Polly's is adorable! The flavor burst ice cream is delicious and nostalgic, the Carmel corn is amazing, there's just not a bad thing on the menu. The staff is friendly and owner is sweet as can be; I'll definitely be making this a must see stop every time we come to town!
Amazing treats! This cute little shop is a MUST go-to if you are passing through Grand Lake! Staff is wonderful, and the ice cream is heavenly! Best sweet shop in the mountains by a long shot.
Yummy treat on a hot day in Grand Lake! I loved all the different sundae options. Huge variety of sweets and we found something for everyone! Our doggie especially loved the free doggie cone 🥰
Good ice cream and friendly service. Line gets a little long but for only two people working they move through fairly quickly. The Huckleberry ice cream is my personal favorite but the family enjoyed all of their selections (Cookie Dough, Cotton Candy, Coffee, Butter Pecan, Strawberry Cheescake) and an ice cream cookie sandwich.
It's super awesome that you can get a puppy ice cream cone on the house...
Our kiddo had her ice cream fall of the cone and they offered to give her a new one right away! Great customer service. And yummy ice cream.
Great ice cream and friendly people! They are always very accommodating of my nut allergy and never act like it’s any extra trouble. Also, they have malts, which are harder to find.
Enjoyable little ice cream shop. My family recommends the soft-serve with rainbow highlights. It's unique and memorable
Snow cones are good. A small was gigantic. The lemonade was ok. The staff is really nice. Small benches available to sit and enjoy. Very refreshing
Great little shop with a very well selection of ice cream. Cookies are to die for as well. Not small servings at all. Definitely worth it
Cute shop on the downtown strip. Grocery store ice cream literally from the freezer aisle, yet they do have lots of flavors.
We loved the ice cream here. Absolutely delicious and worth the stop!
Great variety of sweet treats and ice cream flavors. Ice cream is delicious !
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Grand Lake
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes