So good!!! The caprese sandwich was delightful and the balsamic sauce to dip it in is genius!
Oh and that cookie!!! So good and a nice little great that comes with your sandwich! The shop is small and cozy and happy employees. We will hit this place up every time we are in Hailey!
My husband and I were delighted to find this Cafe. We sat on the back patio and enjoyed delicious sandwiches made with great salami, ripe tomatoes, rich, green lettuce, and a homemade vinegrette dressing worth buying to-go. In the spring, the patio, with its potted plants and umbrella tables, is the perfect respite.
I think the turkey ceasar was up there in the best salads I've ever had. The lettuce was fresh but it was really the shredded turkey that I thought was amazing. I think I will come back tomorrow and get the exact same order.
Food this Gem searching for food options while visiting in Hailey, Idaho. The owner is from Jersey and so am I. She and her staff were very nice and hospitable.
I had a hot pastrami with American cheese. It was great and reminded me of Jersey. I will definitely be back when I'm in town and I highly recommend this place.
Jersey Girl you kill me, every time, breakfast and lunch is a torture of too many good choices. By now I have had them all and they have never been less than fantastic. You can taste the love in this food. I cheat every now and then and hit Shorty's across the street. But I aways come back to the Girl.
When my wife discovered a place with pork roll here in the west she had to stop and give it a try. She loved the jersey girl sandwhich and said the pork roll holds up against a sandwich in Jersey. I got the meatball sub. I was hesitant because my mother-in-law's meatballs are so good and most restaurants do not make theirs homemade. This was not the case! The meatballs were delicious and and the sauce also tasted like it was made in-house. All in all, a great lunch after our weekend backpacking in the Sawtooths!
Why did I wait so long to try this place? I had the Bacado and it was perfect. The shredded deli Turkey, crispy bacon bits, creamy Mayo, avo, and that hoagie roll was the best I’ve ever had. The patio is open and it was perfect, too!
Very tasty sandwiches and three outdoor tables.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Hailey
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes