I've come here at least 2 times a month since 2012. From 2012 and on, the food has only gotten better. The atmosphere changed for the better since then with a much needed fresh coat of paint. Great pizza, great food for kids (chicken tenders), and great garlic knots. Great service to top it all off. The 5 stars are well deserved.
This is a wonderful low key place that makes an awesome pizza. We ordered an 18” plain pie. It was wonderful using nice fresh tomato and a quality mozzarella that blended together just the way pizza is supposed to. The crust was a little thicker than a traditional NY pizza making it slightly different experience. The staff was friendly and very helpful. The next time we are out in Greenport we will definitely stop again.
Traveling Motor Coach Gourmets
+4
We are the traveling Motor Coach Gourmets. We frequent restaurants in many different cities and review them. Our ratings are as fair as we can make them as our reviews and yours can also impact a business owner. If we can’t give a 4 or 5 star review, or we don’t care for the service or food, we hold our review and give the place in question a 2nd and 3rd try. If after that, still not to our liking, then we rate the establishment.
We were looking for another pizza joint but couldn’t find it so we ended up at Emilio’s. We ordered a round pizza with pepperoni and sausage.
The pie came to us in a reasonable amount of time. It was hot and fresh. Overall a decent pizza but certainly not a Brooklyn pizza. It was kind of a let-down for NY pizza. But hey, this is Long Island so I wasn’t expecting much. The crust was sort of limp. I’m from Brooklyn but reside in Florida and it reminded me of a typical Florida pizza.
I wouldn’t come back but it’s not bad if your expectations aren’t all that high. If you’re from Brooklyn, it’s a big let-down. If you’re from Long Island or Tennessee, then it’s probably good pizza. Enjoy.
Nice lovely outdoor patio with picnic tables for big groups pizza was delicious and the garlic knots was off the hook!
Wonderful place and great pizza! We love Greenport and passed Emilio´s many times before finally going in last summer and we were missing out! Great pizza and we also love the Pasta with Spinach and Baked Clams. Calm, relaxing ambiance that I highly recommend. Bravo!
We just had a great meal at Emilio's! The four of us ordered wine and a large pizza. The place is clean and the food is excellent. The pizza crust was light and crispy, just the way I like it. Pizza slices are huge. The service was very attentive. I recommend Emilios highly.
We come here with our muscle cars plenty of parking. The town is very welcoming of Muscle cars and exotics. Emilio’s owners are huge mustang enthusiasts as well as foreign cars and appreciate the sound of big power! Food is first class and Service is always on point!! Make sure to get the home made cannolis and espresso !!
Average pizzeria, decent tasting pizza with pasta dishes and heros. Very clean, separate dining room apart from common self seating pizza area. One of the places open early enough in Greenport to satisfy an early afternoon hunger pang during the week. The patron of the establishment is a friendly fellow and helps the place gain a star with his positive attitude.
Love the beautiful renovation!!!! Outrageous Italian food and great original pizza- the crust is to die for! It's one of those restaurants that you know you can always count on for a great meal whether its a quick slice of pizza or you want to sit down for dinner in the dining room. To my surprise this winter they RENOVATED the pizzaeria/restaurant not only internally but the outside of the restaurant as well and WOW! The restaurant looks unreal, absolutely beautiful!!!! The pictures need to be updated on here and the internet to show the gorgeous renovation! The outdoor stone patio is gorgeous to eat outside! They even have a Wine Bar attached to the restaurant! It's the cutest bar ever! Awesome music playing- the atomostphere is a MUST GO! They even offer Italian Prosecco! The owner was very accomodating and very personable- the staff is friendly and service is great! What are you waiting for? Grab your friends and check out this gem on main street!
Antoinette Merenda Carbone
+4
Service was excellent on the mid week visit in springtime. The lunch was very good and the cannoli freshly filled with a filling similar to what you would get in Sicily. Will go back to try their linguini with white clam sauce.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Greenport
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes