Beat pizza I've ever ate, and I eat a lot of pizza. We had medium with a garlic crust flavoring, chicken, bacon, mushroom, and banana peppers. The crust was perfect, the sauce was spot on.
Great service - loved the Tuscan pizza. We played on the piano and entertained the staff while they prepared our pizza. :)
Really good “up north” pizza. The Buffalo Chicken was generously topped and had some OK heat - I added some habanero hot sauce to fire it up. The crust is doughy, so if you like crispier crust, ask for a well done bake or throw it in the oven or maybe reheat over a campfire once you get back to your spot. Salads are made with iceberg, so we added some spring mix because that’s our preference. Great phone customer service, too.
The pricing is clear-cut. There are no hidden prices, unlike other pizza places. Service was top-notch. Made my date and I feel like we were someone special walking in the door. The employees kept making us laugh and chuckle. Felt like I was visiting some old time friends.
Me and my friend stopped in and the pizza was so good! It was freshly baked and was very good quality. The man working there was very nice and the service overall was great! 10/10 would recommend to a friend, and definitely will be returning!
I just love this place!!! The owners are awesome people! The food is delicious and sometimes the pizza 🍕 is so hot that you can't touch it for a few lol! Been ordering from Cicero's since my twenties and I'm now fifty five!!!
They are so kind and generous here. The Tuscan is my personal favorite. The small is the size of most places mediums so a large is plenty for myself, my husband and our ravenous teen. We will definitely be back.
This is a take out only location.....but don't let that stop you from ordering!! The best pizza my husband and I have ever had! Especially when you add Mike's Hot Honey drizzled on top! We stopped in, ordered and then had a wonderful conversation with one of the owners who gave recommendations about the area!
My dad and I ordered a pizza about 45 min before closing, the person on the phone was super friendly and when we picked up the pizza the service was amazing- above and beyond! Now when I say this pizza was unrivaled, I mean it- super fresh, perfectly cooked- wish we lived closer but we'll definitely be back!
Great pizza for a decent price. We ordered a large pepperoni and large sausage. The pizza was cooked to perfection and had a perfectly crisp crust. Everyone in our house enjoyed it. The place seemed clean and well kept. If I planned to stay in town longer, I'd definitely order from here again.
By far the best pizza I’ve ever had. Not to mention the kindest people work here. We might have been 5.5 hours from home, but we were treated like family with a place at the table. I cannot recommend this place enough. The drive is worth it just for this pizza. The dough was fluffy and flavorful. The pepperoni was just the right amount of spice. AND the cheese was ooey-gooey deliciousness. I would give 6 stars if I could. This is the way a business should be run.
I absolutely love this place! Been going here for years now. It is a little pricey but what isn't today. Food, service, and atmosphere is top notch!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Interlochen
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes