Crystal McCausland
I am an annual visitor to Hilton Head and have come to Wise Guys a few times in the past. Tonight our party enjoyed items off the specialty menu which were recommended to us by our server Tanner. We enjoyed the Beef Wellington and Wagyu New York Strip both were incredible. Our server Tanner was extremely knowledgeable on the menu items giving recommendations and explaining everything included in the items in great detail. Tanner never rushed us and gave us plenty of time to review the menu and enjoy our evening. What a great night!
Veronica Smith
OMG...better than I could have ever imagined! We were celebrating my husband's birthday, so I wanted a special place. The reviews were great, so I made reservations. We were about 20 -30 minutes early, but they were able to still seat us immediately! We had a large party, 14; they sat us in a private room! Not at all what I expected, but definitely a nice surprise. The room, oh the room...had a nice atmosphere and we did not have to worry about disturbing others with such a large group, with small children. The servers were attentive to our needs and the food came in a timely manner. The portion sizes were decent compared to the prices and no one complained about taste! We had a great time in our own little space with family, food, drinks, laughter, and conversation! A definite add to our list of go to restaurants. Stop reading andake your reservation.
Saahil Panikar
This restaurant is such a hidden gem! I wasn't expecting to find such a cozy steakhouse on the island.
All of the food was absolutely delicious. We tried Carpaccio, Fried Burrata, Duck Egg Rolls, Short Rib Lasagna, Short Rib Dinner, Gyro Pizza, Asiago Gnocchi, Swordfish, and bread pudding.
We took the bread pudding to go, and it was still delicious a few hours later. I bet it would have been perfect served warm at the restaurant.
My only nitpick about this place is that for the price point and the atmosphere, they didn't meet expectations about service. Our server was incredibly friendly and helpful about the menu, but didn't refill our water, never cleared dirty plates (by the time we got our entrees we had a stack of dirty bread and appetizer plates just sitting in the center of the table taking up space) and they gave us cheap styrofoam to-go containers that they just dropped off at the table when we asked to have our food packed.
Claus Dieners
Food and wait staff was excellent! Steak was fantastic! This was not our first visit and won't be our last. Only complaint was the attitude of the hostess! When we arrived here statement was "what are you here for?". When we responded that we were there for dinner she rudely said do you have a reservation which we did have! For some reason she actually seemed disappointed that we indeed had a reservation!
Pamela Pena
Limoncello martini citrus and sweet. The meatloaf gravy was one of the best! Mashed potatoes? Buttery deliciousness. We also has the lasagna, which was really good but not my fave. Now for dessert…save your appetite for the largest portion of bread pudding with ice cream. The server Cecilia explained things kindly and gave us our space for convo but always ready to check in. Can’t wait to come back and try their steaks.
Patsy Hosterman
The experience was amazing all the way around! DJ our waiter was knowledgeable, friendly, and had great recommendations! The food was amazing! Full of flavor! The drinks were delicious and strong! The restaurant itself was beautiful and the vibe was perfect for our vacation! This was the best food we had on the whole trip! Will definitely be back!
Michael Reilly
Update November 2023: Still amazing food. Still amazing service. Still our go to for a really fine experience.
First things first. Our server Michael was exceptional. He was attentive, funny, and had a great personality. He really made the whole evening better. The rest of the staff that helped us we very friendly as well.
The food is excellent. My table had the meatloaf (flavorful and melts in your mouth), braised short ribs (tender comfort food), Delmonico (can't go wrong with steak), and stuffed chicken (loads of flavor, very tender). Everything was amazing, came out hot, and had so much flavor.
Prices for the the quality and quantity of food are fair for HHI and I would absolutely make this a go to restaurant when we're on the island.
The atmosphere is modern and the decor is well done. The restaurant is a little dark but certainly not too much so. A nice overall place to be.
This is a must try (multiple times) if you're in the area. The worst part is trying to decide what to get on the menu. So many great options.
Mark Sincavage
My first time at Wiseguys was this past Friday night. I went here with some friends after a local event. I have heard so many people rave about this place and always wanted to try it. It did not disappoint. The food was excellent and our waitress was very attentive and friendly. We are already looking forward to returning to try more dishes from the menu. In addition, we had a couple of their specialty cocktails which were really enjoyable too.
Jayne Clamp
We ate here on Monday night while visiting the island over Memorial Day weekend. We sat outside in a cozy environment and our waitress was warm and friendly.
We LOVED the food here. The shrimp & crab wonton appetizer was amazing and the muscle appetizer was also delicious. The steak entree was great, but holy cow, the potatoes that came with it - which arrived in a mini cast iron dish - was our favorite part of the meal. To be fair, I've never met a potato dish I haven't liked, but this one was by far one of my favorite potato side dishes ever! So good. The creme brulee flight was also one of my favorite desserts in a long time!
Along with our waitress, we also spoke with a friendly bus boy and manager so our overall impression of the staff was that everyone was warm and professional. Definitely recommend this restaurant!
Sheshe1 Sheshe43
This place was amazing. Recommend that you make a reservation. The lemon drop was so good. Small plate: lobster rangoon, I got the salmon with shrimp and vegetable farro and, he got the meatloaf with green beans and mashed potatoes. They also bring you bread with olive oil and mashed tomatoes. We got the creme brulee flight. This meal was so amazing and the atmosphere was awesome.
Danny Schupbach
Let me start off by saying that all the food was more than excellent and the service, even better. Our waiter was amazing. He explained everything including the tomato basil purée, which was so good. The steak was cooked to perfection. The seafood my wife had was the best we had ever. Highly recommend this place as the best food on the island. Thank you!!
Abby McGahee
Amazing experience with great food and service. My husband and I dined here for our anniversary this week. We may have been the youngest people taking advantage of the early bird special menu but it was worth it. Perfect portion for an early dinner! I love the filet and crab together! Also be sure to try the flour less chocolate dessert! Yummy!
Dawn Rightler Loaiza
Great atmosphere and service was excellent. Our waiter was especially friendly and attentive. The French Onion Soup was some of the best I've had. We highly recommend this restaurant.
Melissa A. Arnold Podolak
We really enjoyed Wise Guys, and our server, Sam, was great! My fillet mignon was cooked perfectly. My husband's steak was slightly overdone, but they were so nice to comp a dessert even though we did not return the steak. The drinks were delicious, too. I recommend.
Melissa Seebs
Everything was on point. Martinis were fantastic. Delmonico steak was cooked perfectly. Our server Harold was very helpful and knowledgeable.
Gerald Bell
Most people who visit HHI will tell you that Wise Guys is among their favorite restaurants. I now consider myself one of those people. The bar drinks are great and really superior. The steaks are aged and well appointed. The service is first rate. The place is just very welcoming and one leaves with a great feeling of just having a great dinner.
Gene Rascle
Wonderful dinner and wine. Danny is a great waiter. Excellent recommendations. Tuna special and seared scallops. The wine flights were worth it too.
Christie Hunt
I had the shrimp, calamari and scallops. It was so delicious. The sauce was creamy, slightly sweet and slightly spicy. The calamari was cooked perfectly. The coating was crispy, even coated in the sauce. My husband and I ate the leftovers later the same night and it was also delicious cold. This was my best meal of our week long vacation. I will be bragging about this meal for a while.
My husband ordered the sirloin. He said it was the best steak of our trip; however, it was a little over cooked for his preference.
Melissa was an awesome server. It was a Friday night and they were super busy. I could easily see that Melissa was busy, but you wouldn't know by the attention she gave.
Brian Natale
One of the best bars on the island. The staff is 5 star. Wine selection is great.
Tonya M Hurst Simonsen
Taylor and I came in for the filet and salmon. We were not disappointed. The food was fabulous and the service was awesome. Make sure you ask for Ashley, the best server! Always a great night when I get to enjoy it with my son!
Scott A. Starr
Amazing service!! Amazing atmosphere ! Amazing staff up front, servers and chefs. Had such a good time with such great food. M
Steaks were cooked to perfection, fish was perfect, had the best Scallops in a few years!
Bruno Pursche
Great food by far the best server I've had on the island
Nancy Zevola Torborg
Not as upscale as it wants to be. Loud, but nicely decorated. Had to wait at the bar for 30 minutes after our reservation time. Baked Brie small
Plate was magical! Filet dry and salty on the outside and the mashed potatoes were runny. A mixed experience.
Mitch Ulrich
Amazing menu, our entrees were delicious. We enjoyed the ambiance immensely, but what made this a 5 star dining experience was our server Cecelia. She was a consummate professional with a wonderful personality.
Katie Lang
Great wine selection, great food choices & the staff was very attentive. If I’m ever on Hilton Head Island again I will definitely visit!
Lisa Morgan Kirkpatrick
The food is wonderful, my filet was one of the best I've had. The atmosphere was so nice. And our service was outstanding. Definitely recommend to anyone in Hilton Head!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes