Sluurpy
Reset

There are 7 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Grilled cheese in Indianapolis

There are 7 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Milktooth
90/100 (2363 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Cafe
Gluten Free Options
American
Vegan Options
Cafe
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Brunch
Breakfast
Lunch
Raclette
Cakes
Lamb
Pancakes
Salad
Wings
Oyster
Sandwiches
Toasts
Burger
Grilled cheese
Waffles
Café
American
Café
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Accepts Credit Cards
Brunch
Breakfast
Lunch
Mid-range
"One of my favorite brunch spots. Haven’t been here in a few years and it was as good / better than I remember. Such a fun spot on a cute..."
Stephanie O'Callaghan
"We recently visited Milktooth and had brunch with our son. We had not been there in awhile and we were so happy to know that the food was as..."
DeAnna Murphy - Murphy Group Realtors
"We really enjoyed our visit to Milktooth! The food was delicious and vibe of the restaurant was great. We did arrive 10 minutes before they opened on..."
Raegan Garnett
"We've been wanting to go to Milktooth for years and it did not disappoint. We got there as it opened and had to wait over an hour, but we didn't mind..."
Sarah Irwin
"We had waffle ( only one option) and crab cakes. We went for brunch, the vibe was perfect, taste was perfect and ambience is great but there are not..."
kshitija sulakhe
"4.5/5 Have been planning got to try Milktooth forever! I visited on a Saturday brunch time and expected a long line, but fortunately i was seated..."
Ghadeer AlMuhaisen
"I think 4 1/2 stars 🌟 is the perfect rating for Milktooth. Delicious food, made with love. Modest selection. Reasonable prices. Good service...."
Jerry Foltz
"Service and food were amazing! Wonderful flavor combinations that kept surprising us with every plate that arrived. Highly recommend for foodies and..."
schollat
"The food was delicious I have a sourdough waffle with scrambled eggs with cheese and bacon. The bacon was little bit of..."
Rissa Masengo
"Hands down the best brunch spot in Indy. Menu offers seasonal delights and a varietal take on tried and true staples. Staff is welcoming. Worth the..."
Hilary Andrews
"Dusty our server was great. The food is always amazing. This is our favorite restaurant. We will be..."
Kenn DeHart
"Excellent food, coffee drinks, service, and great atmosphere! Everything was freshly made and tasted delicious. Highly recommend for a brunch..."
Shawnda Hollon
"Food is to die for! Can't go wrong with that delicious mint lavender syrup for that sweet tea. So relaxing as I had the best Dutch baby pancake of..."
Samantha Garvey
"Shared a brunch menu tour and was absolutely obsessed with the masala savory dutch baby. Make sure to get here early enough to get in line and snag a..."
Nicki Rough
"The breakfast Sammy was awesome. A nice mix of spicy, smoky and so tasty. The Dutch baby was very good too. Sweet, lemony and really good (but not..."
Chris Pacifico
"Cute little spot for breakfast/brunch. We went during the weekend, and there was a bit of a wait. Friendly service. Food was great. A bit pricey, but..."
Sarah Salahuddin
"Came right at lunch time, and was prepared for a long wait, but was impressed with how efficiently we were seated. Honestly, if we had waited for an..."
Mallory Sailors
Shoefly Public House
90/100 (454 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
American
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Duck
Tapas
Tacos
Hummus
Nachos
Sandwiches
Pretzel
Burger
BLT
Grilled cheese
"4/21/18: Friendly service again today. Meatloaf again came with the hash and everything was delicious and perfectly cooked, but I much preferred..."
Lindsey Roy
"We love Shoefly! At first I didn't fully embrace the structure of the menu; most of the items stand alone and you don't automatically get a side...."
Sarah Mink
"One of the best spots in Indy. I have never eaten something I wouldn't again, which is why I have to keep going back! Everything on the menu is made..."
Geoff DeSmit
"Friendly staff, great service! Ecclectic menu, food was..."
Janine McKinney
"It was predictably excellent. I love being able to have such good food in such a comfortable casual atmosphere. Service was good, server was very..."
Mark Finney
"Delicious food with exciting ingredients at a reasonable price! Great beer list, picnic table outdoor seating on the east side of the building let..."
Amy Lynn Budd
"I hate Shoefly because the food is too damn good. Both times I've been both the food and service were out of this world. Will definitely be..."
Kegan Kegley
"What a fantastic dinner at Shoefly! I had the BLT with avocado and loved it. So much delicious, crispy bacon! The house pickles were a delight! Then..."
Staci Fahlsing
"One of the best meals I've had in recent history. From start to finish the food and service were..."
Bruce James Bales
"Why does Facebook only have five stars? There should be six stars. Because Shoefly Public House is that great. I could rave about the sandwiches,..."
Robby Slaughter
The Eagle Mass Ave
87/100 (5212 ratings)
Bars & Pubs
Restaurants
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Brew Pub
Barbecue
American
Brew Pub
Vegetarian Friendly
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Shrimp
Pasta
Salad
Mac and cheese
Chicken Sandwich
Kale Salad
Po' Boys
Sandwiches
Grilled cheese
American
Brew Pub
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Seating
Accepts Discover
Lunch
Drinks
Dinner
Mid-range
"This fried chicken was moist and crunchy, it was a good portion. It’s seasoned well, usually people add hot sauce or I add ranch and it really..."
Tyler
"This place is great. It may be tough to find parking as there is limited spaces in front of the restaurant. Please find a spot because this food was..."
Ebony Navarrete
"The Eagle, a convivial eatery and beer hall, has successfully captured the essence of Southern comfort cuisine while infusing it with a modern and..."
Kaiser Brodie
"I've been here twice, and The Eagle doesn't disappoint!! I had their Chicken BLT sandwich, and shrimp & grits. So good. Also tried some of their..."
Shara Hatton
"This is a awesome spot to have lunch at today! Our service was excellent, very speedy since we were just on a lunch hour in the building, an..."
Mackenzie Williams
"Party of 5 on a Monday night. Waited at bar for 25mins but atmosphere and employees are very pleasant. Food was awesome and sides especially stood..."
Liam Paschen
"One of the best meals I’ve ever had. The hush puppies and biscuits/honey butter/jam being our top faves 🤤 We went there for the chicken, but..."
Lindsay Jacobs
"We started with the bacon and it was really tasty. A perfect blend of spice and sweetness. Then everyone ordered the chicken. The chicken is really..."
Ashley Payne
"Service was excellent. Went around 6 on a Sunday with a party of 4. Seated right away. Our waitress was great. Establishment is very clean...."
Ms Miller (Amanda)
"I can not say enough about the food. It was amazing! Started with the hush puppies and an order of bacon. Both were next level. Bacon was crisp..."
Christof Will
"Good spot good food! Today Robbie was amazing! She is a total vibe. Her ability to serve is top tier! I loved her and she will always go the distance..."
Devon Roberson
"The food was delicious. I wanted to go back the next day but I live too far away. We ordered 4 items and were all delicious (which is rare) also our..."
dale haddock jr
"Best Spicy Chicken Sandwich in my opinion. Flavor is spot-on, meat is cooked to perfection, nice crunch. And the spice? It’s there, but it’s not..."
Joe Ybarra
"I stopped by The Eagle tonight to get food and a couple cocktails. Olivia S. was an amazing waitress. She was on top of everything. I would..."
Ryan DePew
"Robbie was absolutely fantastic. Just the right mix of zest, sass and helpfulness that has seemingly been lost in the restaurant..."
J T (Spoon)
"The food here is fantastic! We went in a group of six so everyone bought a different appetizer or side to share so we could try several things since..."
Vanessa Kenworthy
"I can’t rave enough about the fried chicken and the shrimp and grits. I make it a ritual to come here every time I’m in town for work. Omg and..."
Aaron-Albert Hargrove
Yard House
86/100 (6661 ratings)
Restaurants
Bars & Pubs
Quick Bites
Bar
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Bar
American
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Crab
Grilled cheese
Nachos
Calamari
Jambalaya
Cobb Salad
Tuna
Calamares
Queso
Noodle
California Roll
Shrimp
Pesto
Beef
Crab Cake
Fish
Fish & Chips
Pork
Tapas
Lobster
Fish Taco
Pancakes
Tacos
Fish & chips
Swordfish
Pasta
Ribs
Salad
Wings
Sandwiches
Clam Chowder
Cheeseburger
Mac and cheese
Burger
American
Bar
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Brunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"This place is amazing! No, exception about it! The food, the service and atmosphere are just enjoyable! Our waiter Austin, was amazing and the..."
Pat Wilgocki
"Nice atmosphere with big dining area. All their staff are amicable. Liked the food as well. Their happy hour deal is a must..."
Farhana Afroj
"We had a big party so maybe that's why the food wasn't as hot as it probably could have been. Nothing was nasty but I just wish the food was a little..."
