Five Star Pizza
5001 NW 34th Blvd, 32605 - Gainesville
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
Updated on
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
62/100
Data Completeness
56/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
📷 Photos (6)
Photo 1 / 6
100%
Google Reviews
262
Google reviews
The thing I'll say off the bat is that I liked how fast the pizza was delivered. that was probably the only thing I liked though. I used a 1 topping pizza coupon on an extra cheese pizza. What I got was... Excessive. I worked for dominos for 4 years, and extra always meant 1.5x the usual amount. I am not sure how they cheesed a pizza with like 4 pounds of cheese and sent it out with so much it spread and filled a corner of the box. The cheese also just didn't taste good so it was overpowering. Even after cutting a bunch of it off the next day it was like twice as much as the crust. Just disappointed, and I know now that extra really means EXTRA at this place.
Read more
Google
Extremely greasy to where that’s all your tasting. Also don’t waste your time ordering the “chicken bites” for the price with the amount they give you doesn’t add up. There are better places to order from.
Google
I've just been here once, but the service was friendly and really fast, and the pizza was delicious. I wasn't expecting it to be as good as it was, having ordered at 11:30 pm. It was ready in about 15 minutes, and the crust had a nice chew without being too crispy or too soft. The tomato sauce tastes pretty similar to Domino's pizza sauce. There was a bit too much crust on this pie though.
Read more
Google
What can be said besides this is the best take out delivery pizza in town. It's somehow exactly what you imagine delivery pizza should be like, and I love it! This location has great employees, aleays pleasant and friendly. Thank you Five Star!
Google
Ok so the food is almost always piping hot and the last 2 orders took only 17 and 20 minutes to get to my doorstep. Just wow! Professional and friendly staff. We need more companies like 5 star pizza!
Google
They actually make the pizza the way you order it. The pizza tastes great and the wings last time I ordered were excellent. Used to order Piesanos regularly but the have lost a step.
Google
Really really great Buffalo Chicken Pizza and Garlic Rolls. Really quick and easy pickup. Nice, friendly staff.
Made it a few bites in and realized we had to shout out how tasty it all was.
Google
Pleasantly surprised I hadn’t had their pizza in an awful long time and it was really fresh! A decent was price. Fresh veggies. Big pizza, very tasty reheated well.good job guys
Google
Explore more in Gainesville
Recommended pages
Help improve this page: