The best Lobster Roll in Islamorada | Sluurpy updated in April

Meat Eatery And Taproom

91/100 (2646 ratings)

Restaurants

American

Bar

American

Dinner

Lunch

Late Night

Salad

Wings

Mac and cheese

Duck

Lobster Roll

French Fries

Sandwiches

Chicken Sandwich

Cheeseburger

BLT

Bread Pudding

Burger

Pulled Pork Sandwich

Hamburgers

Pimento Cheese

Turkey Burger

Lamb

Fish

Beef

Pork

Lobster

Pasta

Sit down

American

Seating

Wheelchair Accessible

Serves Alcohol

Wine and Beer

Parking Available

Free Wifi

Accepts Credit Cards

Takeout

Television

Dinner

Lunch

Mid-range

"Amazing food and drinks. Among the best burgers I've had. Also had the banana bread vanilla milkshake special. Only wish I lived near this place...."

ArMorris

"Great food, interesting decor, friendly service. Very busy, very small place (looks like a hole in the wall from the street but super cool inside),..."

MAMA Bookasaurus

"Food was great. We had a Juicy Lucy which was incredible. Beer selection awesome. Meat is a great option when you get tired of seafood in the keys!..."

Mark Filichia

"Excellent food. I had the veggie burger and my partner had the chicken bahnmi special. Both were fantastic. Beer and drink selection was very good as..."

Lmd123

"EAT HERE! Driving through the Keys you probably want somewhere outside that serves fish and conch fritters. Take a break from that! If you love meat..."

Hungry Fl Girl

"Great burgers, great music, great service. The hamburger buns are..."

Frances Find

"The food was delicious and the service outstanding. Everything they have they make in house, including their ketchup and mustard. It was probably the..."

Miah Sack

"This was the best burger I have ever had. Enough..."

Biff

"Fabulous. A small place that makes as much of their own stuff as possible, including the ketchup and mustard. The specials looked interesting, but we..."

Bill Joyce

"Best Hot Dogs Ever!. We eat here regularly as they have the best Sabrett hotdogs I have ever had. Starting with the fresh, toasted bread to the push..."

Lilos

"Stopped today for lunch. Its a small plaza in a small plaza but let me tell you the the black and bleu burger was outstanding and the fries so yummy...."

RV

"Stupid, crazy good. Don't go for the decor...go for the food! the mushroom burger (grilled, marinated portobello) was the best I've had and my..."

Jorgina

"Wow. Our family stopped here for lunch and we ended up having the best burger of my life. My 11 year old son was a little nervous about his fries..."

Dr Dave

"Best restaurant I've eaten at. Home made bacon, duck fat fries, home made ketchup.... What more can I..."

Merlin Jensen

"Hands down best burger I have had in awhile. Had the House burger, nothing fancy but the classic Lettuce, tomato and cheese is hard to beat with a..."

Asa Monson

"The lamb burger was so good I made an urban spoon just to say that. The Oreo cookies and cream bread pudding was tdf too. This place is..."

Cassielou

"Worth going out of your way for!. My husband and I stopped by for a quick dinner and a drink. I got the American Kobe Burger, no cheese, added bacon..."

Aerinea

"I had the Turkey burger with fried onion strings, delicious. Hubby had the inside out juicy lucy burger with truffled bistro fries, yummy. We want to..."

Steve And Jasmine

"Really awesome addition to the Keys. It was high time there was a foodie place down here. We come to Islamorada two or three times a year and this..."

Patty Khuly

"Good solid burger - husband had a standard burger and I had a lamb burger with blue cheese and onions - very very good. Fries are good and crisp,..."

Sylvia Ruby Imm

"Can't go wrong. The food was delish. I had a burger and fries - don't remember the exact one but I do remember how wonderful it tasted. I wish we had..."

Brip

"Classy surprise!. After 10 days of fish we were ready for a change & found MEAT. Not only excellent food but very unique choices. Lamb sliders!!..."

Orthopedics2

"Best burger in recent memory. We decided to drop in after getting a rec from a coworker. the food was spectacular. we shared a cheeseburger and the..."

Liz

"Great place! Nice beer and wine selection. Food is outstanding! We had the pork rinds, onion strings, Asian Turkey burger, and an inside out loosey..."

Jne

"Worth a two-hour drive.... ...on a friend's recommendtion -- time well spent! Amazing draft beer selection complemented well-prepared eats: we had..."

Astrosquirrel

"You can’t really tell very much from the outside of MEAT Eatery and Taproom. When I walked in I had that feeling…you know the one….the “this..."

Burger Beast

"We had dinner with friends. Burgers were great ! Service was quick! They added gratuity and there was no wait staff, we ordered at the counter..."

Lo Ja

"What a great burger place. I had a Juicy Lucy burger with cheese, and it was the best tasting burger I have had in a while. In fact, I didn't even..."

carol maurer

"Not flashy on the outside, but such an amazing meal and atmosphere! Fresh catch of the day sandwich and Black & Blue burger were phenomenal. Homemade..."

Kaitlin McGugin

"Amazing burgers! I got the lamb burger it was excellent. Husband got the inside out burger. He said it was amazing and our friends got the fancy..."

Kimberly Johansen

"I really can’t say enough about this place. I’ve eaten there 6 or 7 times. The service is always great. They are helpful and super down to earth...."

Clinton Agidius

"Got take out one night as we needed a break from seafood. Husband had the double burger and fries, he loved his. I had the pulled pork sandwich which..."

Amy Lynn

"Stopped in for some drinks and appetizers. The food was excellent and the drinks were good. Strongly recommend the pork rinds, they were so good we..."

Richard Kober

"Great burger, I had the inside-out Juicy Lucy. Very good. The Fry's were very well seasoned as well and also great. Great burger..."

Martin Tate

"I had a wonderful dining experience recently at MEAT Eatery And Taproom in Key Largo, Florida. Our supper was made even more enjoyable by our waiter,..."

omar minou

"Captain Bob Loves their burgers! The burger had a special flavor. I can’t say I ever had. I had a burger with cheddar cheese, smoked bacon,..."

Reset

There are 4 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Lobster Roll in Islamorada

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

ArMorris

MAMA Bookasaurus

Mark Filichia

Lmd123

Hungry Fl Girl

Frances Find

Miah Sack

Biff

Bill Joyce

Lilos

RV

Jorgina

Dr Dave

Merlin Jensen

Asa Monson

Cassielou

Aerinea

Steve And Jasmine

Patty Khuly

Sylvia Ruby Imm

Brip

Orthopedics2

Liz

Jne

Astrosquirrel

Burger Beast

Lo Ja

carol maurer

Kaitlin McGugin

Kimberly Johansen

Clinton Agidius

Amy Lynn

Richard Kober

Martin Tate

omar minou

Robert Bloome

BJORN VAN DEN BREMT

key lime

Stephanie Findlay

Jo Patman

Frida Nguyen

Clement Amato

Julie wingate

Daniel Ocampo

Zerbe Adventures

Ron Tiah

Dan Henry

Amanda

Gumbie Island Vibes

Carmine Valentino

Greg Rampy

Lana Boychuk

Geneve

Randy and Trish Lake

Jacqueline Bruin

Joseph Buckles

Brian Stubler

Luis Enrique GQM

Oliver David

Lorraine S

Razz Val

somkietr rojanasathit

brenda denton

Jamy

Sluurpy

Useful links