Jarel Washington
"The parm truffle fries are great’s. Had those for an appetizer and enjoyed them thoroughly. Had the whiskey burger and that was really damn good. ..."
BMF Garage
"It took a minute for us to get a waiter due to miscommunication. Other than that, we enjoyed our visit. I love the brussel sprouts and kale salad. My..."
R. W.
"Visited Sunday morning on game day. We had a party of 9. Server took great care of us. Food was excellent! Lots of beer..."
Jason Marsh
"Got quickly seated, server was very attentive and friendly, good came out quickly and was quite good. The queso has a little spice to it and was..."
Nich Gray
"We got the sliders and the Korean style cheesesteak (forgot what it was called). For dessert, we got the banana pudding. So good, everything was hot..."
Sarah Salahuddin
"This is my first time I visited this restaurant in Indianapolis. If you like sweets like me you must try their cheese cake. That’s the best cake I..."
Kavita Tawadarre
"It’s been a long time since I’ve been to Yard House (a few years I believe). Finally after all this time, I got to make a revisit this..."
The Elevator and Airplane Finder
"The food was really good and packed with flavor and our server was always there when needed but they blasted music and the TV was so loud that we had..."
Andrew Hizer
"Some of the best service we've had in Indianapolis! We left the Sugar Factory after the service was atrocious and walked across the street to the..."
Jessica Johnston
"I was dining with a friend who has a severe mushroom allergy. The restaurant accommodated us by making sure the surrounding tables did not have..."
Isma “Izzy”
"Probably the largest selection of draft beer in Indy. Over 100 taps. The service very friendly and the food ok. The Truffle Cheese burger was nice...."
Matthijs Bil
"The food was phenomenal. One of our vendors hosted a small get together and the service was amazing. Very attentive to everyone and there were lots..."
nasha nicole
"I had the sesame crusted ahi tuna dish and to be honest I was dumbfounded by how delicious it was. It is easily one of the top three dishes I’ve..."
S7117
"Right in the busy Circle Center Mall district of downtown Indianapolis. Delicious selection of New American food. Flavored teas and lemonades. Loud..."
Mrs. Charissa Graham
"We loved this place so much that we went multiple times during our visit to Indy. Every app and entree was amazing and the customer service was..."
Sueann
Macniven's Restaurant & Bar
85/100 (1579 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Pub
Vegetarian Friendly
American
British
Scottish
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Grilled cheese
Beef
Salad
Fish & Chips
Roast Beef
Sandwiches
Burger
"Absolutely the best place to have delicious food, I had tuna salad and and chicken curry is really delicious and the food is cooked really nicely and..."
Bella North
"Absolutely the best fish and chips in Indy. Try the haggis - it's an amazing chorus - not dissimilar from the 'Jet Song' scene from West Side Story...."
Greg Pilcher
"Fun atmosphere and decor, warm and friendly staff, flavorful, hearty food and generous portions. Had the veggie haggis, peeps, and tatties. Really..."
Whimsical.ladybug
"Stopped in for a quick drink and snack. We made a good choice! Our bartender/server was the fastest ever! Great service. The Scotch egg was perfect..."
Robbie
"Great food and atmosphere. When you go (notice WHEN) you have to have the Scottish Egg. You won't be..."
JoeAquatics
"If you have to pick one place to eat in Indianapolis. ..This needs to be it!. I found this place by chance as a off handed semi recommendation of a..."
Schneeweib
"Excellent service, great food, great beer. I highly..."
Topdogfroyo
"Hey Egg Drop Erin, I thought this place was loud too! What's up with that?. Okay, so other reviewers say that this place was loud too, and now I've..."
Professional Eater Mike
"The service is really amazing.. Every service-person in this establishment gets an A+. If they're slow enough the bartenders will try to remember..."
Tiffnay Kay McIntire
"Great Place. Service is wonderful. Stuart is a Gem. You should check it out. We go here to get away from our kids and have a bite. Great veggie..."
Julie Byfield Pearson
"The best pub food in..."
William Potter
"Always a great place to eat, have fun, and best of all, great people, and fantastic food! Love warm spring and summer nights at the window watching..."
Steven B
"Bar & Service were great but the food only okay. We liked the look and atmosphere of the bar and the service was good. The food was pretty average at..."
Mhav2k
"All the drama from past posts aside I got to try this place and was very impressed. Since it was my first visit I went for the fish and chips. I..."
Tracy
"This place is pretty great. Fish and chips are probably the best in town. I don't know what kind of vendetta the guy at the bottom has against this..."
J Street
"Dessert. The best bread pudding I've ever had in my life!!! SO GOOD! Warm, moist and not too sweet, just..."
Melissa Bradley
"Thumbs up. I had very good and fast service here on a Saturday evening from my waiter. They let you have little samples of food and drink before..."
Dan
"After reading a couple of the poor reviews on this site, I felt I needed to put my two cents in. I have visited this place on several occasions and..."
Joseph Ritter
"Food and beer is amazing. We usually get fish and chips and haggis. Best fish and chips in town-- and we've tried a lot of..."
DNAbrams
"Worth a visit!. AWESOME beer menu & the burger just has to be..."
Andrew
"Not a fan of fare from the Isles, I gotta say, I really like this place. Hearty steak fries, great flat grilled burgers, excellent beef stew and..."
Garlicaper.com
"Gotta try the Angus Burger w/ Fat Onion Rings. One of my favorite things in town.Also, MacNiven's offers a monster beer menu. I think the count..."
Nibbler
"Great Food and Beer. This is still our favorite English/Scottish/Irish resturant in the Midwest...Extensive beer menu...Small pub food menu but great..."
Mbastuk
"Special place in my heart. And a special place in my alcohol problem! great pub food, haggis is a must try at some point of everyone's life. the beer..."
Christian
"Good food and beer. I really enjoyed the atmosphere of MacNiven's. They offered a nice selection of beers on tap, and the had a variety of vegetarian..."
Maddie
"Good selection of beer and..."
Trevor Yager
"Best Bar in Indy. MacNiven's has the widest selection of beers in Indy, and an ever-changing tap smorgasbord. On warm summer days, they open the..."
SMC Nola
"My first-born son and I decided to recognize his Birthday with lunch; rather than dinner. Initially it was to be Saturday dinner but he got some..."
Benson Skelton
"We had the Vegetarian Curry, Clam chowder and Shrimp & Chips. Everything was excellent AND the owner brought the food out and told us a little about..."
Samara Dulik
"My husband and I have been here twice from the recommendation of my parents! Both times super good food/drinks and the fastest service anywhere we..."
Justina McDougal
"We chose to celebrate my birthday at MacNiven's this year. It had been a least 11 years since my last visit and that was too long. When I used to..."
Brad Anderson
"Pretty good Scottish food in the U.S. Will go back for sure next time we are in Indy. The service was good and food came out super fast. You get a..."
Alisha
"Scottish American pub style restaurant. I ventured here thanks to Devour Indy. The food and atmosphere was great and very fast. Looked like there..."
Aimee Holsclaw
"It has a pub feeling, but the dining area was rather loud. The (GIANT) onion rings were fantastic and filling. The mashed potatoes that came with the..."
Max Pham
"A cool little restaurant/bar on Mass Ave. The atmosphere really nice. The Scottish eggs are to die for. The hamburger is different being rolled flat..."
Paul Gaddie
"Live nearby but never tried it because it always looked busy, and I haven't been impressed by the American options in Indy so far. Well, I was..."
Christine Chern (陳筠)
"One of my favorite places in town to go. Their Scotch Eggs are great, and so is just about everything that I've ever ordered. Love it. In the..."
A J
"I had a beverage tonight and really enjoyed the window dining because the weather was perfect. I want to try their onion rings, haggis and bread..."
Pat Lacey
Punch Burger
83/100 (4435 ratings)
Quick Bites
Bar
Fast food
Pub
American
American
Fast Food
Dinner
Lunch
Grilled cheese
Beef
Duck
Waffle Fries
Turkey Burger
Sandwiches
Cheeseburger
Burger
Sit down
American
Bar
Pub
Fast food
Serves Alcohol
Takeout
Reservations
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"We were staying downtown and wanted lunch. Came across Punch Burger and we are glad we came in and ordered lunch. They have plenty of unique burgers..."
Hugh McLaughlin
"Everything I could ask for from a gourmet burger restaurant. The make your own burger menu has tons of choices and I love that they offer duck turkey..."
Craig Pederson
"We ordered 2 burgers, waffle fries, 1 drink and 1 milkshake and they gave us the 2 drinks on the house. Food was delicious. Our Texan burger was..."
Bessie Gessner
"Simply amazing! We dropped in while on a @bandsofamerica grand nationals trip- and this is a MUST STOP! I got the burnt cheeseburger on a pretzel..."
Kimberly Poe
"Nice local burger spot. Plenty of options available and they will make it to your liking. Waffle fries are terrific! Service was fast and friendly...."
Jay Ball
"Ahhhhmazing burger! And the waffle cut fries were even better! Great atmosphere and super fast delivery. Great place for..."
Cassie Collins
"Burger was prepared well and the fries were excellent. They're waffle fries, so beware if you don't like that style. I made a small order mistake and..."
Brad Kingsley
"This place has amazing burgers and sides. It's well worth a trip downtown. They also deliver via grubhub. It's not expensive for the quality of food..."
Paul Ward
"Punch burger is a best place to customize your own burger with fillings and addons. They have good vegetarian options as well!! Try different breads...."
Praharsh M. Patel
"A little pricey for lunch, but you get more waffle fries than a person should probably try to consume in one sitting.. and God bless them for that! ..."
Nathan Harris
"Very interesting selection of unique burgers. I tried the limited time selection Chorizo burger. Chorizo as a burger patty was an amazing idea and..."
Brandon Sloan
"Jalapeno Popper burger was legit. Tried waffles fries and the sweet potato tots. Everything was hot and tasted..."
Blaine Rout
"Damn good burger! Waffle fries were tasty too! Good beer selection! Friendly staff! Fair prices! Will be back again! Highly..."
Emily Springer
"I’ll admit, I’m reviewing before I even receive my food. These folks have great personality. They’re all properly wearing masks. They’re..."
Sunshine Aria
"We're from out of town and chose punch burger for a quick meal. The burgers were delicious - we had the punch burger and the Thai. The sweet potato..."
Joanna J
"Friendly service and the food was excellent. I got the burnt cheese burger and it was sooo good. I'll be..."
Kayla Maley
"Got the burnt cheese burger. My wife had the chicken burger. And waffle fries . The best. Will be going..."
curtis wilson
Three Sisters Cafe
78/100 (1425 ratings)
Restaurants
Cafe
Deli
American
Gluten Free Options
Deli
Cafe
American
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Brunch
Breakfast
Lunch
French Toast
Toasts
Pancakes
Eggplant
Salad
Omelette
Chili
BLT
Salmon
Biscuits and gravy
Fish Taco
Burger
Hummus
Grilled cheese
Burrito
Tortillas
Fast food
American
Deli
Café
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Brunch
Breakfast
Lunch
Mid-range
"The wait to get into this place was crazy. However, we were blown away by the kindness of the lady who took our name and our waitress. Both were so..."
Wilson Reyes
"10/10! Had the best eggs of my life here. I'm not much of a breakfast person usually, my partner is the breakfast food lover. But WOW this place is..."
Hannah Banana
"This place has an ultra-woke, anti-gun, anti-conservative people vibe to it, but they make up for it with the charming atmosphere, good food, and..."
Greg Eakins
"An adorable and cozy brunch place in the heart of Broad Ripple. We had an awesome waitress who gave the most hospitable and welcoming experience. The..."
Christine W
"The service was fantastic. They had a fair amount of vegan options, and everyone in the family found something they were happy with. I got to take a..."
Eric Christenson
"This is a cozy house turned restaurant cafe with good breakfast options. The coffee is really good. The special that morning was avocado toast. The..."
Prasad Nair
"My wife and I decided to try something now and found ourselves at this quaint restaurant. We were greeted by a friendly staff member who promptly..."
Wes Weber
"Have been going to 3 sisters since they were in their old building down the street. Loved the little home they used to be in. The new building adds..."
Vikramjit Rai
"Service was impeccable, food was some of the best breakfast I've ever had, and the atmosphere is perfect. We got the Beer Biscuit with black bean..."
Anthony Williams
"Fantastic place to eat. Very eclectic and unique. Parking was a little tricky but it was well worth it. Especially since you're so close to shopping..."
Maizie Steinsberger
"A nice brunch place with many meals to offer. The food was delicious. The service was great. The pricing is fair and the meal was big (even better!)...."
Widya Ukkas
"Absolutely wonderful place to grab breakfast and brunch!! Their food is delicious, the servers are kind, and the atmosphere is cute and unique. The..."
Kyra Segraves
"This food was delicious! A bit of a wait...but the food is great quality. Be sure to get the power breakfast potatoes over the regular hash browns...."
Kesha Williams
"Quaint and cozy, friendly staff, reasonably priced. Our food was delicious! We will definitely be back. I am sorry to point this out but we went late..."
Michelle Alvarez
"Amazing food, we got the omelette, French toast, monsterous pancakes and the breakfast burrito. Tasted great with some..."
Kevin Best
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use