Sluurpy
Reset

There are 3 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best New York Style Pizza in Hilton Head

There are 3 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Fat Baby's Pizza & Subs
90/100 (3025 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Bar
Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
American
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Drinks
Sandwiches
Roast Beef
Alfredo
Meatballs
Lasagne
French Dip
Hoagie
New York Style Pizza
Cakes
Pasta
Bruschette
Salad
Pesto
Wings
Margherita Pizza
Sit down
American
Bar
Pizza
Italian
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Seating
Accepts American Express
Table Service
Accepts Discover
Wheelchair Accessible
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Good pizza, good service and cold beer. Need I say more...ok I will. Great casual place to grab some NY style pizza after a hot day out at the beach...."
Lindsey Anthony
"There are certain things people do before running a half marathon, and one of those things is to carbo load the night before. We were preparing for..."
The Hungry Sprout
"Most incredible pizza, ever! We ordered the pepperoni, garlic, and basil pizza. Had enough to take back to our condo and devoured the rest..."
Stephenie Griffith
"Finally!!! I found a pizza on this island that I actually want to eat. The Py Pie is spot on for flavor and crust quality. Fresh garlic and basil..."
Josh
"I'd have to say that this was what I was looking forward to most on the island. The pizza is some of the best anywhere, and the subs are loaded with..."
Jiries Dawaher
"Had a margharita pizza and a sausage pizza tonight. Really good. Thin crust, not too crispy. Right amount of sauce. Great taste. Wicked..."
Mark
"Good Pizza. Tried several pizza's while in the area and this was our favorite. Super nice staff and great..."
Matt Lucas
"We got the pms pizza and garlic cheesy bread and enjoyed it! The sausage is huge slices which was delicious. Pizza was really greesy but that's to be..."
Sarah Thoma
"The spinach and shroom slice was great. A couple beers and good company from Dave, the maker if my..."
Rachael
"A real surprise!. This was a great pizza. We ordered the PMS pizza and it was awesome! Will definitely come here..."
Steve Edrington
"A consistently good pie with high-quality fresh..."
Leo Shock
"Great calzones! Wish we loved in town, we would eat here all the time. Dave is great..."
MST0308
"Awesome pizza! Reminds me of the pizza place I love at the beach in Maryland! Perfect for lunch at the beach! Greek salad and dressing was..."
Rebecca Ramia
"Yummy!. One of the best pizzas on the island and beyond. Caesar salad is great too! The dining room is a little toasty, that would be my only..."
Hhipets
"Great pizza and subs. Zero atmosphere! Friendly staff! A hidden pizza..."
Tobermori
"FABULOUS!!!. Can't get enough of the Caesar salad, lasagna, pizza, and soooo much more!!! LOVE this place! An islander's favorite!! Don't miss..."
Anne
"Besides their delicious pizza, we can never dine there without also having their delicious greek salad and mouth-watering toasted Fat Babies..."
ChampagneToast
"This place was good but not great. We really enjoyed the pizza. The garlic cheese bread was over cooked and average tasting. My younger so ordered..."
Michelle
"Best Pizza/subs in HHI. Fat Babies has quickly become a favorite spot to meet up with friends and share a pizza. The crust is so excellent in fact..."
Andy
"Great subs. Very good bbq chicken calzone. The cheesecake cupcake desert is to die for. Will eat there..."
Muadib395
"Loved, loved, loved the pizza. Extra cheese was actually extra cheese. Definitely will visit when I'm in the area again. The service was great and..."
Kathy Parker
"We didn’t eat in so can’t really rate the atmosphere but the pizza and mozzarella “balls” we really good. The mozzarella tasted homemade and..."
Wesley White
"We came here because one of our friends referred us. We are from Kansas City and when we walked in around 2 PM nobody was in the place except for 2..."
Steven Foster
"We had a short wait for a table, but our server, Amanda was very good. She was quick to greet us, bring our drinks, and put in our order. She was..."
Kristina Villella
"We struggled with finding a place for dinner as we have had lackluster meals on vacation. We finally settled here because pizza sounded good and the..."
Lindsay Bernardi
"Their brushettas are phenomenal! We also tried the subs, chicken strips and pastas - all were..."
Brandi McSheffrey
"Great spot for the whole family. In Hilton Head for the weekend and came for dinner with our two littles and my parents. My husband said his burger..."
Emily MacFarlane
"Winter visitors to the island and we always like to try a new pizza place. Had the Fat Baby dining in and it was delicious. Very flavourful and super..."
Ron Hebert
"Tried the "Fat Baby" sub and a 14" pie with sausage and mushrooms. The food was great with the minor exception that the crust was a little bit..."
Matthew Williams
"The best pizza and salads on Hilton Head! The meatballs are amazing too! Service was top notch! We always go here on our trips to Hilton..."
Kelly Moseley
New York City Pizza
79/100 (1186 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
American
Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
Bar
Pizza
American
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Calamares
Cheesesteak
Meatballs
Lasagne
New York Style Pizza
Pesto
Eggplant
Pasta
Salad
Wings
Calamari
Sit down
Italian
American
Bar
Pizza
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Free Wifi
Takeout
Accepts Credit Cards
Television
Delivery
Seating
Table Service
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"We have tried a variety of pizza restaurants on the island and have found that New York City Pizza is the best around and the most consistent. Having..."
Tory M
"Not sure about the recent reviews, but don’t listen to them! Dominick provided wonderful service and great conversation while we dined in. We had..."
Annette White
"Food is great. Atmosphere is okay but I ordered online 30 minutes prior to arrival and waited another 45 minutes after I arrived for two pizzas. ..."
Allan Wilayto
"Pizza was very good and actually New York style. Skip the " Smash Burger", not very good. Meatball sandwich was outstanding. Very good, friendly..."
Mike Colie
"New York City Pizza never disappoints. Whether we are ordering pizza, wings, subs or one of its fabulous dinner entrees, we know we will be having a..."
Leslie Gromis Baker
"I had been craving Pizza for the prior 2 days, and had already purchased food when I noticed this restaurant on the way back to the truck. Yes, I..."
Laura Lockhart
"This place is amazing!! The waiter was a sweetheart and chatted with us about different types of pasta and how they go with different wines! Did not..."
Samuel Ouellet
"YO THIS PLACE WAS BOMB. We're on vacation in Hilton Head from Florida and I have to say this is the best pizza I have had in many many a year. Great..."
Jessica Atanasova (Hitokiri NekoHime)
"This pizza did not disappoint! It smells delicious and tastes even better! The staff here were great too. I couldn’t recommend NYCP highly enough -..."
William Austin
"My kids love going there on weekends, they have nice staff members and amazing pizza! We were able to relax, and spend some quality time enjoying..."
Jim Henson
New York City Pizza
70/100 (1469 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
American
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Bar
Pub
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Drinks
Salad
New York Style Pizza
Pizza
Italian
American
Bar
Pub
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Drinks
Mid-range
"The food pizza and some Italian dishes the best - but more importantly you will feel like Norm on “Cheers” the entire staff so friendly fun..."
Mike Hayes
"We celebrated my daughter’s birthday here tonight with the family. I delivered a tres leches birthday cake there this morning and they provided the..."
Jill Schrott
"It’s the only place around here that I’ll order Eggplant Parmesan . (My family included)So delicious!! Never had a dinner or pizza that wasn’t..."
Nancy Coppa Bare
"This was our first visit. This place is awesome! Great Pizza and service! We had Doreene as our waitress! She was super friendly! We will be..."
Moti Cohen
"Doreene is the best. She was so nice and sweet! The service was good and also the pizza � I will be back just because off Doreene she was amazing..."
Shir Goldhammer
"Waitress was AWESOME.... Pizza was GREAT and dough homemade! Probably best pizza on the island. Thank you..."
Andrea Andie Dick
"Great place to eat with very friendly Staff & Pizza was..."
Jeannean Chesser Heber
"My fiance and I have been there 5 times. All 5 times we had great food and great service! We are going to be..."
Michael Smith
"We walked in as a table of 5 about 40 minutes from closing. We asked if they could seat us and did without hestitaion. The staff was very friendly..."
Brittany Geraty
"My wife and I have tried MANY pizzas over many years and we both feel that NYC Pizza is among the best. We eat this pizza every year on our annual..."
Larry Vannozzi
"I thought the food was pretty good despite the reviews. Not amazing, but..."
Bre Ianniello
"It's good and a really nice drink selection. Ask for extra crispy, the NYC style was a little soggy in the middle. I would definitely come back. Our..."
Stephen Tuohy
"Came to HH for vacation. My wife was determined to have NYC-style pizza. Went with this place. Pizza was really good in the end, but a premium was..."
Joshua Talley
"The pizza is delicious! The more toppings you get, the harder to eat as they are left in big chunks is my only complaint but others might enjoy that...."
Rachel Jasper
"We visit HH every year and New York City Pizza is our first, but not only, stop. Love the pizza, soups and salads. You won’t be..."
Pat Miller
"We have been coming to this location since our honeymoon in Hilton Head in 2006! The food is always spot on. Very dependable and very consistent! ..."
Steven Baumrind
"Pizza was amazing. Heart burn was worth it. Feeling bad about myself (for eating an entire Supreme pizza ((alone in my hotel room))) was..."
Chad
"New York City Pizza Hilton Head Island Good variety of options. Bar on site Good amount of space for dine in. Close to Coligny Beach. Located right..."
N S Prasad
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use