Colin Bucki
Old school pizza joint vibes and the slices dont disappoint. Even just cheese is very tasty! Will be back for sure! Nice staff as well!
Matt
I love coming here. It's nothing fancy, no thrills and no frills. Just some really good pizza and a really nice owner and his son I believe. He definitely will recognize you if you're a regular. Only complaint is that they close at 6 PM on weekdays, but if it's just the two of them, that's a full shift and I can't blame them. Bottom line, this is the place for a great quick lunch.
Elijah Easterday
Great service and great pie. Saw several reviews about pizza being 'reheated' before serving, but that's how any pizza by the slice place does it. The food is always high quality and the people are even better. A must-visit in downtown Indy
Jeff Hoelscher
Very clean store and friendly staff. The pizza was very good with just the right amount of chheese and toppings. The slices are really big. I eat way too much and two slices were a full meal. I’ll definitely go back. Thank you!
John L. Davis
A friendly place with good food. Very fast service behind the counter. They have a large selection of items with almost endless toppings.
The guy behind the counter was super friendly and greeted everyone on the way in and thanked them on the way out. That is what justifies the #5 star from me.
Mylissa Compton
Stuffed meat pizza! The name alone should get your mouth watering. We stopped by on the way to work to grab a slice and some breadsticks. We usually order a whole stuffed meat pizza with extra garlic but not this trip. Great customer service as always. A nice selection of pizzas and calzones. They also have lunch specials and a customer loyalty card.
D.D Hampton
I love the pizza and pepperoni bread sticks. The guys that work in there are really nice..
Denise Stockton
Probably 1 of the best if not the best place for anything Italian!! Fast, fresh & delicious.
Nathan Harris
I'm not a big fan of pizza-by-the-slice joints, but the crew that runs this shop is top notch and their Strombolis are amazing!
Emily F
$9 deal with slice, breadsticks, and drink. Great breadsticks, okay pizza. Great for a quick lunch spot. Friendly and quck staff.
Daniel D
Solid pizza, one slice fills you up. Breadsticks are excellent. the food is inexpensive. I went here for lunch at least once a week when I worked downtown.
The staff kinda pushes you through the line as quickly as possible which I guess is an authentic New York experience. There's not really a spot to ponder the menu from, so try to know what you want to eat before you get there.
Chris McGuire
It was quiet when I stopped in on a Saturday evening around 6pm. That made me nervous but I was pleasantly surprised. The service was good as well as the good. Good prices I think too. I had pepperoni pizza, a pepperoni bread stick, regular bread stick and cheese dip. Definitely would stop again.
Anisha
Good (and huge) NY style pizza by the slice and excellent service. The fact that it's a small local pizzeria (when there's mostly chain restros around here), in downtown, and is run by the friendliest of people make it go from four to an all rounded five stars. Will definitely be coming by again when in the area
Guillermo Guerrero
Fresh. Tasty. Hot. Downtown Indy needs to be restored.
Asuma Sarutobi
I've spent a lot of time in NYC so there are many times I really miss a good New York pie and other so called "New York pizza" joints just don't cut it except for a desperate fix
This is definitely the place to get it! Will come again whenever I'm back in town!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes