noor S.

Glenn Kroll

Jaiden Wood

C Herrick

Daniella Fodera

robb johnsrud

Tenzin Dikyikhangsar

Martin Castonguay

Krystine

Renee Morris

Anna G

Rebecca Weger

Lisa Luciano

Cj Iannuzzi

Stephanie Matthews

Shannon Barnhart Ruhl

José Luis Ferrer III

Allyse Tanovitz

Gwenivere Harrington

MIlo Coyote

Dan Jossen

madonna stallmann

Amy Won

Sheherazahde

Kerry Demarest

Scott Hawley

Yanit Pineiro

Zachary Drucker

Mike Graz

Hilel Mosenzon

Bonnie R. Rabin

D K

Natalie Cross

Diana Andrews

Shannon Willitts

Jess Hollenbeck

Drew Haaland

Jennifer Veit

June Luu

Nikoli's Kitchen

L Smith

Coleman Swartz

Janine Ziermann-Canabarro