Sunset Restaurant

454 Main St, 11751-3429 - Islip
Recommended by Sluurpy: 2025 2024 2021
🏆 #31 of 36 restaurants in Islip
Updated on
€€ American
★★★★★ ★★★★★
4.0/5
172 recommendations

Sluurpy Quality Index

PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
63/100
Data Completeness
67/100

Verified Dish

Add Missing Dish

4.0/5
Sluurpometro: 79/100
Sluurpy Score
172 total reviews
TA Trip
3.5/5
3 reviews
G Google
4.4/5
169 reviews

Rating distribution

5★
1
4★
1
3★
0
2★
0
1★
1
🌳 Outdoor seating 🚚 Delivery 🥡 Takeout 🍽️ Dine-in 📅 Reservations ♿ Wheelchair accessible

💬 What people say

Acai bowls 33 Burger 22 Price 15 Pizza 11 Salads 9 Grilled 6 Burrito bowl 5 Baked 4

Contact Information

📞 Phone: +1 631-581-8200
📍 Address: 454 Main St, Islip

Google Reviews

4.4/5
★★★★★
169 Google reviews
N

Nilsa Godoy

★★★★★ 5/5
Good and fast service, We ordered two pizzas 🍕 Margarita and Meat pizza, I recommend it to you, good price, You have to try it. The place is nice!!
Google
T

Tom Greene

★★★★★ 5/5
Better than your basic pizza joint, the crust is nice and crunchy. Very delicious 😋 picnic tables inside create a casual eating experience.
Google
J

Joe Bitterman

★★★★★ 5/5
Had the Jumbo Angus Burger, Awesome ! Cooked a perfect juicy medium rare with a char flame broiled crust. Alot of flavor ! This was a good size tasty burger. It was hand made not some skinny frozen diner patty, the bun was a large potato bun nicely toasted with fresh crip lettuce & tomato. I asked for regular fries well done, nice job. I don't know about all the other types of Burgers they have, I asked and they said their all hand made fresh as well. Beautiful day, I ate at a front outside sidewalk table, and forgot about life for awhile. A rememberable Burger, love the char crust flavor.
Read more
Google
M

Marie Fischer

★★★★★ 5/5
Just ate a plant based burger from them. It is made from scratch from zucchini, beets, broccoli, carrots, and mushrooms. It is hands down the BEST plant based burger I have ever eaten. I had it with cheddar cheese, and cole slaw to top it off. If you are on the fence, def come in to try it!!!
Google
M

MistaSherman

★★★★☆ 4/5
Came here for a quick bite to eat. Had a regular burger, fries and a drink. It came out to $19.73, and that’s pretty expensive for a burger. I thought I was at Yankee Stadium for a second, and then I saw the Starbucks across the street, then I knew where I was lmao. Took a bite into this burger (that was cooked medium well), and it was burnt around the edges, but really good inside. Bread was burnt too. Overall, a pretty decent burger. It’s not what I wanted for $19.73, but I guess it’s because of how the cook made it, because everyone has their preferences of how a medium well burger should be cooked. Maybe if I do medium next time, it won’t be burnt around the edges. But what I did love was the wait. I love waiting for a burger, cause that’s how I know they they’re freshly made. They also have Stewart’s Orange ‘n Cream soda and that got me really excited. Overall, experience was nice. I’ll be back to see how the burger will be if I get it cooked medium.
Read more
Google
A

Alizabeth Rose

★★★★★ 5/5
Love everything I've Tried and I've tried just about everything..🍔🍔🍔Burgers are delicious and so many to choose from the vegan burger to veggie and Angus and salmon burgers I cant choose a favorite they are ALL Amazing and the wings Yum Yummy! Acai Bowls are the best I've had. Love the cozy atmosphere and the seating here makes you feel as safe as can be ..winner winner chicken wing Dinner !
Read more
Google
J

j s

★★★★★ 5/5
The staff is ALWAYS friendly on the phone and the two women that are usually there are absolutely pleasant. They give the vibe that they’re ACTUALLY happy you’re there. The vibe is cool and the deco is much needed in an old islip like run of the mill village . It’s different for sure. They’re opening a new location that’s similar at the islip town beach with alcohol....check it out! The food: we’ve had the baked crab, a Burst of flavor and definitely not something you find everywhere. The chicken Caesar wrap checks all the boxes, the lobster Mac is outrageous with so much fresh lobster, and the salads are really great and wholesome. My ONLY WISH is that they would get a little bit bigger salad bowls for take out....just a TAD bigger. ALL of the food is hot and fresh even taking it out and getting it home. Please support this local hidden gem!!!!!
Read more
Google
B

B

★★★★★ 5/5
I Love their turkey burger platter. It is very tasty. Order it twice a week sometimes :) Their homemade soups are DELICIOUS too. Really enjoy their Honey mustard dressing it's my favorite dressing there. They should bottle it. I'm usually a balsamic vinaigrette type of girl, but I do enjoy that honey mustard!
Read more
Google
V

Victoria Petrino

★★★★★ 5/5
Yummy and super fresh food. And satisfying portions too. Lots of choices on the regular menu and daily specials as well. The staff and owner are very nice, knowledgeable and accommodating. The atmosphere is casual and comfortable. I've been there twice and look forward to trying the rest of the menu.
Read more
Google
H

Holly Pichardo

★★★★★ 5/5
I was very sorry to read the few bad reviews. I have been coming for about 6 months every couple of days and really enjoy the food and the service. I have never heard an owner shout or treat an employee disrespectfully nor have I ever been approached by the owner for any other reason than to thank me for my patronage. And P.S., I've been to Sobel across the street and did not care for their Acai bowl. It was also more $$. The music was so loud and banging I couldn't wait to get outside. I'm a fan of LI Beach Bowls!
Read more
Google

Explore more in Islip

Help improve this page:
← Back to all restaurants in Islip

🍽️ Suggest a dish

⚠️ Report error

🚫 Report closed

Do you confirm that Sunset Restaurant has permanently closed?