Marys Pizza Pasta is the best Italian restaurant on the South Shore. The food is always delicious and the portions are generous. Their prices are reasonable and offer specials every night. They have price fix dinners Monday through Thursday including salad, entree and dessert. The chicken rollatini and eggplant rollatini are my favorite! Give it a try you won't be disappointed!
I go to all Mary's locations and have never been let down. The meatballs are the best I have had. I have had parties in the catering rooms as well and the staff has always gone beyond the call of duty to accommodate all guests. I highly recommend Mary's pizza and pasta.
I have not eaten here in person yet, but I ordered through an app. The slices were delicious that I had, and this time, I also received calzones. So far, I enjoyed all the slices except for the pasta stice. Just pizza and pasta don't feel like they are meant to be together, in my opinion.
Love the food. Great service and friendly staff. I only have 2 complaints. I often order the same slice as a friend of mine. The sizes are hit or miss. One time my slice was less than half the size of my friends. It made for a good laugh. I suppose I got the diet slice. Also, very minor, the cups they give you when you ask for the free water are comically small. I think they want to discourage you from getting the water. But soda is so expensive lately. I just can't see speeding near 3 dollars for sugar water. But all restaurants are like this, so do I understand. And I get more exercise having to get up to refill my cup. So win win for me.
I mean what kinda place goes above and beyond like Marys? Always willing to help and the food is amazing. Service here is second to none. Someone new starts, doesn't matter. That person Is instilled hard work and amazing service. Thanks for being the best, always.
I love the cheesy knots and penne a la vodka either before or after my lessons or horseback competitions. Mary’s is lucky to have Emma as a server. she is extraordinary!
Ordered a Chicken Parm pie and it was amazing. It had thin crust with sesame. Everything from cheese to chicken tasted very fresh and tasteful. I will definitely be ordering again from here in the future.
We ate dinner at this restaurant last night and really enjoyed it. The ambiance was nice and the service was great. We both enjoyed our food. I had the seafood FraDiablo over spinach (low carb)and my husband had the veal cutlet parmesan. The portions were large and the food was good. He also got the baked clams as an appetizer and said they were good also. The only thing I could complain about was the muscles in my dish. I thought they tasted a little off so I only ate the shrimp and the calamari. I would order the same dish again but without the muscles. The food is reasonably priced and you got a soup or a salad with your meal. They have an outside dining area which also had couches for having drinks. They have live music on Friday and Saturday night outside which is very nice.
First time here. I had the spinach and artichoke slice and it was fantastic. Had a regular slice as well and it did not disappoint. I will definitely be back to try their meals. Its a nice restaurant and the staff was helpful and friendly. Prices are reasonable.
Came here for a surprise party. I ordered ther personal pie and asked the waitress how big it was and the size she described was not what I got. The pie was HUGE. Definitely couldn't eat more than two slices. I got the chicken bomber . It was good but had so much chicken and not a lot of anything else . I would recommend but def ask for extra sauce
My children and I love this pizza it’s so good. This is the only restaurant we order pizza from now .
Everything is constantly good. Eggplant, chicken parm, stuffed shells, linguine with clam sauce, even the meatballs and I'm fussy about meatballs, my mom's italian and I usually only eat mom's or my own. Great service. Would be 5 stars except atmosphere and a little noisy.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Islip Terrace
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes