Great pizza! One of the best pizza by the slice places I’ve been to. The ingredients were very fresh and the dough was really good. We had the pepperoni breadsticks, I felt like there wasn’t enough pepperoni to bread ratio, but the bread was so good, it didn’t matter.
Pictured is: cheese pizza, pepperoni breadsticks, and the Hawaiian pizza.
I have been going here since this place opened up years ago. Hands down the best New York style pizza in Indiana. Maybe the entire Midwest. Owner is a fantastic stand up guy and loves his business. I can't recommend this place enough. I do wish they sold shirts here. Brooklyn style pizza is my favorite pizza here (chicken bacon ranch), and you HAVE to try their knuckles out!! Believe the hype people! Make the trip and stop by. You won't regret it!
This is our first time back since they reopened. Very nicely done renovation. Our server was very friendly and attentive. The Garlic Knuckles are like we remembered them. Crispy and golden brown on the outside, soft and chewy on the inside, and coated in a garlic butter sauce that is warm, creamy and chock full of garlic. Delicious. My son loved the Pepperoni Pizza. Each and every bite was chock full of tomato sauce, stretchy mozzarella cheese and crispy pepperoni slices. I loved the Garden State Parkway Pizza. It is chock full of the chunky and flavorful Grandma sauce, stretchy mozzarella cheese and fresh basil. I loved it as well. One downfall was the puffy crust. It made the pizza doughier, and it felt like I was eating more crust and dough than toppings. The second negative I saw was a crust, primarily at the tip, where the dough was soggy and wasn't holding up to the toppings. These are good pizzas, but they do not live up to the NY Style Pizza thin crust.
Excellent pizza and garlic knuckles to die for. Wings didn't look crispy, but were very good. Salads are huge.
So good. Even the dough was delicious on its own. Worth a visit for sure. We have so much leftover.
Love the atmosphere here! Grandma’s pie pizza is the absolute best. Our server Monica was also super on it, made our experience dining it so much better!
Had an excellent experience with service, and I absolutely love the pizza!
Always a great spot for NY style pizza. Food is amazing no matter what you get. The restaurant had a face lift which many loyalists were wondering if they would ever reopen...well they did and still don't disappoint! Atmosphere is nice and clean with a NY vibe. Little pricey, but you do get what you pay for here, quality is excellent.
Great service, good pizza and a fabulous dining room. We enjoyed our 16-inch half Brooklyn and half Riverside Drive. They also served us complimentary (smaller) slices of a Garden State Parkway pizza and it was delicious! So glad we tried this restaurant today. I recommend Brozinni's Pizza.
Great service, great atmosphere, and outstanding pizza. Be warned, everything is huge. The stuffed breadsticks are like mini baseball bats filled with heavenly delights! We also had the Maiden. It was there version of Hawaiian. Sliced Boars head ham, bacon, and pineapple. Absolutely delicious as well!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Indianapolis
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes