Nice little place with a baseball themed atmosphere! Staff is friendly and helpful with good service and personality! The food was delicious heard no complaints! Deserts were also delicious. Plenty of parking in the rear! Would come back here again when in the area.
We arrived at 12:25...lunch time. Got the last table in the house...a high top in the bar area. There were folk waiting out front for a table in the restaurant section as there is no "wait" area inside the building. Atmosphere was comfortable. Family-type place... comfortable for families with kids...as well as families with grandparents. Burgers. Haddock. Salads. "American" food. Dinners. Appetizers. Beers on tap. Nice menu. Reasonable prices. Good food...served piping hot...and quickly! A very nice surprise since all tables were full!
Bar atmosphere is a little stark. Restaurant offers a much "homier" decor. Didn't affect the quality of the food, though.
Personally, I love the way the name just sorta "rolls off your tongue" when you say it. Kinda makes you smile. Gettysburg Eddie's.
Nice restaurant in downtown Gettysburg. Friendly and attentive service made us feel right at home. The food was unique and delicious. The atmosphere was very cool. Highly recommend this restaurant.
This is the second time I have eaten here. I don't live in Gettysburg, so choosing to eat here twice instead of trying another new place says something. Both times I had an attentive waitress and was served great food. I was wowed by the Philly Cheese Steak, but not so much for the house Hero sandwich. It was still good though. The homemade gingerbread dessert was really unique. I liked it, but if you don't like fresh ginger don't try it. This is worth the stop if your in this area.
Fun place. Sat at the bar and ordered happy-hour drinks and dinner (had the crab cakes). Great food. Very friendly bartender. Felt like a local, homey place. Only 1 mile away from Gettysburg National Military park.
We loved the baseball theme! The restaurant stays true to the overall atmosphere and it’s very cozy and exciting. My boyfriend ordered a foot long hotdog and it was extravagant. The carrot cake was delicious and the cocktails were very good as well. The server was pretty busy with tables but ensured we were refilled and satisfied. I’d eat here again!
My teammates and I had a great lunch here, and the baseball memorabilia is fantastic. Food was really good, and the crab cakes were outstanding. Can't wait to go back!
Enjoyable place to have a lunch or dinner. Our group of six came here for lunch during a break in our tour of Gettysburg. We visited in early October, so we were seated immediately and had our order in about 15 minutes. Four of us had the Eddie's House Hero, which is packed with meat and very tasty. One had the Turkey Avocado Salad and the our last tourist had a custom made burger with fries. And two of us had their coffee, which is far and away better than your average restaurant coffee. The atmosphere was perfect and, Tracy, our hostess and waitress, was outstanding. We look forward to returning here the next time we visit Gettysburg (off-season, of course).
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Gettysburg
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes