Been here since 1989, always had Mario’s before and was pretty good 8.5/10. Discovered this place by word of mouth. Even though it’s 10-15 mins drive away and cost a bit more than other pizzerias, the quality speaks for itself. The toppings are double amount on Raimo’s Special vs other pizzeria special pies. Sauce isn’t too sweet and seasoned very well. Right amount of cheese. The crust has a nice flavor. First time we had the special, the crust was a bit under cooked, second time it’s cooked perfectly. We will be regulars here.
I grew up in this neighborhood back in the 70’s and 80’s. Raimo’s pizza every Friday was a treat that I have fond memories. It was awesome then and it remains awesome now! The grandma’s Sicilian was so delicious and the white slice (ricotta and mozzarella) equally fantastic….so much cheese!
I wonder if the original family still owns this business. It continues to be one of my favorite pizza places!
This place was AMAZING!! From the food to the service everything was Grade A+! We will definitely be coming back here again!!
The food was AMAZING!!!! So flavorful and delicious!! The service was great and Bobby treated us like family! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!
Maryann B (Bluemidget)
+5
Delicious! Worth trying people! The aroma of rhe fresh sause smell fills the air as you walk in The food cooked fresh
Clean and well kept Accommodating friendly
I’m 5 mins from Marios, Phils and every pizza shop you can name on jericho turnpike or the surrounding area. But my family and I make the drive down South Oyster Bay road for Raimo’s. Their large pie is a true 18”, not a fake large 16” like everyone else. Their pizza is the most cheese filled pizza I’ve ever had in my entire life. Sauce is perfect with a bit of sweetness. Crust is dead on. But its all about the massive amount of cheese they drop on their pies. I’m originally from Queens and their pie ranks up there with Amore’s in terms of the GOAT pizzas. If you’re reading this, Raimo, never change. You have the best pie on the Island and lets keep it that way.
Tropical Smoothie Cafe Hicksville
+5
Raimo's Hicksville Sicilian and grandma pizza beats everyone in Long Island. I don't care what others say, their fracchia bread is the best period. Honest opinion, not a fan of their chicken marsala but their chicken francese is once again the best in Long Island. All my employees love their sicilians. Give them a try and you won't be disappointed.
I have been going here since the place first opened back in 1976 or 77 I think. I was around 14 then. The owner, Sal, always was consistant with the recipe. Always great service & great pizza. I live out of town & always stop for a couple of slices when I am in the area. My last visit I realized there is new owners. I guess Sal packed it in after over 40 years, good for him. The pizza was still the same. Beautiful. I hope the new owners will keep it up with good pizza & service. Sal built a wonderful business, keep it going..... Best of luck...
Very pleasant staff. Delicious food. Been a staple in Hicksville for over 20 years. I believe these are new owners sometime over the last 5 to 10 years but still the same. Great tradition. Nice variety of pizzas and great chicken rolls.
I have been going there for many years, since high school. The ownership may have changed, but the food remains fresh and delicious.
It is a happy and casual busling place.
I attended w 4 friends.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Hicksville
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes